[University English/History] Can anyone tell me if either who or whom is appropriate here?

I am writing a book review on A Vietcong Memoir and I am having trouble with "who" and "whom"

Here is the sentence,

"Once in exile, Tang began writing his account of his experiences in order to express the views of a revolutionary WHO/WHOM was later disillusioned by the post-war communist government and the effects the war had on him, his fellow revolutionaries, and his family."

Posted Mar 21, 2014, 2:47 AM UTC

14
francesmorris47•

"Once in exile, Tang began writing his (the) account of his experiences In order to express the views of (as) a revolutionary WHO/WHOM was later disillusioned by the post-war communist government**(comma)** and the effects the war had on him, his fellow revolutionaries, and his family."

Sometimes when you are having trouble with the grammar of a sentence, you need to look again at tightening and re-wording.

PS u/insteadofwhat is correct, grammatically speaking.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
insteadofwhat•

It needs to be "who." "Who" is the subject of the passive verb "was disillusioned" inside the adjective clause modifying "revolutionary." It doesn't matter that "revolutionary" is the object of the preposition "of"; what matters is that "who" is the subject of a verb.

1
UnshackledaiWriting & Biology•

This might be useful for the future!

http://theoatmeal.com/comics/who_vs_whom

1
lonesome_godMS Structural Engineering•

I feel like this is a compound-complex sentence, which more of less can be divided into two main clauses -

"Once in exile, Tang began writing his account of his experiences"

"The views of a revolutionary WHO/WHOM was later disillusioned by the post-war communist government and the effects the war had on him, his fellow revolutionaries, and his family"

Clearly, in the second sentence, revolutionary is the subject of the sentence, so WHO becomes appropriate to use. If instead, his fellow revolutionaries, and his family were the ones under scrutiny, you would be using whom, like so -

"The views of a revolutionary WHO was later disillusioned by the post-war communist government and the effects the war had on him, his fellow revolutionaries, and his family, WHOM he loved and respected."

0