Alfredsson Email

There's a rumour circulating on Twitter, from Travis Yost, stating that Melnyk sent Alfredsson a drunken, abusive email, presumably after he asked for too much money.

Is Yost a reliable source? He writes a lot about money sometimes seems to have an inside track.

And if this is true... Wow.

http://www.hockeybuzz.com/blog.php?post_id=58751

Posted Mar 17, 2014, 8:09 PM UTC

1233
Spongetoe•

For what it's worth, Brent Wallace was on the Team TSN 1200 yesterday and talked quite a bit about how things in the Senators organization are not well. He's about as reliable as a Sens reporter gets and he's indicated that the word "zoo" has been thrown around in regards to the team.

8
GaaaaaaaOP•

So that means we're a small market, bankrupt team in a cold, unglamorous city, with a batshit insane owner who insists on being involved with player and coaching decisions.

That is GREAT.

8
ErikKarlssonsTendon•

I've thought Yost was a hack for a while now. But Jesus fucking Christ, he's jumped the shark with that one. He spews conjecture about money, none of it with any source. He's a top down writer, starting with the conclusion and focusing on how to prove it. It's drivel.

4†
GaaaaaaaOP•

Okay, well that's good. Not familiar with him at all really.

3
shining_•

He's not the one that started this story.. I knew about this at the beginning of the season. In fact, I'm 100% sure someone on this subreddit had a story of how Murray came into his office and went on a 45 minute rant about the current state of the franchise that involved this drunken email. This franchise is a complete shitshow, would you really be surprised if our owner got drunk and told Alfie to dip?

3
ErikKarlssonsTendon•

I wasn't aware you personally know Eugene Melnyk and his drinking habits

-1†
shining_•

Did I say I did? I HEARD this story at the beginning of the season. It's been going around for a while. You denying it has the same amount of credibility as me saying it happened.

SensChirp ‏@SensChirp 5h @carteciel Hacked again?! This one was a little off base though I think. Although the "email" he mentions at the end is real.

Why exactly would SC claim it's real if it wasn't?

2
ErikKarlssonsTendon•

Unless SC is either Eugene Melnyk or Bibi Alfredsson, how the fuck does he know?

-2
Grizwald•

I've met Melnyk twice. Both times he was completely hammered and incoherent. Granted both of those times were at Bert's Bar in Barbados, but still...he caused quite a show. he was watching the Sens game yelling at the TV and then got on his phone during the intermissions to yell some more at whoever was on the other end. This was in 2007 - 2008 though.

2
mike-kt•

Yost does hockey analysis and organisation analysis; it's useful to separate that out. A lot of Yost's hockey analysis is very good. He's not a hack at that, and uses numbers that are easily verifiable. That part of his writing shouldn't be in doubt. He writes for the Citizen for very good reasons. He's certainly a great person to follow on twitter.

The issue someone could have is the organisation (i.e. the Sens) analysis, which is the really explosive stuff. Looking at the money and the Melnyk email will be very difficult to source, as the organisation keeps this bottled up for a reason.

Conjecture about Yost, about his journalistic credentials/methodology or where he's from are ridiculous. Criticising the author and not the report doesn't really help anything.

2
[deleted]•

The guy lives in New York and has never set foot in ottawa. People are fools if they take anything he writes seriously. He is a loser, no doubt about it.

-5
T-ohm-y•

Just because he doesn't live in Ottawa doesn't mean he's unqualified to write about the team..

4
[deleted]•

To me it does

-6
mike-kt•

What a terrible viewpoint. How far away are Sens fans allowed to live and still comment on the team? Is Brockville too far away? How many times does he need to come to Ottawa to qualify? 10 times? Is that in his life or over the last 5 years or something?

1
[deleted]•

Yeah no. Hes not a fan of the team. That's different. Hes trying to be a reporter yet is never around the team. He is a joke, does not understand the game outside of a piece of paper, and is a negative person

-1
mike-kt•

What's wrong with answering a single question I asked? Why are you so internet tough?

3
SunsOutGunsOut23•

I've been reading Yost's stuff for a while now, and despite what you guys might think is an obsession with Corsi, the guy knows his stuff. Someone on Twitter asked him today about the email and he replied that he 'wouldn't write anything on this I wouldn't include in an affidavit'. Saying that Bibi received this email could be considered libel, so I don't think he'd write about unless he could back it up

4
great1zero•

SensChirp also confirmed the email story a couple of months ago but he wasn't comfortable making a post about it without being 100% certain.

3
ErikKarlssonsTendon•

"Confirmed"

4
great1zero•

Correct, I should have used quotations.

3
GrumpyM•

Huh, he'es pulled the article entirely. The above link goes to 404 not found.

Google cache still has it: link

3
Stoet•

So, am I blind or is this the only reference in the article to OP's post

Abrasive relationships can wear on the involved parties. And if you won't take my word for it, take Bibbi Alfredsson's. One scathing e-mail loaded with an equal balance of inebriation and expletives had her running for Detroit, Michigan.

1
totes_meta_bot•

This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.

^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Comments? ^Complaints? ^Send ^them ^to ^my ^inbox!

3
Boonedoggle•

This guy can be a great writer, but as someone else has said already, he seems to have an extreme vendetta against Melnyk and it hurts his credibility. He can't seem to go a week without posting bad news about the Sens finances, even when it's completely irrelevant.

2
mike-kt•

Sens finances are one of his niches, that's what bloggers do. Are you willing to go through his blog posts and see how often he really talks about finances, then are you willing to say what a reasonable frequency would be?

With what's happened since last summer, do you think finances are irrelevant for bloggers to comment on?

Personally I'm willing to accept Melnyk as owner over no NHL team, but it would be hard to see a worse case right now

1
matty323•

He's probably an asshole (yost). But, either he has a vendetta for melnyk (which seems wierd) or he has connections to melnyk's inner circle.

Read about the ukrainian hackers.

1
ErikKarlssonsTendon•

I'd believe vendetta. Controversy = page view$$$.

1
[deleted]•

Some of his stuff is informative and very well put together, however on occasion he does post some trash. He had a very interesting series of blog posts about Eugene's finances which were soon taken down by "hackers".

1
mike-kt•

The link from OP is already down.

1
[deleted]•

Its like scouting players. You can't scout them on video, you have to be at the games. You can't see what they are doing without the puck, what is actually going on all over the ice.

Yes I would respect him more if he didn't live in new York and didn't just base opinions on stats that nobody uses. I would also respect him if he didn't make shit up about melnyk and about sources he claims to have. Its no wonder his articles are always removed, he creates controversy for no reason.

I would always take the opinion of a guy like a jason York over Yost any day.

Read Yost all you want but its the people that are balls deep in with him who are annoying. Thing like phillips is terrible, greening smith neil are terrible, etc.

1
Nutzillaa•

Yeah, I think this Yost guy is a hack as well. Always seems to be cooking up rumours but never providing any sources.

Also annoying as shit to follow on Twitter. Coris over everything for that guy.

-1