Honeymoon Recommendations?

Hi all,

We are looking for an all-inclusive in the Caribbean for around 5k flights included. We will have Hyatt points we can throw at the trip if it's a Hyatt property. Safety is my main priority, but of course we also want the most luxurious possible for the price range, SCUBA DIVING, good food, all the bells and whistles we can possibly get.

TIA!