Would You Rather: Contract Hours Edition

Would you rather your contract hours be 6:45-2:45 (dismissal duty means you don’t actually leave until 3 every day and sometimes as late as 3:15) or your contract hours be 8:30-5:05 (you get to leave at 5:05 daily)

My best teaching friend and I always debate which one of us has worse hours, so we are curious what the masses think!