I get the feeling that Donna is entirely content with living in Fromville forever.

It feels like she's been there so long that she's become comfortable locking herself indoors while vicious, shape shifting monsters tap on the windows and occasional ripping a member of the town to pieces, just as long as she gets to stay in charge of a house full of degenerates. She always seems against any attempts to go home, and I understand that these attempts often lead to let downs or someone getting hurt or killed, but their choices are either find a way to go home or spend the rest of your life in a living nightmare.