Help troubleshooting Mumble?
My TF2 community is experiencing some strange issues with Mumble, so I wanted to tap into the extensive experience of the r/truetf2 community in this area.
The issue is apparently that some players will be unable to hear anyone when first joining a Mumble server until they press their PTT button. Some other users have said that if they stay silent for too long, the same thing will happen, and they'll need to press their PTT button to hear people again.
I've used Mumble for a while now, and I can't say that I've heard of this before. Does anyone have any experience with this? Is there a solution out there?
At the very least, we'd like to try to determine if this is a client or server problem, and any help we can get with this would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks,
Savage
^FirePowered ^Community ^Administrator
^Reddit ^((Personal Account)^) ^| ^Reddit ^((Official FirePowered Account)^) ^| ^Steam ^| ^FirePowered
Posted Feb 22, 2014, 9:13 PM UTC
see if forcing TCP mode makes a difference.
in mumble, click on Configure -> Settings
ensure Advanced is checked on the bottom of the Mumble Configuration panel
click on Network, then check "Force TCP mode". restart mumble.
Thanks for the tip, but it didn't seem to fix the issue.
:(
this could possibly be caused by half-open connections and/or improperly lengthened timeouts with their router's NAT table.
if only SOME users are experiencing it, i wouldn't be hasty to fault the server. ask them to also uncheck "Use Quality of Service" within the same configuration module i previously mentioned. for all possible checks, ensure TCP mode is constantly forced.
ask them to also disable any firewalls (windows or third-party, including possible router firewalls for the meantime -- if they do not know how to connect to their router, ask them to type "ipconfig /all" in the Command Prompt & locate their gateway, then type that IP in their browser. if they do not have the user/password for their router, skip the step for now).
there really aren't a whole lot of mumble options for them to manipulate when it comes to redundancy checks. outside of timeouts & other various packet manipulation schemes, ensure that mumble isn't taking exclusive control of their audio card (Configure -> Settings -> Audio Input & Audio Output -> Ensure Exclusive is unchecked below the System Interface.) turn off application attenuation for the meantime as well (under Audio Output, uncheck "white other users talk" and "while you talk" under the application attenuation slider.)
they could also manipulate their Output delay & Jitter buffer under Audio Output, but the real issue probably has to do with their NAT tables, and that'd probably be a bit too complicated & in-depth to fix for most affected users. the very least your affected users could do is attempt to replicate this issue on different servers just to quell your fears. if they can replicate it on other servers (and hopefully it affects them on all servers), then they will need to:
a. get into their router & try to locate NAT table information & timeouts. most consumer-grade routers/gateways will not allow users to manipulate their NAT table timeouts, but if they're tech-savvy enough, and if they are fortunate enough to have compatible Linksys/ASUS/Netgear/Buffalo routers, they can flash custom firmwares that give them enterprise-grade access (look into TomatoRAF and DD-WRT for more information.)
b. replace their router with a higher RAM, bigger NAT table, better NAT timeout model. i highly recommend the Hawking HAWNR3; it's the least cost-prohibitive, but attempt to narrow the issue down to the best of your abilities before recommending something like this.
if you have access to Murmur (the server-sided component of Mumble), you may find assistance here:
http://sourceforge.net/p/mumble/discussion/492607
peruse the Murmur.ini and see if anything strikes you odd. i'm not very knowledgeable about the server-sided aspect of Mumble, but i'll try to help you some more if you have any additional questions.
Thank you so much for spending so much time trying to help us. We seem to have found the solution on the Discussion board you linked us to (thread).
We really do appreciate your help though, and we'd like to offer you a week of donator privileges on our server. I know it's not much, but we wanted to recognize your effort in some way. Please PM me your SteamID so we can get that set up.
Thanks!
Savage