r/herbalism•
cranne

My firecider is suddenly carbonated

Question

I made this year's batch of firecider roughly 2 weeks ago.

Pretty standard recipe. Lemons, oranges, onions, ginger, garlic, peppers, tumeric, horseradish, and apple cider vinegar with the mother. I have not yet added honey.

Gave her a shake and a taste today and was shocked to find that she has carbonated.

My understanding is that firecider is closer to a pickle than a true fermentation which is why im so confused on how this happened. Ive never been able to carbonate a vinegar base before.

No weird smells or taste. Visually she looks fine. Shes just fizzy.

Do I need to toss it?

Posted Aug 29, 2026, 3:16 AM UTC

41
Loading comments…