r/Dualsport•
Emocmo

FS800 or 1200?

I am trading up from the KLR650 and I am wondering if anyone has any real time experience with either of the BMW big dual sports. I am 53 and in good shape, but lifting a big bike is a pain in the ass no matter the size.

I started riding when I was 11, straight through college. Then I got married and did other things. Started back up last year with the KLR purchase. During the summer and fall, I've rode it often and consistently on four or five hour trips back and forth to my place in Northern VT. (I live in Mass.)

I would love to say that cash is not an issue, but it always is. Is it worth the extra $7k or so for the bigger bike?

I am probably 80% road, and my off trail life is pretty much limited to long dirt roads but no real challenging enduro stuff. That train left about 25 years ago.

I read all of the reviews and both seem like they would do the job. But for the highway or long rides getting to the dirt roads, does the 1200 really make THAT much difference.

I am looking at the Adventure packages for both--I like the lights and the extra bars and what not. I would have put those on anyway, so better to get them up front.

Of course, resale comes into play as well.

Any thoughts are appreciated.

Posted Mar 12, 2014, 8:26 PM UTC

734
thirdbestfriend•

First, I am sure you meant the GS. Not that it matters to me, but certain BMW purists might want to string you up.

Now, onto the comparison.

When it comes to riding style, the F800GS(A) will be the most similar to the KLR. Not that it is THAT similar, just closer compared to the R1200GS. You know those things that are a bit weak for the KLR—buzzy at high speeds, not as dirt-oriented as you'd expect, heavy weight? They're equally true for the F800GS(A).

Of course, with the Rotax twin engine on the 800, your ride will be overall much more smooth, and it's general manners are much more refined than a KLR's. But still.

The R1200GS(A), on the other hand, will be a big departure for you. I can hit 90mph on the highway without even realizing it. It's smoother on tarmac and at highway speeds than the 800, but sacrifices some offroad capability. (The way to compensate for this is to get dirt-oriented tires on the 1200, but they'll definitely affect your highway ride. There's compromise for everything and no free lunch.)

The feel on the 1200 is also very different because of the boxer engine. Hard to describe, except sitting idle at a stop light, the bike feel vaguely like it wants to go sideways (very subtle).

Me personally? I went went with the 1200 because of better highway performance and the heritage of the boxer engine (nothing else quite like it). I, too, save most of my offroading for fire roads and such, and I'd say I get in dirt more than the average 1200GS rider. It's definitely competent with the right tires, if not exactly dazzling.

As far as lifting the big bike goes, there are many YouTube videos that show you how to do it properly without a lot of strain or fuss. I've seen a 130 lb woman do it, and she was no Olympian—it's all technique.

Based on what you say about your riding style, I'd recommend the 1200 over the 800. And I'd go for the Adventure (I didn't and should have) over the standard, not for the farkles like lights and bars (you can get them all after-market and most better than the BMW version), but for the much larger fuel tank.

Of course, test drive both, that will tell you more than I ever could.

Source: I rode a KLR650 and was hell bent on getting an F800GS. Decided on a R1200GS after the test drive and LOVE it.

11
EmocmoOPBmw 1200 GSA•

Thanks. I appreciate your input. I have to wait for the latest snow storm to melt before I can take them for a ride.

My Dad had a big 900 back in the late seventies. I loved that engine. My mom sold it after he passed, thinking I wouldn't want it. I recall being 17 and driving down the highway, looking down and seeing I was going 90. Scared the crap out of me. But smooooth....

2
te_anau•

That's north of 20k tied up in a bike you should expect to drop, uuuuuugh. The only time i would consider a 1200 is if i were doing a bunch of motorcycle camping, two up with a, um... robust lady friend.

2
thirdbestfriend•

Totally. I "soften" the blow with crash bars, soft panniers, and some other hardware to cover breakable pieces. And I don't single track it, just fire roads.

I've had a few low speed offs and there's been no lasting damage, but agree, you have to accept that your bike will not look pristine and you may have to replace some part on it now and then because you knocked them off. I take comfort in the fact that every single scratch on her is one I put there. And that boxer engine will easily last 200k miles, so I'll be able to hand her down to my boy when I am too old to ride.

2
te_anau•

hahaha, i was under the impression, the moment anyone gets a 1200gs they set about attaching massive aluminium refrigerators to each side of them.
Glad to see your a soft luggage advocate, here is my approach
If its the last bike you will ever buy maybe the 1200 is suitable? who am i to disagree.

1
thirdbestfriend•

Ha! I've got almost the exact same set up, with a big Wolfman duffle in addition the Giant Loop. Every now and then I think about getting aluminum panniers (mostly for locking things in the city). But then I remember what a drop looks like and come to my senses.

2
PtrPan•

If you're mostly going to be traveling on roads, you should take a look at the Triumph Tiger 800 xc - it seems to be pretty comparable to the F800GS, but maybe a little bit more road oriented (according the comparisons I've seen)

4
Django_gvl•

This bike was consistently given the higher marks for being better on road then the F800 by every magazine and review web site/youtube/forum. It could still handle the light off road duty you mention OP.

Love my R12GS. But really only on road. I take it off road but it's heavy and expensive and I can't say it's really any fun. Plus, the R12GS has a notorious final drive problem that you will probably experience if you plan on riding the bike for years.

I've had two R12GS's. Love the bike.

If I was in the market today, I would look at the Tiger or a KTM

3
PtrPan•

I'd love to get my hands on a Tiger 800xc...

2
JakesterWI•

Love my 800XC. Best adventure class engine ever. Highly recommend testing one out.

2
cryospamTiger 800 XC•

I looked and looked in 2012, and went with the Tiger 800XC, I love it.

1
EmocmoOPBmw 1200 GSA•

Thanks. They sell them locally--hadn't even thought about that. Thanks.

2
syspigWA Olympic Peninsula - 800XC,WR250R•

Was in the same boat a couple years back...thought about a GS upgrade from my KLR, but got talked into taking a test ride on an 800XC.

Not gonna knock the BMW, plenty of satisfied owners. But for me, riding both made the decision easy...for any DS rides longer than overnight (in which case I take the WRR), the 800XC hits all the right buttons. Compared to the F800GS, it's not even close on the pavement, and for the type of offroad I'm comfortable with on a big bike the 800XC is more than adequate. Perhaps a tad less nimble than the F800 in this regard, but not by much.

Only two negatives for me - stock handlebars and fuel mileage. The former is easily addressed (Rox Risers), and the latter isn't a big deal. Sure, the BMW does a little better on the MPG's...but range isn't all that different, and by the time the Tiger tank is empty I'm ready for a break. And, if memory serves - unlike the 800XC which runs fine on regular unleaded, I'm fairly certain the F800GS requires premium - negating the MPG advantage to your pocketbook.

2
cryospamTiger 800 XC•

Only thing is that the 800 XC seat SUCKS! You have to spend the money and get one from Corbin if you're going to do any real road tips on it. I drive mine from Boston to NYC fairly regularly and on a stock seat it was as bad as my old sport bike...now it's like sitting in my car making the trip, between the seat and heated grips, those are 2 upgrades you can't skip!

1
EmocmoOPBmw 1200 GSA•

Good point. The seat on my KLR left my crotch numb for three days the first time I took it for a long ride.

1
NWfreshF800GSA•

The Tiger is a great bike. It has great engine torque for street riding, but lacked the technology and farkels that are included with the BMW

1
te_anau•

Tiger feels pretty damn nice on road, the triple engine just seems more engaging than the bmw twin. The luggage attachments seemed a tad under resolved on the triumph by comparison. and disengaging abs was an awful multi button exercise on the triumph.
That said, they are both pretty damn lame off road, you are riding the clutch anywhere south of 30mph, they are heavy expensive and cumbersome. Basically road bikes on stilts.
Id be inclined to admit that any road bike can handle what you have in mind for your f800, for the money might as well get a good road bike.

1
NWfreshF800GSA•

I can tell you i love my F800gsa. Great ride, lots of technology, but god damn heavy

3
EmocmoOPBmw 1200 GSA•

The KLR is a bear too. I don't "plan" on dropping it. But we all know about plans.

1
snow_enthusiastBMW HP2 Enduro •

If you ride 80% on road then you want a R1200GS. The 1200GS has way more power, especially if you plan on using two metal panniers worth of gear + gear on the seat. For the little off-roading that you'll do, the R1200 will be able to handle it no problem.

Here's the rub though. If you carry a lot of gear then the F800 and R1200 will be too heavy to off-road. Also, both bikes are only as good as the rider. I find that if I can't use my HP2 on a certain trail, it's because my skills are lacking, not because the bike is deficient in some way.

So to summarize:

  1. Always go Ultralight, no matter what bike you're on.

  2. Whatever GS bike you use will have more capability than you have skill, so take an off-road riding course and then practice, practice, practice.

  3. Get the R1200GS if you have a need for speed or if you're only going to ride fire roads.

2
OrdinaryMrFox•

If you think you need the bigger bike, I think the Tiger is a better choice. Otherwise, I think the 650 Sertao is the actual way to go. Easier to handle, more efficient and cost effective, and you really, really don't need the 1200 power, which you'll finally admit to yourself the first time you drop it in the mud. Still much more functionally pleasing than a KLR.

Also, you speak of upgrading, but you should know that all of the above mentioned bikes are worse offroad than a KLR. If you want an increase in creature comforts while still being pleasant offroad, you're probably looking for something orange. Just in case you see an iffy trail that looks like it goes someplace cool.

2
darmon'05 KLR650, Seattle•

Hey man! Sad to see ya ditch the KLR, just got mine and I'm loving it. But you're not going in a bad direction! I came from a BMW 650GS. And I work in the moto industry, in a dualsport shop that caters mostly to the large BMW dualsports. So I'm somewhat of an authority on the matter, I like to think anyways ;)

Since you're mostly on the highway, and the dirt you do hit won't be single track stuff, you would probably love the 1200. Though I don't know if you need all that power, unless you plan on doing a lot of two-up riding carrying gear for a few days for two people. The F800GS is probably exactly where you want to be. A fully loaded 1200 GSA takes two people to lift, no question.

That all said, when I worked the BMW MOA rally circuit up here in the Pacific northwest last year, most of the attendees are in your age group, and riding two up man and wife style, with tons of gear, on 1200s. Seriously, like 95% of the rally goers are on 1200GSAs hooked to the nines... that never see much action. I tend to look at it like this: if you buy the 800 you plan to use it every day. If you get the 1200 you plan to use it like once a month. Not exactly intuitive, but seems to hold true.

2
wlm2048•

Take a look at the KTM Adventure too. The non-R is more road-ish, and it's got lots of tech and power. I was dead set on either the 800 ADV or the 1200 too, until I screwed up and demoed an R. As far as 4-5 hours in the seat, it's probably somewhere in between the two BMWs, and it's priced closer to the 1200 (especially once you start adding in all the farkles).

I don't think any of the suggestions so far will steer you wrong, though - the Triumph or the BMWs are great, so go find a demo and find the one you like.

2
secutoresOlympic Peninsula - WA - 2003 DR650•

Sweet baby Jesus my dream bike

1
T_G_O_T•

Might be worth looking at the Yamaha Super Tenere as well.

2
Smoke_eater•

I love my 1200gs and I would never even consider a Triumph. I rode a Tiger once and couldn't give it back to the owner fast enough. It has only slightly better quality than a Suzuki.

1
HansBlixJrBMW R1100GS•

My feeling is the whole point of getting a BMW is for the R boxer engine. The balance on the big 1200s is amazing for as high as you sit. I've tipped my (older, smaller, heavier) GS over and it's a bitch to get up by myself, but doable. Two friends went the f800 route and they like their machines a lot. You have 40 plus years riding experience and I think you're gonna get more out of the 1200.

1
infinite0ne•

I put 30k miles on my KLR and loved every minute of it. Through a strange set of circumstances, I had the opportunity to keep and ride a 2008 R1200GS for around 6 months. So I have ridden both, the KLR quite a bit, and the GS enough to get a good feel for it.

The big thing I did with the GS was ride it from Moab, UT to Tucson, AZ, including a trip across Lake Powell on a ferry. That ride was surreal in the best way.

Anyway, I have some opinions on the 1200GS coming from a KLR650, but have never ridden the 800GS, so can't comment there.

Wow. The 1200GS is such an incredibly awesome bike. At first it felt big and a little unwieldy, but that feeling quickly passed, and gave way to a permanent shit eating grin. The power of the 1200GS makes the KLR feel positively sluggish. It will jump off the line faster than just about any car if you want it to. The boxer motor is interesting, too. As thirdbesfriend mentions, if you rev it up at a stop you can really feel the bike lean to one side in response. It's weird, but not in a bad way.

The antilock brakes were trouble in the dirt, but they can be disabled. I remember trying to slow down with the rear brake as I approached a turn, expecting maybe a little skid, and the bike just kept on rolling, as if the brakes were failing. It is a big old pig to maneuver in the dirt, even moreso than the KLR, but it's not all that bad if you have some sense and some decent tires. I was running Continental TKC80s, which were good in the dirt and surprisingly good on the highway.

Where the KLR would be maxed out and leave me bedraggled and beaten down, the GS will do 90+ all day long and feel like nothing. It just feels solid on the highway at any speed. It was such a welcome change to be able to just get up and get past a semi in a hurry whenever I needed to. I always hate hanging around behind or next to those things. I don't want to be around when one of those 100psi tires throws a tread!

I had to let the GS go and went back to the KLR. It was hard at first. The KLR felt so rattly and slow, but there's something about the KLR that's always fun and I was back to loving it in no time.

Anyway, I'm rambling, I guess.

TL;DR: The 1200GS is an awesome machine.

1
at98rd07a•

What i have heard about abs and traction control in 2013+ GS650 (or was it GSA) is that it is really good, and the owner kept it always on. Same guy uses Tourance (street) tires to drive everywhere (loose sand, mud) faster than newbie (2years experince) like me on AT with knob tires. But he has 20+ years experience.

TL;DR If you are looking for new bike, ABS + traction control may actually work on dirt roads

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
b5db0y•

Gonna drop my 2 cents here too.... I have an HD touring bike and an F800GS. If you only have one bike with your riding style I would recommend the 1200GSA. I have ridden both 1200's and own the 800 because anything other than crappy weather commute / off road (fire road stuff) I am on my "big" bike. You will absolutly love the GSA (I almost bought it over the HD).

1
EmocmoOPBmw 1200 GSA•

Thanks for the responses. You have given me a ton to think about.

I will take a look at the triumph and the 1200, just to make sure I am not making a huge mistake (like going with any of these would be a mistake!)

Again, thanks for the answers. I appreciate your time and comments.

1
cryospamTiger 800 XC•

I have a Tiger 800 XC and looked at the 1200 Explorer, and while the 800 is heavy...the 1200 was SUPER heavy, and lost a LOT of it's off road capability as a result of the extra weight (mud or sand put you totally out of commission).

I'd suggest the 800, plenty of nut to get where you're going, and it won't sink.

I also live in Massachusetts so we're riding in similar areas (I ride Monadnock Family Trails fairly frequently).

1
EmocmoOPBmw 1200 GSA•

I am down around Springfield. I do most of my back road riding in Northern VT though. My "enduro" days ended in 1985.

1
cryospamTiger 800 XC•

Ah, I have taken my 800 even down gnarly logging roads with NO problem whatsoever. I do have skid plates and crash guards on it, for Panniers I use a pair of 30mm rocket cans from army surplus, and racks that a dude on the ADVRIDER forums, MisterPX, made me for 40 bucks out of thick box steel to which I attached a quick release kit. The bike is super comfortable to ride on the road, and I ride down to NYC to see my brother quite often during the warm weather with no saddle soreness with the corbin seat.

The bike is heavy, but not unwieldy and it's got plenty of power to rip along on the highway.

1