Questions and ideas about hull types, evasion, strike craft and fleet compositions
There also was a new series of relatively recent tests and discussion about different ship layouts and how they perform in terms of per capacity effectiveness when facing mixed and mono fleets at different stages of a typical game.
I try to summarize what the general consensus is that vs AI fleets:
- Bigger hulls generally perform better per capacity, apparently because casualties are less granular and few bigger slots scaling better than many small ones for most layouts.
- Top performing mixed fleets exist, but they are typically 1 tier next to each other, for example cruisers + battleships but not corvettes + battleships.
- Strike craft are very strong, many of the best performing fleets incorporate them.
- Layout variety matters, for example cruisers bring G slots to the table, which opens up possibility for combinging them with battleships.
- Hull variety inherently matters less or is detrimental (see point 1 and 2), even though evasion seems strong on paper.
What interests me is the combination of the above with the background of evasion seemingly not providing much impact.
On paper it should make sense to mix hulls because big weapons are less efficient vs small hulls, so they should regularly miss or even overkill smaller targets.
We're looking at a lot of evasion on corvettes and quite decent evasion on destroyers. Intuitively there should be scenarios or compositions so these ship types serve a purpose in a mid to late game fleet.
I have a theory about this: What if the culprit is strike craft?
Hangar slots seem to generally perform very well and strike craft have very high tracking. It could be that smaller ships just get wrecked by mixed AI fleets because of strike craft?
We also know that if we have about 1.5 flak cannons per enemy hangar, their strike craft will effectively be shut down. But that needs to be a deliberate investment. Flak generally punch above their weight in terms of raw DPS as well if you get close enough, so it's not a dead investment if the opponent doesn't have a lot of hangars.
What if we deliberately add both flak and hangars in order to quickly take over the strike craft superiority. Are smaller, more evasive hulls more valuable in this scenario?
If the theory is correct then something like a generic battleship with a decent weapon setup plus hangars plus for example flak destroyers with a strong short range L weapon should do well in combination. Maybe even corvettes? The destroyers would quickly dispatch and contain strike craft and other smaller, high tracking ships. Then they basically add their evasion against most heavy weapons that the AI fields, which decreases their efficiency.
Does that make any sense or what am I missing?
Posted Sep 24, 2026, 1:46 PM UTC