Help Me Choose a Convertible Car Seat - Target Trade In

I am overwhelmed by my options for convertible car seats. We currently have a Joie Mint Latch and have loved it. I like to do my research, but there are so many pros and cons to each seat. The ones that continue to stand out to me are Joie Saffron and Graco Extend2Fit.

More details:
I have a Subaru Outback
Our child is 12 months old and on the smaller side
We need affordability
Prefer easy installation & comfortable padding
I don’t need a rotating seat

I am open to any affordable recommendations!