Cigars are Binary to me

I don’t get the varying scores when it comes to cigars. All cigars fall into two categories for me.
Do I want to smoke another one or not.
For example today I smoked an Olivia MB3 and a Plasencia Reserva, both for the first time.
Olivia hit it out of the park and is going in the buy again bucket. This Plasencia did not and is going in the other bucket.
I think many things in life are overcomplicated in the same manner by people with to much time on their hands.
Any thoughts?