r/Guitar•
13Zero

Chord Construction Inconsistency Question

I'm trying to figure out chord construction, because music theory is interesting. While I have the basic idea down, there are some inconsistencies which bother me.

C#m is a good example. C#m is C#, E, and G# (the root, its minor third, and its perfect fifth). This makes sense to me. Where it breaks down is the way the chord is played on guitar. Based on these notes, the most natural way I see to play C#m is open high E, second fret on B, first fret on G, second fret on D, muted A (I need to work on stretching to the fourth fret), and open low E.

My problem: any chord diagram I've seen of an open C#m just excludes both E strings (and uses the fourth fret on A, but that's a technical issue rather than a theory issue). Why is this?

Posted Mar 11, 2014, 8:44 PM UTC

210
ackshunpact•

its because the lowest note is supposed to be the root note. what you're playing has E as the lowest voice so its actually C#m/E which is the first inversion of C#m.

2
13ZeroOP•

That makes sense, but if I play the first four strings as described, is it still C#m or is it something else?

And thank you!

1
tehgoatmanRG 3570z/LP Classic•

It's still c#m just an inversion and a different voicing. If you only play the "first 4" (i think you mean d-e strings?) then your bass note is still an e and its still an inversion. c# has to be the bassiest note for it not to be an inversion, but if you only play the b and e string (c# and e) theres not enough tonal direction and it could also easily be called part of a an Amaj chord.

The reason its often played as a barre chord based off the 4th fret A string is because that is the lowest c# available on the guitar in standard tuning.

2
13ZeroOP•

My bad. I meant strings high E through D. C# is the lowest note, but the diagrams I've seen say not to strum high E.

1
tehgoatmanRG 3570z/LP Classic•

When following what you described, high E through D how is C# the lowest note? 2nd fret on the D string is E. Going in order from D to high e you get E G# C# E

2
lusterwill•

The voicing that you described is really freaking hard to play (gotta stretch your hand a bunch and possibly use your thumb). While it is an option, there are many voicings for each chord, which enables you to pick the easiest one that fits in the context of the progression you're playing.

1