/r/hometheater, I need to replace my TV and could use some help picking out a new one.

Yesterday a very tragic event happened, the new shelf my girlfriend installed (after me finally relenting over weeks of debate) above my home theater system collapsed and destroyed my Panasonic TC-P50S30.

So today I am in the market for a new TV! I read a few reviews and found that the Panasonic ST series was highly recommended, only to discover they have stopped making them! (nooo not my panasonics!)

So now I am lost as to what to get. I went to Costco but many of the models they had I can't find a review for online.

What would be a good television in the 50-60 range, that would have comparable or better picture quality and black levels as the Panasonic TC-P50S30 I am having to replace.

I don't care for 3D, and I have plenty of devices on the "Smart side" so I don't use many of those features directly on the TV. I want the best picture quality I can get for about $1,500.00 or so.

Thank you!

Posted Mar 31, 2014, 1:32 PM UTC

512
svirbt•

Well if you could possibly expand your budget a little more, the Samsung f8500 would be your best bet for best picture quality. Sadly, the smallest it comes is 51" and it runs about $1800 right now... If your budget is pretty set, then check out the Samsung 60f5300. Or the [Samsung 60f5500] (http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-PN60F5500-60-Inch-1080p-Plasma/dp/B00BCPGZB0/ref=sr_1_1?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1396274437&sr=1-1&keywords=pn60f5500) seems like a great deal as well if you want a few more bells and whistles for essentially a few bucks more than the 60f5300+shipping.

With Panny pulling out of the plasma game and not much competition, other manufacturers (Samsung and LG) will likely water down this years sets before they likely pull out of plasma next year too. For the money and quality, if you get a 2013 model it will be a very wise decision!

3
notacceptableOP•

Thank you very much!

They had a Samsung PN60F5350A at costco for about $750.00, do you think it would be comparable to the f5300 you mentioned here?

I can't find it on their website but I did find this blurb about it.

I might be able to stretch my budget up to the f8500 if it is a big difference in quality, I may have to hunt one down in person.

I was looking for a Panasonic model from last year locally, but haven't had any luck finding them yet, except one HT store that wanted $4,500 for the ST. :(

2
svirbt•

Yeah, once Panasonic shipped their last of the 2013 Models in December/January, prices soared. Nobody can find them and the ones who do have them price them about 2-3x their MSRP price. The f8500 model was Samsung's best tv from last year and it rivaled the VT and ZT60 in performance/picture quality. I am not familiar with the model you posted but most likely the f5350 from Costco is almost identical to the 5300 except maybe one more or one less hdmi port (anything to give it some kind of a difference). If you can find somewhere (maybe a Best Buy Magnolia) that has the f8500 on display I would highly recommend checking it out! Its a nice TV!

3
notacceptableOP•

Thank you very much for all of the information svirbt.

I am going to figure out what I need to do to see one of these in action, as I'm sure it will be my choice after the information you've provided.

2
svirbt•

Happy to help :-) Good luck!

3
notacceptableOP•

Edit: It looks like u/bearwulf answered my question!

2
pound_some_cunth•

The f8500 looks like a great plasma TV, but which level of Panasonic plasmas would it compare to? St, VT, or zt? I'm looking at 65" tv's and the price of the Samsung seems to be the same as the VT models.

1
svirbt•

It is up there with the VT and ZT. The VT and ZT imo have better reds and black levels, but it really could go toe to toe with them. It really is the best TV Samsung has ever made.

2
bearwulf•

The reason it'll be hard to find a review on TVs at Costco is because them and Sam's are the worst about getting models that only they sell. Say for instance you have a sharp 60le800. Costco will name it like a 60le825 or something and the only difference may be a USB port or something minor. If you want reviews just match up the series number with the TV.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
notacceptableOP•

If only, I am in Texas / DFW area. That is awesome though heh.

2
Deadleggg•

Why in the blue hell would you trade a ZT for any led? Madness.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1