If one state rules gay marriage unconstitutional, why doesn't the verdict apply to all states?

Edit: Thank you Reddit for showing me my (sad) lack of basic understanding of U.S. government, but also for pointing me in the direction I need to go to learn more. Also, thank you for giving me my first 'real taste' of Reddit interaction. Normally, I scroll through logged out, but this is awesome. Sure, only 29 responses to my question, but I have bigger things to worry about and got exactly what I needed. Thank you for the help. I just feel the need to say Thank you so, Thank You.

                                                                        -------------

I know that I don't understand the entire legal system and nor will I ever, but can someone explain how such a ruling doesn't constitute a ruling over the entire United States?

I know there are some jurisdictions and legalese that contradict one another. For example, the new laws and provisions with regards to the recreational use of marijuana and it's classification according to Federal law. I have read some articles and journals on possible reasons why it's overlooked, but when it comes to rulings that classify human rights issues, such as gay marriage, as unconstitutional then how come if a few states can consider it as unconstitutional others aren't applied to the ruling? Doesn't the United States Constitution apply to all states within the United States of America?

If there is any information in regards to an oversight on my part with regards to my understanding of the system that I'm not understanding, please point me in the right direction.

Posted Mar 3, 2014, 5:40 AM UTC · edited

135
RandyJackson•

Only federal laws can apply to the entire country. Each state has their own set of laws as well as the over arching federal laws.

2
goefyou•

State laws can be declared unconstitutional on a national level by the Supreme Court such as brown v board of education setting the precedent that separate but equal is unconstitutional nationwide even though it was originally a state law

2
broadcastingstudentOP•

I recall the basic synoposis, for lack of a better word, of Brown v. Board of Education multiple times throughout my education. I will certainly re-examine it tomorrow during my three hours between classes. I know that it was a pivotal case, so thank you for bringing it back to my attention. I only wish I could go back to when it was first brought to my attention and understand it better.

1
goefyou•

Basically it was a collection of similar cases that the Supreme Court grouped together to hear at once. This is why I would assume of the Supreme Court ruled on gay marriage they would do something similar because of how many practically identical suits there currently are from multiple states.

The way I see it is if the fed is determined enough and it remains the popular opinion then gay marriage will be made legal and discriminating on the basis of sexuality will be made illegal. While what everyone is saying about the 10th amendment is true, I don't see it standing up against the "Equal Protection Clause" of the 14th amendment. But hey that's why people argue this in courts. In terms of progressive thinking gay rights is gaining supposed and has been for years. Everyone against it I just see on the wrong side of history and will go down in the books with the segregationists.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

So even though the United States Constitution is to govern the entire United States (from what I've been taught and can recall anyway), the states laws can override the federal? Although, in terms of the recent marijuana provisions, the states overrides the federal.

1
sunofabeeeyetch•

If the federal government decides to enforce federal law, it can do so regardless of whether or not it contradicts with state law. States can enforce their own laws only insofar as those laws don't directly contradict the Constitution or federal law; even if a state wishes to enforce its law, it's no longer able to do so if the feds intervene.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

So then, technically, even if the federal government (Supreme Court?) ruled it unconstitutional, it can decide whether or not each individual state law contradicts with the ruling?

1
[deleted]•

not quite. The federal government can't 'trump' state laws unless the constitution specifically outlines and provides that power over those laws for the federal government. Marriage isn't covered by the constitution, so it has always been left to the states..there are no federal laws regarding marriage. Each case for each state as it reaches the US Supreme Court has to be heard individually, as it isn't a collective matter.

The US Constitution's Tenth Amendment

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

The Tenth Amendment states the Constitution's principle of federalism by providing that powers not granted to the federal government by the Constitution, nor prohibited to the states, are reserved to the states or the people. The amendment provides no new powers or rights to the states, but rather preserves their authority in all matters not specifically granted to the federal government.

1
[deleted]•

No no...the Constitution is very broad, and there is NOTHING in the US Constitution that talks about marriage. anywhere. The states have always been responsible for marriage laws.

That makes this time in our constitutional history very interesting..because the Constitution does specifically say that any powers not specifically granted to the federal government stays with the states. So the states can make their laws about marriage and always have, especially since the Constitution says NOTHING about marriage.

The US federal government isn't 'in charge' of states. So the states can make their own laws. Now, any cases filed by individuals against their states for 'discrimination', have to make their way up the ladder till they reach the US Supreme Court. Once the US Supreme Court has a chance to hear the case, they can then make a decision if all of that law (for that state) is unconstitutional or only parts of it are. But they have to do that for every state, since...

...states have always made their own marriage laws, as the Constitution doesn't cover marriage laws.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

Interesting. I have found myself finding my way up (and learning) of the ladder since the end of 2012; at least, in my case in terms of unemployment. I didn't realize how many appellate opportunities there were and how the structure of the law actually worked. It has been an eye opener and I applaud the people who work for organizations like the EFF to defend our rights. I can't imagine how much work, energy and time goes into it. nonetheless, I am thankful. Also, thanks again for helping clarify this up for me.

1
babypumapounce•

Many would say the constitution applies to gay marriage in two places: the Equal Protection Clause and substantive due process, which guarantees fundamental rights like marriage. So it's misleading to say the constitution is silent on the issue. Technically, marriage is not mentioned. But these legal victories don't spring from thin air. We have a large body of judge made interpretation that in essence extends the constitution.

1
YouVersusTheSea•

Although, in terms of the recent marijuana provisions, the states overrides the federal.

Be careful with this! Just because marijuana is legal in one state, you can still get in trouble with the Federal Government for it, even if you're in a state whose State Government allows it. It's technically not completely legal even in places like Colorado because the Federal Agencies (like the DEA) can still prosecute you for it.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

So I have learned. With regards to the marijuana side of my post however, I am for it's medicinal use. When it comes to allowing users to escape the clutches of the pharmaceutical industry, I support it's purpose, effects and use. I do feel we have made significant progress as a whole, though. Even though there are still Federal Agencies that will prosecute, they are beginning to shift their views. It isn't by a fraction of what it's made out to be, but it is a long process that will eventual reach a new high and change everything.

1
drdeadringer•

Only federal laws

I hope you mean this also includes Supreme Court rulings?

1
gambiergump•

Marriage is a contract within a state. While most states recognize the contracts made in other states, each state deals with their own marriages separately.

Does that help?

2
broadcastingstudentOP•

In a way. I do understand that the states have the powers to recognize their own set of rules and laws (as in, again, the recent laws in regards to marijuana as both medical and recreational use), but doesn't/shouldn't the constitution have a 'final say' on what is ... well, Constitutional and superior to that of a states adoption of their own law?

1
[deleted]•

The Constitution is very broad on purpose, since it was drafted to keep most power in the states' hands. It distinctly says that any power not specifically granted to the US federal government, resides with the states. The US government does not automatically 'trump' states' laws. In other words, in many things, the US government is 'not the boss' of the states. (You aren't the boss of Me!) (Maine).

Now, if a specific case goes up through the court system, the US Supreme Court might get a chance to hear it and make a ruling. They can rule that certain parts of a state law is/are unconstitutional or that an entire law of a state is unconstitutional. But this doesn't happen automatically, and has to happen on an individual basis for each 'case, state and specific law' unless the Supreme Court rules ALL state laws governing same sex marriages are unconstitutional. And that hasn't happened.

Remember, the United States of America is a group of associated states which are by law, stronger than the federal government in many respects in regards to governing themselves. Before the Civil War, the States were even stronger...the USofA was a lot like Nato or the European Union. It was the Civil War that changed it into having a stronger central government. But the states still govern a lot about themselves individually.

TLDR: The US government doesn't automatically trump states and isn't 'in charge' of states, and each state is wording their laws differently, so it might take a while for the US Supreme Court to rule on all of them and see if there are unconstitutional parts or wholes of each states' individual laws.

2
broadcastingstudentOP•

Thanks for that. That did clarify, in simpler terms, a direction for me to start my studying in. The individual basis for each 'case, state and specific law' seems to be a huge deterrent to moving forward. Of course, with all the politics, money, and other agendas involved, is that why such things (not just the issue of gay marriage) haven't resulted in favour of the people? Thanks for giving me a direction to go and start to get my self in order. I suppose until I understand at least the fundamentals (which I should have been more keen too in school), I can't start advocating for the people I want to help; not just gay marriage, but far beyond. I'll never be a lawyer, policy maker, or political official, but I'll be damned if those who are take away our liberties. Thanks again.

1
babypumapounce•

Gay lawyer here. States ban gay marriage in their state constitution, in their state statutes, or sometimes both. Until recently, gay activists sued to overturn these laws under state law only. This was a strategic choice. On the one hand, it limited the impact to that state only. Activists hoped to build up momentum by winning gay marriage in a few states first. It also kept gay marriage from going to the U.S. Supreme Court before that court was ready, which risked the court setting bad precedent for the entire country. Only recently have we had many serious law suits under federal law (California, Utah, Oklahoma, Virginia, etc.) that have the potential to affect all the states.

2
goefyou•

It all depends on which court rules a law unconstitutional. State supreme courts only have jurisdiction over their state so if they rule something unconstitutional it doesn't affect any other states unless it is appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court and the Supreme Court agrees to hear the case. Then the decision of the Supreme Court can affect other states.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

That is a very valid point that I over looked. I do recall going through the WestLaw database at my school and seeing the options for multiple 'Circuit Courts'. So ultimately, if the Supreme Court rules a verdict, then it would affect the other states as well?

[Note to self: Review the court and governing system]

1
[deleted]•

Not necessarily. If the US Supreme court rules UTAH"s marriage law unconstitutional, that doesn't affect Nebraska's, unless someone files a suit against Nebraska and it goes to the US Supreme Court.

This is because marriage laws fall to the states, not the federal government. The federal government can't make a single law regarding marriage that applies to all states (because of the Constitution's 10th amendment) but it can rule individual states' laws unconstitutional.

1
goefyou•

While I'm pretty sure all of that is true I don't think it usually works like that in practice because on controversial topics usually there are multiple suits and the Supreme Court oftentimes groups them together to hear them at once such as Brown V board of education. I keep bringing Brown up because the whole segregation and marriage thing seem really similar to me. Also with regards to the fed not being able to make laws regarding marriage there are plenty of ways that politicians can get around this whether you consider is constitutional or not. For example, they can deny funding for other programs to states that ban gay marriage like they did with the drinking age or actually put language in tax bills ensuring gays get the tax benefits. Basically, I am no expert but they do things to bend the law and it would take a whole line of judges willing to put their reputation on the line declaring pro civil rights legislature unconstitutional

1
YouVersusTheSea•

This is true but I'd like to note that most of the gay marriage bans are taking place on the Federal level, so the furthest left column of this chart. That means that it's not even really the State supreme courts dealing with it, but the laws they are trying to overturn are State specific, which is why it stays within the state.

I'm only pointing this out because if Texas appeals the decision, the hearing will actually occur in New Orleans because they are in the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, but that doesn't mean that the holding will not apply to Texas just because the court was in Louisiana. There are only 13 U.S. Appellate Districts, and they go there before they go to the US Supreme Court.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

I'm beginning to see how many different courts there are. I never realized until this post and my own experience, how appealing a ruling worked; not only how the appellate courts work, but the extent of them as well. Not just in my case of an unemployment appeal either. While researching for my case, I learned a vast amount of information about the circuit court of appeals. So much courts!

1
TIger474•

This is more of a ELI5 post than askreddit. I understand it, but explaining it is difficult.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

Thanks, I am also new to Reddit. I'm trying to keep up with the whopping 12 answers I've already received.

[Does someone like /ickthus mentioning /ELI5 mean, my question/answer will show up there, too? I'm going back to read the Wiki tonight as well.

1
TIger474•

Well welcome to reddit! Someone commenting on a post does not transfer the post over, you would have to do that. ELI5 stands for explain to me like i am five and is really good for one response questions, like this. Ask reddit is better for open ended questions with multiple responses. For example "What is the best job and why?"

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

Thanks. I found myself here around the same time last year, but this year I am in a much better, more focused, more determined mind. I want to harness the power of the community and use it to change the worldcommunity; I know, I know, as cliche as it sounds though, I mean it. I'm not going to change the world, but I'm willing to spend the rest of my life trying and I have found there are a lot of others on here that feel the same. I certainly will make sure I read, review and post to the appropriate subbreddit from now on. Although, this posting has given me a great deal of insight and pointed me in the right direction.

1
shogi_x•

It's because the judges are overturning specific laws. Even though two states may have laws that are almost identical, those are two separate and distinct laws. A state judge can only address laws of their state.

1
babypumapounce•

It's not that the laws are unique. It's that the claims are being brought under state constitutions. We have several cases now that are brought under the federal constitution. They have the power to affect marriage laws nationwide, regardless of wording.

1
YouVersusTheSea•

The states can't override the Federal laws, but the Federal laws can override the state laws. The federal law is silent on gay marriage, as a whole, meaning there is no federal statute that explicitly grants everyone the right to marry with no restriction.

The problem is that the US Congress never specifically amended the US Constitution to say "marriage is a fundamental right for everyone no matter what." That means it's hazy as to where the line is (the official word is ambiguous).

Following? Now, in the US Constitution, there is a provision that leaves anything not expressly reserved by the Federal Government in the US Constitution are to be left to the states' individual laws. It's the 10th Amendment. The states have enacted gay marriage bans within their own constitution so every time the argument comes up that it's "unconstitutional" the people are saying that "This particular state law does not follow the US Constitution for x reason."

So basically, every challenge is specific to that one specific State's laws, because no state constitutions are worded identically and they are all separate states. If the Federal government were to add an Amendment to the US Constitution that said "Any two, non-related adults who consent to enter into the contractual relationship of marriage may do so," it would automatically make all the states' laws unconstitutional but since there is currently no broad, clear Federal rule, each state only has to defend its own specific law.

If you're still a little lost, this site explains the idea of "federalism" in kid language which is helpful. Also, you could watch this video about the Tenth Amendment, which might help you understand.

1
broadcastingstudentOP•

Thanks. Definitely following.

That site is a great starting place. I find myself all over the place sometimes, and really need to take it back to the elementary level to get myself back on track. The entire legal system is all over the place. It's a lot of information, but for the sake of ensuring our rights, I'm willing to learn, fight, and raise awareness for. Starting at that site is a great refresher and makes it a bit simpler for me to organize my thoughts and study process. Thanks!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
babypumapounce•

I don't think this analysis is correct. It's not that federal law is silent on marriage and the 10th amendment thereby gives that right to the states. Rather, the federal government has limited powers granted by the states (interstate commerce, taxing and spending, etc.). Secondary from that is an affirmative statement in the 10th Amendment that other powers are reserved to the states. But that's kind of icing on the cake. You could reach that outcome without the 10th amendment because if it's not granted in the constitution, the federal government doesn't have the power. The 10th Amendment just states what is implicit in the constitution.

When gay activists challenge exclusion of gay marriage as unconstitutional, the relevant question to ask is unconstitutional under what--the federal constitution or that state's constitution. Until recently, activists only brought claims under state constitutional law. That limited rulings to that state only.

We now have lawsuits under the federal constitution. They have the potential to impact all states.

1
ickthus•
0