Unstable SMP: If egg is a scholar.

SpoilerTheory

Massive spoilers of Unstable SMP lore

Sources

I explored Minecraft's forgotten dimension

I explored Minecraft farlands

I got hunted by Minecraft deadliest assassin

1000 players simulate underground civilization

Farlands arc

Fake Identity arc/skill vs power arc

I have made a theory for scholars way too many now this will probably be the final one.

Scholars

A group of players that was first mentioned on the farlands arc at that time was just a joke

And again on fake Identity arc

But mentioned again on law arc

And again on kingdoms arc

And finally the latest mention of them was in spoke latest video.

But today I'm not talking about scholars I have talked about them way too long

Instead I'm gonna talk about if egg was a scholar.

I'd recommend you to watch my previous 2 theories on scholars because that will give much better information about this post.

If egg was truly a scholar which at this time I'm 99% sure he is.

Does Wemmbu know about that? This question has been asked numerous times in this subreddit and even other social media.

And my answer to all of that is yes.

My proof?

Although there's really no proof of Wemmbu acknowledging the scholars we can piece evidence of previous mention of scholars to figure out if he knows or doesn't know.

First mention of scholars

More likely as a joke thrown by egg

Second mention of scholars

Fake Identity arc: "there's some debate among the scholars" that line already proves that egg might have been in this group a year before they were first shown physically in spoke latest video, but there's no Wemmbu there so the question is still left unanswered.

Third mention of scholars (One of the main ones)

I explored the Minecraft farlands: when Wemmbu, egg and jamato are walking in the farlands and jamato mention about a special portal egg said this line: yo bro do I need to report this to the scholars? And Wemmbu replied with: no keep the farlands stuff under wraps. That line alone meant that Wemmbu knew the existence of the scholars because he didn't react at all instead telling egg to not report them which if he doesn't know he would at least react and if eggchan is really hiding the truth behind Wemmbu back, he wouldn't mention that in the front of Wemmbu. Still not enough proof?

Fourth mention of scholars

I got hunted by Minecraft deadliest assassin: egg referred to himself as a legendary scholar and again Wemmbu didn't react at all. Not enough? Still think it's a joke? I'm not blaming you.

Fifth mention of scholars (one of the main ones)

1000 players simulate underground civilization : when Wemmbu finally got a chance to meet with egg we saw him writing a book and when Wemmbu took a look at that book the first page had a text as follows: Translated by eggchan, published by the unstable scholarly association.. and again he didn't react to it. Some would argue that was another joke because the book inside is just some Greek thing but why would there be that text then? And another weird thing Wemmbu didn't mention that book at all after taking a look it felt like he was trying to hide this secret as well.

Sixth mention of scholars (Spoke)

We are finally able to see the scholars physically they were a group of players writing everything on the server with that document saved in the place called citadel.

With all of this previous mention I can finally conclude this theory once and for all

egg is a scholar and Wemmbu knew that this also explains why the wraiths wanted him and why egg book is so important that he's scared of losing them.

But again the plot could change and it happened before, but as of right now Wemmbu knows about the scholars and maybe had been in citadel with egg you never know what happened of screen.

This concluded my theories on scholars.. maybe or I'm gonna make another one lol such an interesting group and I'm excited for them in the future.

He knows

He hid the truth

He's been in the underworld

He's purple

He's Wemmbu:)

Posted Sep 12, 2026, 2:25 AM UTC

53
Loading comments…