Personally I think he could've been fleshed out more since imo is probably the least nuanced protagonist of the HD universe, but in a way I feel like that's the point of his character. One of GTA's  biggest themes is the disillusionment of the American dream and on a personal scale, the disillusionment of your surroundings. In almost every GTA game there's always a moment in the story where the main character finally wakes up and realizes "why should I care about this anymore? Opportunity is out there, all I have to do is reach out and take it". Lost and damned in my view is a cautionary tale of what happens when a main character sees the world around him for what it is and chooses to do nothing about it. He gave his loyalty to the wrong people and he had no good support outside of his biker club, Niko had Roman who kept him grounded and Luis had Tony who showed him that the world was bigger than just his neighborhood. Who did Johnny have? Elizabeta? Playboy X? Ray Buccino? Thomas Stubbs!? Johnny never had a chance, the smart thing would've been to take control of the club completely before or just as Billy's coming back, or just leave all together and strike out on your own. But Johnny was loyal to a fault, loyal to his club, and loyal to his woman, and both got him and everything he loved killed. But what do you guys think, cuz I keep seeing this sentiment of Rockstar doing him dirty in GTA 5 but I thought it was a fitting end for a tragic character. He tried to be more but failed and chose to retreat into his archetype. He couldn't be more than who he was, so now he's a footnote in the history of a better, more memorable game. 

How did you guys feel about Johnny Kibbitz?