I just finished book 6! Aside from a few minor things, I really enjoyed the first series and will try and pick up the 2nd!

Aside from the occasional cheesy dialogue, and not enough Ravenpaw, my only complaint is how they wrote out Tigerstar.

I'm not opposed to Tigerstar being killed by Scourge, I just think there should've been more buildup instead of just "BloodClan, attack!" "No lol." maybe if Tigerstar lost his other lives whilst trying to execute his plans to take over the forest (Trying to lead them to ThunderClan camp, around when Bluestar loses her last life, their battle with WindClan to show superiority, maybe even in a battle with RiverClan when convincing them to join. I highly doubt that either Leopardstar or Tigerstar would reach that agreement peacefully). But apart from those things I'm really enjoying these.