My opinions on Overhaul, Stars Above, and Catalyst (am new)

Overhaul: 3.5/5. Bosses are great, Lore is great, quest system is great, but VERY unbalanced, especially with the legendary weapons. At least they're optional to use tho. Some visual aspects of the mod like domains can also detract from the boss fighting experience. Very much a mod you either hate or love.

Stars Above: 3.5/5 Probably my favorite weapons mod. Progression is smooth enough, bosses are really cool. However i really don't like using the Stellaglyph, and it's not the most fun to play alongside other mods that change a lot like overhaul.

Catalyst: 5/5 I know it doesn't add or change a ridiculous amount, but Astralgeldon is really fun and the mod fits into the regular progression so well i hardly notice it's there.