Porsche Pre-Paid vs Dealership vs Independent Maintenance plans?

Took delivery of 2026 Base a few days back. I want to check if the maintainer plan prices that are currently offered at my dealership is reasonable?

Porsche Maintenance Plan (1+4, 50k miles) - $7965 (attached to vin, no cancellation ever)

Dealership Maintenance Plan (1+4, 60k miles) - $4950 (fully refundable if unused; otherwise, prorated refund applied). Read through the fine prints it does cover every parts and labor as per Manufacturer recommendations and no cost cap. But, essentially locked to their service department.

I usually keep my cars 5-6 years. I have a few weeks to decide but not sure if going to independent shop would be better? Does anyone know if the dealership quotes are close to what Independent shops offer?

I am doing this for the first time all my myself. My dad, who used to take care of these things, has passed away.