MysterySolvedScoob•

That's a damned shame, there're very few things more fun in UK politics than watching Jeremy make some weasel squirm in his seat for a few minutes.

14
EvsieFiscally Sensible Lefty [-3.62, -4.21]•

I dream of a show like Charlie Rose.

A smart guy, non-combative but willing to call politicians on their bullshit. Hour long show, often 3x20minutes, sometimes a 30 and two 15s, sometimes a whole glorious hour in conversation with someone important.

Paxman just shouts at people these days. I get it. I get why. There is only so much evasion and non-answers I would be able to take before losing my rag too... but we're never better informed after it. We're rarely treated to an honest discussion of policy areas, it's Punch and Judy journalism, and it's a massive problem.

Assuming the BBC stick with the format, someone like Faisal Islam could do a good job. Very bright guy, understands economics and is willing to challenge guests when needed. He's also quite young, so could become a new Paxman/Dimbleby in time.

14
Kreindeker4, -3•

All our question time seems to be more heat than light these days, with the possible exception of some select committees. Newsnight, PMQs, The Home Affairs committee under Vaz, BBC's Question Time, they all seem to descend in my mind into one big blast of preening, and grandstanding, occasionally shouting and general farmyard behaviour.

I suppose it's difficult to answer questions honestly or something.

7
axlotus•

Reason being, at the end of the day you can't compel anyone to come on TV, while you can compel them to appear before a select committee. If attendance is voluntary then only the people who feel fully coached and briefed and talking-pointed will be willing to appear.

I vote for a new series of compulsory interrogations of public figures, starting with the highest net worth and working downwards. They sit in a cold cell with a Paxtonian interviewer, a fact checker, and a camera. They don't get to leave until they're psychologically disassembled and their defences are completely broken down, ultimately leaving them as shivering tearful basket cases in a natty suit. (Big Brother style.) Imagine the ratings!

1
TLS96Liberal Democrat•

Very true. Or a real life Howard Beale!

2
DirectAddressOP•

Newsnight* obviously

7
JorvicDemocratic Socialist - Red Labour•

No no, you were right the first time

9
RugoseIf the facts change, I'll change my mind -2.0, -2.0•

Who else could fill his boots? He is the main reason I watch Newsnight.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
SoyElPadrino•

or Alan Carr

2
Dick_HarringtonDux•

Keith Lemon

1†
ICritMyPants•

Sucks. Cannot stand the guy. He would just sit there trying to make mundane jokes. Keep him on ITV.

3
Arkyl•

I think this is a good thing, someone new could really give the show a new feel that it hasn't had for a long time.

1
[deleted]•

Good riddance. Most overrated TV journalist on the most overrated news show on TV. Newsnight is a total parody of itself.

Last time I watched they had a 15-minute segment on 'Nature Deficit Disorder'. First an intense hippy man presented a film about how lack of nature is affecting children's mental health. He stood on a traffic island in a council estate interviewing children about whether they liked grass. Then we cut to a pretend forest where he had a debate with a single mum, an eight-year old and David Aaronovich of the Times. The eight-year old sat in silence throughout playing with her iPad. They had got a live caterpillar to crawl past the camera to add to the atmosphere.

The whole show is indistinguishable from The Day Today.

0