College student looking for a laptop [15.6 in] [USA] [~$700]

LAPTOP QUESTIONNAIRE

  • Country of purchase: USA

  • Budget range: $500 - $600

  • Purpose (netbook, ultraportable, mainstream, gaming, desktop replacement, etc.): mainstream / entertainment / productivity

  • Screen size preference: 15.5in

  • OS preference (Windows/ Mac/ Linux): Windows is fine but the more linux compatible the better as I will most likely be dual booting and Linux will be my full time OS

  • Gaming requirements (example games and desired fps/settings):

  • Performance requirements (video, CAD, etc.): The only thing i'm not willing to compromise on video playback whether that be youtube, netflix, etc. Also I want the same level of quality or, near to it, when scaling to larger televisions (50+ in) I want no graininess, no stuttering, no refresh rate issues, nada. I'm sure the Intel HD 4600 graphics can handle this coupled with whatever HDMI port is in the laptop I purchase, but I just want to run this by you guys first

  • Method of computer support (office supplier, college bookstore, self support): self-support

  • Brand preferences and reasons (already owned accessories, familiarity, busineLAPTOP QUESTIONNAIRE

  • Country of purchase: USA

  • Budget range: $500 - $600

  • Purpose (netbook, ultraportable, mainstream, gaming, desktop replacement, etc.): mainstream / entertainment / productivity

  • Screen size preference: 15.5in

  • OS preference (Windows/ Mac/ Linux): Windows is fine but the more linux compatible the better as I will most likely be dual booting and Linux will be my full time OS

  • Gaming requirements (example games and desired fps/settings):

  • Performance requirements (video, CAD, etc.): The only thing i'm not willing to compromise on video playback whether that be youtube, netflix, etc. Also I want the same level of quality or, near to it, when scaling to larger televisions (50+ in) I want no graininess, no stuttering, no refresh rate issues, nada. I'm sure the Intel HD 4600 graphics can handle this coupled with whatever HDMI port is in the laptop I purchase, but I just want to run this by you guys first

  • Method of computer support (office supplier, college bookstore, self support): self-support

  • Brand preferences and reasons (already owned accessories, familiarity, business compatibility): I'm heavily looking at the Lenovo Z510 59400192 seen here. I know I probably don't need the I5 or the 1080p screen but being that its only $100 difference and I'm already spending $600 if I get the core i5 version it just seems worth it to me. what do you guys think. Also I realize the G510 would also be another option but that's still a $600 laptop and the z510 comes with a backlit keyboard which I think would be nice

  • Any particular style that you like (examples are great):

  • Which of the following qualities would you prefer? (Choose one, the other, or balanced)

  • Long battery life -vs- Low weight: Probably low weight and low battery life, but at least a 4 hour battery life would be acceptable

  • Build quality -vs- Low price:

  • Low noise/heat -vs- High performance: whatever is most econonical

Would you pay a premium for something that has:

  • High resolution screen: not necessarily, and I'm not stuck on a 1080p screen it just seems worth the additional pricepoint

  • A great keyboard: no, but backlit would be nice

  • A great touchpad/mouse buttons: no

  • Great audio: no

List any features that are critical: (e.g. Optical drive, USB 3.0, SD card slot, ethernet port, HDMI port, bluetooth, VGA port, removable battery, glossy screen, matte screen, etc.) these sum it upss compatibility): I'm heavily looking at the Lenovo Z510 59400192 seen here. I know I probably don't need the I5 or the 1080p screen but being that its only $100 difference and I'm already spending $600 if I get the core i5 version it just seems worth it to me. what do you guys think. Also I realize the G510 would also be another option but that's still a $600 laptop and the z510 comes with a backlit keyboard which I think would be nice

  • Any particular style that you like (examples are great):

  • Which of the following qualities would you prefer? (Choose one, the other, or balanced)

  • Long battery life -vs- Low weight: Probably low weight and low battery life, but at least a 4 hour battery life would be acceptable

  • Build quality -vs- Low price:

  • Low noise/heat -vs- High performance: whatever is most econonical

Would you pay a premium for something that has:

  • High resolution screen: not necessarily, and I'm not stuck on a 1080p screen it just seems worth the additional pricepoint

  • A great keyboard: no, but backlit would be nice

  • A great touchpad/mouse buttons: no

  • Great audio: no

List any features that are critical: (e.g. Optical drive, USB 3.0, SD card slot, ethernet port, HDMI port, bluetooth, VGA port, removable battery, glossy screen, matte screen, etc.) these sum it up

thank you guys for your help this is an excellent sub and if you have any other suggestions I'm all ears. Like I said I'm really leaning toward the Z510 but I wanted to tcheck with you guys first that it would do what I require.

Posted Mar 10, 2014, 2:48 PM UTC · edited

65
CyberJeevesCyberjeeves.com•

Hi halfbit. The HD 4400/4600 graphics should be OK to connect to an external monitor/tv.

This version of the Lenovo G510 dropped to around $500 over the past few days. It has an i5 4200M processor, 4GB ram, 500GB HDD and a 1366x768 screen.

The Asus Q501LA is another good choice, since it has a 1080p screen, i5 4200U processor, 6GB ram, 750GB HDD all for $660 at Best Buy.

2
halfbitOP•

Thanks for the reply!

I do not mean to be pedantic, but when you say it should be OK do you mean in the sense that it will be just fine and my requirements will be met or that it will be okay but not great?

the suggestions you made bring me to another question. For my purposes will having an i7 really make a remarkable difference. Both chips seem to have the same internal graphics and it seems like for what I want to do the graphics will become obsolete (for my purposes) before the processor itself will.

is this true?

edit: also something I should have mentionedin my original post. I do some coding work in VMs (for school) and having the additional memory to allocate to the virtual machine for reducing compiling times would be nice.

thanks!

1
CyberJeevesCyberjeeves.com•

Please excuse any ambiguity. The HD4600 should meet your requirements to scale to a 50" TV via HDMI without any issues such as graininess, lag or tearing.

There's usually no reason to upgrade to an i7 if you aren't running specific programs that utilize four cores, like Adobe products, Crysis 3 and VM programs. For most purposes, the i5 4200 is sufficient, and based on your requirements, you should be absolutely fine getting the i5. Integrated chips can't give great gaming performance, but they should suffice for simple video playback for years.

2
halfbitOP•

Just wanted to say thank you. I actually went with the Asus at your suggestion. I liked the IPS panel and Asus has a very strong name.

I looked into HD 4400 vs 4600 and there does not seem to be much of a difference save for the clock speed not being set in the 4400.

I'm looking forward to it. Thanks again for you help

1
CyberJeevesCyberjeeves.com•

You're very welcome, and we wish you many happy hours of use on it :)

If you ever need help purchasing something online, feel free to reach out to us by filling out a free search request. Tell us what you need, and we'll get back to you with some recommendations.

2