Dunton hot springs vs brush creek ranch

Going just with my husband for a relatively quick trip this fall will plan to do some mountain biking fly fishing and relaxing.

Have looked at other lodges/ ranches but these are only two that have available on the weekend we want to go. Was leaning towards dunton and was going to hit telluride for a night or two on way in, but now I'm reading some mixed reviews! Would love any feedback from anyone who has been to either!