Can anyone explain why breaking the rules or doing something you know you're not supposed to can sometimes feel good?

Psychology

I'm curious if its just a loophole somewhere in the brain's reward system, of if there is something deeper to be discovered.

Posted Mar 12, 2014, 1:06 PM UTC

63
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

There are a few possible explanations which are not mutually exclusive and can apply to a varying degree in different instances.

First, performing some kind of "bad" behaviour is usually the result of a motivation to gain some kind of reward. For example, a person may see something which they like or want to have, like a nice hat. They have two options, (1) they get a job and work until they have enough money, or (2) they simply take it. The reason this is so rewarding is because not only have they got their reward, but they have also circumvented their implicit idea about the right way to obtain things, or in simpler terms, they feel as though they have cheated the system.

Second, most people find games and playing them intrinsically fun. Running around playing "tag-your it" or maybe playing touch football or a game of soccer is fun. This seems irrelevant to doing bad things, but committing crimes can be delineated into some form of game playing behaviour. The subject has a goal (maybe to vandalise a train) which they are trying to accomplish and also has people who are trying to stop this from happening (think, the "other team"). Sometimes doing illegal things is WAY more fun that playing soccer, but that is because the stakes are much higher. If you've ever played paintball you'd know it is much more fun than playing with water pistols because the stakes are higher.

Third, this kind of relates to the second and first points, but this kind of ties them all together as to the specific mechanism which makes anythings fun. Neurochemicals such as adrenaline and dopamine are often responsible for what people call an "adrenaline rush" or "dopamine rush". Essentially, humans have all these implicit ideas about what we should and shouldn't do and the consequences of what would happen if we do something we shouldn't. Doing something illegal, you run the risk of getting caught, consequently flooding your body with adrenaline in preparedness of a "fight" (evolutionary psychology). When you have finished the crime and have recognised that you have gotten away with it, dopamine is triggered as a reward. This can be addictive, as you often see with criminals starting off small and having to up the stakes of their crimes. Similarly, thrill seekers who go skydiving keep "upping" their goals.

1
otterchaoss•

it's pretty simple really. all people seek to have control, and when you disobey direct orders, you get some pleasure for feeling like you were the decider in the situation. There is also the added thrill of possibly being caught. i don't think there is anything much deeper than that

0