The American Oligarchy
Is it just me or is America sort of mirroring the events that led to the French Revolution?
Posted Apr 25, 2014, 4:39 PM UTC
Is it just me or is America sort of mirroring the events that led to the French Revolution?
Posted Apr 25, 2014, 4:39 PM UTC
Yes, if you ignore all the cultural, historical, political, economic and religious differences between those two things. If what you really want to say is "wouldn't it be cool if we had a revolution and executed a bunch of people", you should say that.
Why do people on this site always assume everyone else is more stupid or ignorant than they? First, I asked a question, I did not make any claims. Second, obviously I don't condone another civil war; that would be counterproductive to any end. I was thinking along the lines of a Thoreau-inspired revolution IF the economic and political situation here is similar. That, as evidenced by my reply to another comment, was to be my follow-up question. Don't be presumptuous.
First, I asked a question, I did not make any claims
It was obviously a loaded question (implying that there are similarities).
There's no reason to pick on a comparison between the pre-revolution 18th century France and modern day America. Clearly bringing up the question is meant more in the spirit of romanticism of revolution than actual useful historical comparisons, of which there are many that are more fitting.
The downfall of the Church and the monarchy was pivotal to the French Revolution, as were sweeping social and political changes, none of which are going to happen in the US because they don't have a monarchy or a powerful church, and the social and political changes that happened in France have already occurred in the US.
The French Revolution and the American revolution actually have quite a lot in common, but no modern market democracy is in a comparable state of affairs compared to Feudal pre-industrial revolution france.
Well you sort of answered my question so thank you for that. I still don't think you understand my point tho but whatever.
What point was that?
You said you were asking whether 18th century feudal France was mirroring what's happening in America today, which it clearly isn't.
If you weren't making some veiled reference to "we should have a revolution now because of american oligarchy", then its a pretty pointless post to make because the truthful answer to that direct question is a resounding no.
Yes, we're getting to that point. In almost every other industrialized nation the middle class is growing, but in the United States it's shrinking at an alarming rate.
There are several things we can do to stop this:
OK but what about Thoreau?
What about him? He had ideas and never acted on them.
Doesn't mean we shouldn't. If we really feel the political and economic situation here isn't just, isn't it our duty, per the Declaration and Lincoln to ensure govt of, by, and for the people shall not perish from the earth?
No.
Also take a look at european nations that had rainbow coalitions (spain, portugal) and see if having viable 3rd parties helped them avoid corporatist collusion between government and business.
See above.