FS800 or 1200?
I am trading up from the KLR650 and I am wondering if anyone has any real time experience with either of the BMW big dual sports. I am 53 and in good shape, but lifting a big bike is a pain in the ass no matter the size.
I started riding when I was 11, straight through college. Then I got married and did other things. Started back up last year with the KLR purchase. During the summer and fall, I've rode it often and consistently on four or five hour trips back and forth to my place in Northern VT. (I live in Mass.)
I would love to say that cash is not an issue, but it always is. Is it worth the extra $7k or so for the bigger bike?
I am probably 80% road, and my off trail life is pretty much limited to long dirt roads but no real challenging enduro stuff. That train left about 25 years ago.
I read all of the reviews and both seem like they would do the job. But for the highway or long rides getting to the dirt roads, does the 1200 really make THAT much difference.
I am looking at the Adventure packages for both--I like the lights and the extra bars and what not. I would have put those on anyway, so better to get them up front.
Of course, resale comes into play as well.
Any thoughts are appreciated.
Posted Mar 12, 2014, 8:26 PM UTC
First, I am sure you meant the GS. Not that it matters to me, but certain BMW purists might want to string you up.
Now, onto the comparison.
When it comes to riding style, the F800GS(A) will be the most similar to the KLR. Not that it is THAT similar, just closer compared to the R1200GS. You know those things that are a bit weak for the KLR—buzzy at high speeds, not as dirt-oriented as you'd expect, heavy weight? They're equally true for the F800GS(A).
Of course, with the Rotax twin engine on the 800, your ride will be overall much more smooth, and it's general manners are much more refined than a KLR's. But still.
The R1200GS(A), on the other hand, will be a big departure for you. I can hit 90mph on the highway without even realizing it. It's smoother on tarmac and at highway speeds than the 800, but sacrifices some offroad capability. (The way to compensate for this is to get dirt-oriented tires on the 1200, but they'll definitely affect your highway ride. There's compromise for everything and no free lunch.)
The feel on the 1200 is also very different because of the boxer engine. Hard to describe, except sitting idle at a stop light, the bike feel vaguely like it wants to go sideways (very subtle).
Me personally? I went went with the 1200 because of better highway performance and the heritage of the boxer engine (nothing else quite like it). I, too, save most of my offroading for fire roads and such, and I'd say I get in dirt more than the average 1200GS rider. It's definitely competent with the right tires, if not exactly dazzling.
As far as lifting the big bike goes, there are many YouTube videos that show you how to do it properly without a lot of strain or fuss. I've seen a 130 lb woman do it, and she was no Olympian—it's all technique.
Based on what you say about your riding style, I'd recommend the 1200 over the 800. And I'd go for the Adventure (I didn't and should have) over the standard, not for the farkles like lights and bars (you can get them all after-market and most better than the BMW version), but for the much larger fuel tank.
Of course, test drive both, that will tell you more than I ever could.
Source: I rode a KLR650 and was hell bent on getting an F800GS. Decided on a R1200GS after the test drive and LOVE it.
Thanks. I appreciate your input. I have to wait for the latest snow storm to melt before I can take them for a ride.
My Dad had a big 900 back in the late seventies. I loved that engine. My mom sold it after he passed, thinking I wouldn't want it. I recall being 17 and driving down the highway, looking down and seeing I was going 90. Scared the crap out of me. But smooooth....
That's north of 20k tied up in a bike you should expect to drop, uuuuuugh. The only time i would consider a 1200 is if i were doing a bunch of motorcycle camping, two up with a, um... robust lady friend.
Totally. I "soften" the blow with crash bars, soft panniers, and some other hardware to cover breakable pieces. And I don't single track it, just fire roads.
I've had a few low speed offs and there's been no lasting damage, but agree, you have to accept that your bike will not look pristine and you may have to replace some part on it now and then because you knocked them off. I take comfort in the fact that every single scratch on her is one I put there. And that boxer engine will easily last 200k miles, so I'll be able to hand her down to my boy when I am too old to ride.
hahaha, i was under the impression, the moment anyone gets a 1200gs they set about attaching massive aluminium refrigerators to each side of them.
Glad to see your a soft luggage advocate, here is my approach
If its the last bike you will ever buy maybe the 1200 is suitable? who am i to disagree.
Ha! I've got almost the exact same set up, with a big Wolfman duffle in addition the Giant Loop. Every now and then I think about getting aluminum panniers (mostly for locking things in the city). But then I remember what a drop looks like and come to my senses.