Kashmir33[NBA] LeBron James•

http://bkref.com/tiny/Tcmga

There is not a single "first player... since" stat that is worth pointing out because averages are usually so close for the best players.

26
dunned024Timberwolves•

There will always be a divide between the people who consider certain statistical boundaries arbitrary and those who want someone to be recognized for something.

The "27 pts / 8 reb" are pretty arbitrary values to consider. What's significant about them?

12
retrominge/r/CharitableBets•

It's higher than 26 points and 7 rebounds, I guess

15
TheCulbertitude[LAL] Nick Young•

Really? you think so?

-9
retrominge/r/CharitableBets•

I mean, if you could confirm that would be great, I suppose.

7
quisquoseNBA•

Tweaking the numbers a bit adds a number of other players (Dirk, Love, and KG for higher rebounds; KD, Lebron, T-Mac, and Kobe for points), but I'd say the main takeaway is that individuals don't accumulate counting stats like they used to, especially post players.

The Mailman averaged 25/10 for his career, and now we've just gone 11 years without anyone putting up 27/8 in a single season.

1
ZlasherWarriors•

I lowered the numbers to 26.0 and 7.0, and there are 18 players since 2005 that have completed those numbers. I agree, I hate the stat sorting that some people do.

6
okiedawgSupersonics•

In fact LeBron averaged 30 and 7.9 in 07-08.

4
whiskeyandteaKnicks•

I'm going to defend this post, since no one else is. The fact that only Melo and Shaq have put up those numbers in the last 10 years shows how difficult it is to put up those numbers for a full year. If it wasn't difficult, more people would do it. Thats why when lowering the ceiling you found more players. Obviously if you lowered it to 15. points and 5 rebounds you would come up with probably 200 players.

0†
Beep_Boop_IAmaRobotRockets•

Ya but if you raised it to 28 and 10 most of the players on that list would make the cut, but melo wouldn't. It's an arbitrary cut off

4
whiskeyandteaKnicks•

How is that possible, since 28 and 10 is clearly more than 27 and 8? If that's true, then the stat isn't arbitrary, it's just flat out wrong.

1
Kashmir33[NBA] LeBron James•

Look at my link. I only lowered the required rebounds by .1 and it shows 3 more seasons over these last few years. .1 difference in rebounds per game is completely negligible. Obviously the numbers are a great accomplishment but the cutoff is so arbitrary that it really shouldn't be used to make it seem more significant.

1
whiskeyandteaKnicks•

But the fact is still that you had to lower it. Does .1 of a rebound and 1 less point per game really matter? Apparently it counts for something, because, as you said, it eliminates like 20 players. It's not an arbitrary cut off if it is a watershed.

1
SharksFanAbroadWarriors•

11 years, I believe.

1
zaceoryUSA•

I agree that most of these stats are relatively useless but there is some value to it. The vast majority of players won't ever do anything special enough to even get a "first person" post in their entire career. The fact that Carmelo was the first to slightly edge out everyone else since 2003 in some categories should be taken with a grain of salt obviously, but isn't completely worthless.

I agree, this stat is more on the worthless side, but there was recently a post about Kevin Love being the first person to have a 2000 pt/900 rb/100 3ptm season which is much more interesting. The numbers may be somewhat arbitrary, but it is simply to show that Kevin Love broke the mold in some meaningful way. You can drop any category of Love's stats down quite a bit and you won't get many other players near him. So I think you're wrong, we should point them out and take them in context.

2
Kashmir33[NBA] LeBron James•

I had the same though with KLove's numbers yesterday and even looked up how much one could lower the numbers but then I thought about it more. 3 different required stats naturally makes the field of players that can accomplish such numbers extremely small. All of us know that Love is a great player and has a very unique skillset but unless it is something like "averaging 35 PPG on 60% FG% over a season" it really isn't worth excluding players that have accomplished similar things.

1
zaceoryUSA•

3 different required stats naturally makes the field of players that can accomplish such numbers extremely small.

That is really the whole point though. Love's game is unique and the combination of stats simply shows how it's unique. Just like Carmelo's game isn't exactly unprecedented, but he was able to push the boundaries a little bit more. Basically these stats just need to be taken in context and not too seriously. No harm in pointing them out IMO.

1
history_booksRaptors•

Durant even had more rebounds one season than Melo did this year without making the "cut"

1
IanicRR[TOR] Amir Johnson•

Super specific numbers but any stat that gives Melo credit to how amazing he is is alright with me. Dude balls his heart out day in and day out and clearly loves the game of basketball. I hope he gets a ring at some point in his career.

10
Not_A_Doctor__Raptors•

If you make it 28 pts and 8 rbs, then Carmelo doesn't make the cut.

I don't think it actually means anything one way or the other.

7
LeopardSealsOcelotTimberwolves•

Pretty arbitrary numbers, similar to KLoves 2000 points 900 rebounds 100 3-point Made stat the other day.

5
Not_A_Doctor__Raptors•

I think I am going to pick some historically bad player (someone who played three games in 1967 and got paid in free nights in the motel) and then design a stat that fits only that dude.

"Milton Rexhurrington was the only nba player in history to average 3 turnovers, 1 pt and 1 steal between the 32nd and 34th minute of a game in which they were the ninth man off the bench... NOT EVEN JORDAN DID THIS."

2
fugitivedenimNets•

Durant did it in 11-12

source

2
ReadThis5sA10IsTypinBucks•

527 rebounds/66 games= ~7.98 rebounds per game but that just shows how pointless this stat is.

3
[deleted]•

and all for nothing...

1
mikehaven•

wow, if only stats counted towards wins. Melo will keep trying to shoot his way to V

0
nba1211[SAC] DeMarcus Cousins•

Also, the fact that Michael Jordan makes this list is absurd.

-1
nba1211[SAC] DeMarcus Cousins•

He is so gone from the Knicks it's not even funny. Also, I'm surprised LeBron hasn't done this given his improves rebounding.

This stat also shows the shift from post play to behind-the-arc play. The highest scoring big man in the league this year gets a lot of points from three-point range. I hope DeMarcus becomes the next guy in this range, but the stats here show that Shaq was basically the last dominant big man.

-4
dunned024Timberwolves•

Jeez, can anything about Carmelo be posted here that doesn't immediately elicit a "HE'S GONE, SAY BYE BYE NY" response? It's frustrating enough to hear everyone speculate Love's destination; I can only imagine how much worse it is for Knicks fans- it seems like every time he's mentioned the next appropriate thing to say is "he won't be on the Knicks soon!"

4
Armani_KimboKnicks•

Melo's literally looking for any decent reason to stay, but apparently its already a done deal that he's gone

2
ChicanoKid_NYC_7Knicks•

I heard that he doesn't know what he is doing yet

1
nba1211[SAC] DeMarcus Cousins•

Living about 2 hours away from NYC now. Knicks fans find it hard to talk about anything else. The team gave up a lot to get him (thanks, Dolan!) and him leaving would destroy the team.

Unless Phil Jackson gets the level of control Dolan hasn't given to anyone else (not to mention that they don't really have any draft picks for a while), this team will be in even worse shape than people think if he leaves. So it's a huge concern.

-2
Armani_KimboKnicks•

They have a draft pick next year, christ

3
ChicanoKid_NYC_7Knicks•

People forget that it's a league rule that you cannot trade away consecutive 1st rounders so we have one in 2015 and 2017. They make it out like we are in some wasteland with no picks until the end of time

1