Need something like American Elsewhere (Robert Bennett) and The Library at Mount Char (Scott Hawkins)

Title! I read both books above and thought they were excellent and super entertaining. I loved the fantasy elements, combined with the horror and comedy. I guess I'm looking for a blend of all three things!

No Neil Gaiman! I've read his stuff and enjoyed it in the past, but I'm no longer reading any of his stuff

Other books in this vein I've enjoyed:

• Piranesi
• Station 11
• Between Two Fires
• Geek Love
• Almost every short story by Kelly Link