Penny Yvonne Peeler, 37 — Missing from Enid, Oklahoma | April–May 1990 | Suspicious Disappearance | NamUs MP43329
Name: Penny Yvonne Peeler
Last Confirmed Contact: April 25, 1990
Reported Last Seen: May 3, 1990
Location: Enid/Carrier, Oklahoma; later locations disputed
Age When Missing: 37
Physical Description: White female, 5'6"–5'7", approximately 150 pounds, blonde hair, blue or hazel eyes
Case Type: Endangered Missing Person / Suspicious Disappearance
NamUs Number: MP43329
Penny last spoke with her mother on April 25 and disclosed that she was experiencing marital problems. She was never confirmed heard from again.
Her husband later gave differing accounts of where he last saw her during an out-of-state trip—either at an Albuquerque, New Mexico truck stop or a Sacramento, California bus station. That uncertainty creates a vast geographic gap and leaves May 3 as an unverified reported sighting rather than Penny’s final confirmed contact.
Which route was traveled, and do fuel receipts, lodging records, bus manifests, photographs, or witness statements survive? Could records from truck stops or bus terminals help determine whether Penny was ever present in either city? Even old family correspondence might clarify her intentions before the trip.
The Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation continues to list Penny as a suspicious-disappearance cold case, and NamUs still records her as missing. No publicly confirmed recovery or homicide charge has been announced.
Anyone with firsthand information should contact the Garfield County Sheriff’s Office or OSBI. Please avoid treating unverified accounts as established fact or publicly accusing uncharged individuals.
https://independentdetective.com/case-searches/penny-peeler/
Posted Sep 25, 2026, 11:01 PM UTC