r/askscience•
sup3

Why isn't electromagnetism considered two forces, making five fundamental forces of nature?

Physics

There is the electroweak force, combining electromagnetism with the weak nuclear force, but after this force was proposed we didn't decide that there were only three fundamental forces of nature. The electroweak force only becomes relevant above certain thresholds, so is the reverse true for electromagnetism? Does the relationship between electricity and magnetism become irrelevant under a certain threshold? Are there any other ways electromagnetism could be counted as two forces, even in theory?

Posted Apr 6, 2014, 8:23 PM UTC

45
Das_MimeRadio Astronomy | Galaxy Evolution•

No, they're part of the same interaction. Maxwell's Equations make it clear that electric and magnetic forces are two aspects of the same interaction. A varying electric field induces a magnetic field and vice versa. The forces that a charged particle experiences due to electric and magnetic field can be considered collectively as the Lorentz Force. There is no threshold under which this relationship ceases to exist; it works all the way down to the lowest temperatures we've measured, which are tiny fractions of a degree above absolute zero.

7
frogdude2004•

Electric forces and magnetic forces are two sides of the same coin. As Das_Mime says, they can be combined as the Lorentz Force, and it is worth looking at the part of the wiki page he linked to about the relativistic form. In a frame of reference moving with constant velocity, a magnetic field now looks like a combination of electric and magnetic fields. Similarly, a magnetic field would look like a combination of electric fields and magnetic fields.

3
sup3OP•

Electric forces and magnetic forces are two sides of the same coin

See, I thought the same thing applied to electromagnetism and the weak nuclear force, namely that they were "two sides of the same coin" (just that we didn't realize that until recently). I do understand that the physics is something fundamentally different in this case. Is it the case that electromagnetism is always a function of electrons (where the weak nuclear force relies on... W and Z bosons)?

Also, thanks for everyone who replied!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
xxx_yyyCosmology | Particle Physics•

The reason there is a threshold for electroweak unification is that the unifying symmetry is spontaneously broken below an energy threshold. Electricity and magnetism remain unified at all energies, because its symmetry is never broken.

2
aiusepsi•

To some extent, it's a little bit arbitrary how you decide what's fundamental and what isn't, but the electric and magnetic forces are very definitely part of the same thing.

This really becomes obvious when you consider EM relativistically. Consider that magnetic fields are generated by electric currents, which are moving electrons. If you start co-moving with one of those electrons (i.e. you enter the electron's rest frame), you're now seeing an electron at rest, and an electron at rest has no magnetic field, but only an electric field.

In the same way that it makes more sense to consider space-time as a single four-dimensional entity, you also see electromagnetism as a single entity, and then it behaves properly.

1