Help deciding between 2 keepers

I can keep George Pickens in the 6th or Tyler Warren in the 9th.

Im in a 10 man, Half ppr, home league, where TE and QB tend to go before ADP and we don’t know our draft position until right before the draft starts.

All summer I’ve mock drafted with Pickens as my keeper but I’ve slowly started to have second thoughts that maybe taking Warren is the play.

Is the answer just Pickens and stop overthinking it?