r/Diablo•
lite951

Is MF additive or multiplicative?

RoS

If the chance of getting a legendary is L and I have M magic find on my gear is the resulting chance of legendaries L*M/10 or L+M/10?

I got a Nagelring with 47% MF and with a Topaz in my helm I can get a total of 88% MF. If MF is additive then this is only 3.8% higher legendary chance. If it is multiplicative then it is 8.8%. Assuming it is multiplicative, that doesn't sound too bad. I'll take 8.8% more legendaries. I doubt I can swap those two items and start doing rifts 8.8% faster.

Posted Apr 14, 2014, 6:48 PM UTC

141
AvatarOfMomus•

It's multiplicative but I'm not sure where you're getting 3.8% for additive...

It's whatever the base chance is times 10% of your MF, so (Legendary Chance)*1.088

1†
pyromance•

Is there a source for this? You seem rather confident.

1
AvatarOfMomus•

I know I have seen a blue confirm this somewhere in the last week or so but I can't find the post easily at the moment and there are something like 200 blue posts to dig through since the 1.15 per torment level thing was revealed and I don't have time, sorry.

Even without a source for how it's multiplied through though we don't have any reason to suspect it would work otherwise beyond some suspicion of willful obtuseness on the dev's part. We know it's 10% effect on Legendaries so we know it has an effect. Every other percentage effect of the sort, damage or otherwise, is multiplicative not additive, so why assume magic-find is different? Plus how would an additive 15% bonus actually work? Maybe if it was 15% of the base chance but that seems silly and underwhelming for a stat that is now extremely hard to get.

1
pyromance•

...Every one of them except the ones most comparable to magic find (gold find, exp bonus), then sure. That's why I wanted a source. Because "it wouldn't make sense if it were additive" isn't really a sound basis for confidence.

1
AvatarOfMomus•

Except that there isn't another source to increase gold drops beyond Gold Find and same-stat bonuses increase additively. The other stat that increases XP bonuses, +XP per monster, isn't confirmed to be multiplied or not AFAIK.

However we have a set of bonuses that are confirmed to multiply and affect the base Legendary droprate and since neither one has been stated to be Magic Find based we can fairly safely assume multiplicative bonuses even without a blue post.

1
rabbitlion•

Do we really need a source that mobs don't have an 8.8% chance to drop legendaries? I mean seriously, just go and kill one mob pack and tell me if there is 3 legendaries on the ground.

1
lite951OPLite#1427•

T1 Rifts have a legendary multiplier of 2*(1.15) = 2.3.

If MF is additive then the ratio is (2.3 + 0.088) / 2.3 = 1.038, so 3.8% higher.

If MF is multiplicative then the ratio is (2.3 * 1.088) / 2.3 = 1.088, so 8.8% higher.

-2
AvatarOfMomus•

Ah, you shouldn't be dividing there. It's just a straight up [Legendary Chance]1.152*MF = Legendary chance so it's a total of 2.5x, not 8.8%.

150% MF is the same as going up a Torment difficulty, confirmed by blue post, so an extra 1.15% multiplied in.

3
jeftep•

I'm horrible at math and a friend swears by a MF gem in the helm. Can you elaborate what actual benefit he gains towards legendary items on T1?

1
MorticharMorticahr#1118•

Depending on the gem, he has

Legendary chance * (1 + (gem % * .10))

With a 39% MF gem, that's 103.9% normal rate.

Quite abyssmal.

Accounting for rifts, it's 207.8% normal rate, because it's double. Then multiply in the torment modifier, 1.15, for 238.97% normal rate.

Without the gem, however, it's 230% of normal rate. The difference is almost entirely negligible, and extremely disappointing when compared to a % life gem.

2
AvatarOfMomus•

If he's running a 41% Topaz then he's gaining a stacking 4.1% bonus to Legendary drop chance that multiplies together with other drop chance increases. So if he's farming Rifts on T1 then he gets 1.15x for T1, 2x for Rifts, and 1.041x for the Topaz.

Formula:

Torment * Rifts * MF = increased chance.

(also sorry, it should be 2.5x from my last post, not 2.5%, sorry about that)

1
jeftep•

Thanks, to the both of you.

1
kippot•

tell your friend to enjoy the tiniest increase in blue/yellow items over 70k hp, which could partly carry him to the next torment level

1
Paultimate79Paultimate#1333•

What the hell did I just read?

Also its 1.15^2 not 2*1.15.

ಠ_ಠ

0
uhhNo•

The 2 in front is for the 100 % bonus that they added for rifts recently. For T1 it's 2 * 1.15 times the normal rate. For T2 it's 2 * 1.15^2.

2
oTradeMarkoTradeMark#1108•

I seem to remember reading a blue post that said MF is multiplicative, although only 10% applies to legendaries. I created a spreadsheet here which shows the bonus legendary drop rate in Rifts including some typical MF%: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Alrb5qHnXGmbdHFacXJNS1JfWEJzY1hhOVBRZmtRQmc&usp=drive_web#gid=0

1
XsNR•

(1+0.47+0.30)/10 = L

0
lite951OPLite#1427•

Yeah obviously. How does this factor into the rest of the magic find in the game. Multiplicatively or additively.

1
XsNR•

Well it shows up on your character panel, I'm 99% sure its all just additive, but it been a long time since I even looked at it.

1
kippot•

Magic Find as we knew it is dead. just leave it alone and lets all forget about it.

or enjoy sacrificing precious stats/slots to get the tiniest increases in magic/rare drops.

0
GrimpawGrimm#2949•

None of those. It's addictive.

-2
CalamityGG•

It's additive.

Magic find isn't capped at 100, so it can't be multiplicative. 100% MF simply means you gain twice as many magic items as usual, on average.

Edit: I thought you meant between individual sources of MF. Yes, the 10% is multiplied by your "normal" legendary drop rate. For example with 100MF, .001% becomes .0011%.

-13
Promanguy•

..What?

5