r/tallyhall•
ilya22950

WHATS HAPPENING WITH JOE??

Selling

I'll admit - I went down a bit of a rabbit hole and read through some older threads from 2019-2023. A lot of it seems speculative, and nothing has really been confirmed from official sources. I also came across mentions about the band's concerns regarding the frontman's mental health at the time, as well as that controversial Father's Day post that stirred up some discussion.

To be transparent, I haven't been actively following this specific subreddit over the last month. I only found out earlier today that the lead singer was officially removed from the group on August 7.

So here's my confusion: I feel like I've missed a huge chunk of context. Could anyone lay out the actual sequence of events leading up to that date? I'm genuinely struggling to piece it all together because the information seems scattered.

On a personal note - and I know this might be an unpopular opinion - I honestly think the band loses a big part of its identity without his voice. That's not me trying to justify anyone's actions; I just think a lot of people (myself included) originally connected with the band because of his specific style and presence.

I'm not here to pick sides or start arguments. I'd just really appreciate it if someone could fill in the blanks on the timeline. What actually happened, and when? Thanks in advance for keeping it civil.

Posted Aug 28, 2026, 7:44 AM UTC

05
Loading comments…