ELI5: If Islam is a religion based on peace, how do terrorist organisations such as Al-Qaeda justify their actions when they kill innocent people?

After seeing the front page story about the hospital in Yemen they stated that they don't kill innocent people as a policy in Yemen yet they do in other countries. So my question is how do they religiously justify to themselves the killing of innocent people in other countries? Also, what do they hope to accomplish by killing people? Edit: So far a lot people have done is compare it to christianity, but this doesn't answer the question. I was specifically asking how Islamic extremists think their actions are justified.

Posted May 1, 2014, 11:18 AM UTC · edited

019
GirlGargoyle•

Islam is quite a fractured religion, much like Christianity with its sects of protestants, catholics, church of england, mormons, adventists, etc etc.

Now, to explain the differences, I'll have to explain "hadiths." The Qu'ran is a big book supposedly dictated to Mohammad by the archangel Gabriel, and as such what it says is considered absolute by Muslims. But beyond that, there are people who claim to have heard Mohammad say other things, or observed his actions, or had him clarify the meaning of passages of the Qu'ran, which were then passed down through the centuries. These sort of sayings are called hadiths. Think of them as a bunch of extra rules and errata based on what someone says someone once said they heard Mohammad say. As you can imagine, there's a lot of contention about which are true or which override other things said, etc.

The divides in Islam, purely practically speaking, mostly relate to which hadiths are followed. Some minor sects include a belief in hadiths about violence to unbelievers, or using the sword to spread Islam, that kind of thing. Often they claim Mohammad himself spread Islam by the sword when first forming it (which is kinda debated but let's not go there), and that they're just continuing his example, whilst cherrypicking Qu'ranic verses that support their hadiths and ignoring ones that tell you not to fucking kill people. Out of a billion people, there's always bound to be a few nutjobs.

Think of it like if a bunch of 1970-year-old writings were found, by a dude who claimed he hung out with Jesus a bunch, who told him all nonbelievers must convert or be killed, and a new Christian sect formed around that idea to set out murdering people in some far-off country. Now imagine that sect of crazy violent Christians were the only real exposure you had to Christianity. That's how Islam is to many Westerners.

8
_CW13OP•

Thank you, great explanation from somebody who actually understood my question properly.

1
corpuscle634•

Often they claim Mohammad himself spread Islam by the sword when first forming it (which is kinda debated but let's not go there)

That is not an issue of debate, to be clear. Mohammad supported and engaged in acts of war in the name of God during his lifetime. He orchestrated a raid and capture of Mecca from his seat of power in Medina, and his armies eventually claimed most of the Arabian peninsula by force during his lifetime.

In the same way that Judaism and Christianity suppose their claim to the Holy Land (Israel) and justify taking said land by force, Islam unequivocally lays claim to Arabia and the Holy Land. Hence, you know... the whole Israel/Palestine thing.

Now, to be clear, I am absolutely not saying that Islam is more violent than other religions. Judaism (and, by proxy, Christianity) have tons of holy wars in their religious texts, and Christians sure as fuck have been the aggressor in their fair share of holy wars.

All I'm really trying to say is that it's disingenuous to pretend that Muhammad preached a message of Gandhi-esque peace, because that's just not true. Every Semitic religion has piles and piles of God-sanctioned violence in their holy texts.

edit: The real reason modern Islamic fundamentalism has developed is because of a man named Said Qotb. He's an Egyptian who spent time in America during the 50's, and was disgusted by what he saw as a hedonistic and materialistic society. When he realized how much America (and the West as a whole) was trying to influence Muslim countries, he got super fucking pissed. Egypt was being run (at the time) by a British-appointed government, and he did not like that. He started the Muslim Brotherhood (hear that name in the news lately?) and got himself arrested and subsequently executed. His writings are cited as an inspiration by pretty much every Islamic fundamentalist you could think of.

Basically, the point is that Islamic fundamentalism is actually pretty new. It's a radical movement by a very small group of Muslims. In the same way that Christian fundamentalism made huge waves in America in the 70's, Islamic fundamentalism made huge waves in the 50's in the Middle East.

second edit: I should also mention, to be clear, that 99% of what u/GirlGargoyle is correct, at least to my knowledge. I'm just correcting part of the post.

1
Kman17•

Islam is a religion of one billion followers. The handful of delusional extremists out there are not representative of the religion or culture. It's a lot like how there are extremist Christians here in the US (Timothy McVeigh, for example).

Islamic terror cells are motivated more by political goals than by strict adherence to the religion. Bin Laden repeatedly stated that his grievance with the US was meddling in the Arabic peninsula - funding puppet governments and maintaining military bases thought the Middle East, not some unintelligible religious reason.

The thing to remember about much of the Middle East is that everyone is religious... its kinda like how the US was back in the 50's. Remember during the Cold War, the US frequently cited God / religion more to differentiate ourselves from the 'godless' soviets for political reasons and to invoke moral superiority to justify actions, not to actually follow Christ's teachings. Same thing.

5
leSwede420•

Jesus christ you keep the stupid flowing with no stop.

It's a lot like how there are extremist Christians here in the US (Timothy McVeigh, for example).

How many nations are there that have laws in place that reflect the views of Tim McVeigh? Now how many strict Islamic states are there? A totally bullshit comparison.

Islamic terror cells are motivated more by political goals than by strict adherence to the religion

Islamic extremists see no difference between politics and religion you fucking idiot.

in Laden repeatedly stated that his grievance with the US was meddling in the Arabic peninsula - funding puppet governments and maintaining military bases thought the Middle East, not some unintelligible religious reason.

And here is where you completely show how incredibly stupid you are.

He was angry that the US had troops in the KSA, he wanted to fight Saddam with his people but the KSA decided America would be a better protector. He was angry that infidels were on his holy land and defending the KSA. That is an entirely religious view.

All you've done is spread ignorance, you need to shut the fuck up.

The thing to remember about much of the Middle East is that everyone is religious... its kinda like how the US was back in the 50's.

Jesus fucking christ, the middle east is nothing like 1950's America to giant gaping twat.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
macarthur_park•

He was raised Catholic. If I had to assign him a religion it would be some variant of Christianity.

McVeigh was raised Roman Catholic. During his childhood, he and his father attended Mass regularly. McVeigh was confirmed at the Good Shepherd Church in Pendleton, New York, in 1985. In a 1996 interview, McVeigh professed belief in "a God", although he said he had "sort of lost touch with" Catholicism and "I never really picked it up, however I do maintain core beliefs."

source

2
Kman17•

McVeigh was a Catholic. Granted, he was not devout churchgoer in his later years - but he claimed to follow core Christian ideals / beliefs. Near the very end of his prison stay he said he was agnostic.

The point being that McVeigh was a right-wing political terrorist with Christian beliefs, like many of the domestic terrorists we've seen.

Which is exactly what 'Isamic terrorists' are. If bin Laden was an Islamic terrorist, McVeigh was a Christian terrorist... but a much more accurate label for both of them is right-wing political terrorist. The religion is somewhat irrelevant to their core causes.

0
ACrusaderA•

If Christianity is a religion of peace, how do you explain the Crusades? Or Witch-burnings? Or the Papal Army?

If Judaism is a religion of peace, how do you explain Israel's fight with Palestine?

If the UN is a peacekeeping force, then why do they need lethal weapons? (Ok that one's a bit stupid, but at this point you see the theme)

4
anotherbrokephotog•

Logic and religion.

The original oil and water

-3
krystar78•

Just like Christianity has a commandment forbidding murder, the religious leader can claim that killing heathen is not murder, its religious justice. The whole crusades was based on that

2
Larry-Man•

When you cherry pick any holy book you can justify any action. You find the passages that most support what you want to do any follow those.

Leviticus is for owning slaves, against blended fabrics, and against homosexuality. Yet Jesus preached of love and acceptance. It's all in how you look at the book.

2
rewboss•

Most, if not all, religions advocate peace. But that doesn't mean all their followers adhere to their religions' actual teachings.

The word "Islam" -- which means "submission" -- actually contains the root s-l-m, which means "peace". The same root is found in "Muslim", which means "he who causes peace to be". And most Muslims -- there are about a billion, remember -- take that seriously and routinely denounce the violence perpetrated by some extremists. We get a distorted picture of what goes on because terrorist acts are front-page headline news, but a billion people saying, "Oh FFS, this is giving us all a bad name" isn't.

But to your question: How do they justify it?

What's interesting is that if you got a bunch of fundamentalists to take a test on the Quran, they'd probably do badly. There are some passages they'll know off by heart, but they'll be stunningly ignorant of most of the rest.

It's the same with fundamentalist Christians, and in fact a recent survey suggested that most of them confessed to not reading their Bibles at all. That's just the ones who admitted their ignorance.

So what you're looking at is not ordinary people who read a religious text and this then inspires them to commit violence. You're looking at people who feel persecuted in some way and have violent tendencies, and are then encouraged to commit violence. The process is called "radicalisation", and there are certain mosques that specialise in effectively brainwashing people.

Imagine a disaffected young man who recently emigrated from a Middle Eastern country with his family to London. They did so to escape the fighting there. He's been removed from the environment he grew up in and is now in a place that is totally alien to him surrounded by people he doesn't know. He meets a radical group of Muslims who know exactly how he feels. They explain to him the reason for the violence in his home: it's the greedy Americans who are prepared to spill blood for oil, and their friends the British. He is exposed to carefully-selected passages from the Quran -- passages which give instructions on how one should conduct oneself in time of war, but none of the other passages. The Quran isn't easy to understand, so of course he's dependent on clerics telling him how to interpret the passages he's reading -- and they can tweak their interpretations as they wish. The clerics can point to specific passages, taken out of context, that "show" that America and Britain are Satan, and that peace can only become a reality if Satan is destroyed.

The word "jihad" becomes relevant here. It has at least a couple of different meanings, but the two most important are the internal struggle to fulfil one's religious duties, and the external struggle against violence and persecution. Radical Islamists put more emphasis on the latter, and indoctrinate their disciples to believe that Islam as a whole is currently locked in a "jihad" against the entire western world, because the western world is persecuting Islam. In other words: "America started it! We're just defending ourselves."

2
_CW13OP•

Thank you, great answer.

1
MyOldMansADustman•

They justify their actions by quoting passages from the Quran that seems to fit their violence. Politics also helps a lot aka we're peaceful but DRIVE THE MURICANS FROM OUR LANDS! or PLANT BOMBS CUZ THE BRITS SUPPORT ISRAEL you know that sort of thing.

Side note:

As a Malaysian citizen almost everyone I know are Muslim. And a fun fact is that 99% of the 'average joe' Muslims would readily tell you that America has to be bombed (not joking here). BUT they justify it by listing political reasons, although American-Judaism relations also play a big part in their Casus Belli. When I mention that their religion is peaceful THEN they bring out the clause that talks about a holy war - Jihad.

Once again these guys aren't radicals; they speak and read english, shave their beards and act/talk in a Western manner. But all it takes are pics from the Syrian cities plus false photo captions to incite hatred against innocent people. Gosh my friend's older brother actually wanted to join the Mujahideen. Case in point: even the non-radicals think that way, or most of em at least.

2
bobdole3•

If Christianity is a religion based on love, why do KKK members hate people? Because there are assholes everywhere, simple as that. There's what, a billion Muslims in the world? Some of them are bound to miss the boat.

The reason you see so many "Islamic extremists" is a pretty complicated one that goes way beyond simple religion though. Part of it is simply that they're overrepresented in the media. A white guy who goes on a killing spree is a murderer, but a Muslim who does it is a terrorist.

More importantly though, many of the countries in the Middle East and Africa (which is where most of these extremists are coming from) are war torn and impoverished. Rule of law is weak, and the governments are often corrupt and brutal enough that there's no limit to people who are disenfranchised, and alliances are murky enough that you can justify just about anyone as a target. If all you've known for your entire life is that the government bombed your house, and you've heard stories that the government was put in place by the West (whether that's true or not is irrelevant), it's not really that much of a leap to want to attack them.

Quite simply, they are countries filled with people who are susceptible to joining terrorist organizations, who are unlikely to ever get apprehended when they commit a crime. The religion is anecdotal.

1
_mufasa•

they're not justified. you can't possibly justify this type of act. organizations such as Al-Qaeda are just terrorists who say they are killing in the name of God and Islam is their faith but no religious faith ( Islamic, Christian, Judaism, Sikhism, etc ) can justify these acts.

i can only just say they do what they do because of their lack of moral integrity and no love. a lack of respect for the life of humanity. they don't even respect themselves to that extent. But hey, thats if you ask me.

1
[deleted]•

What about the U.S then?

They are mainly bible bashers thumpers, they go to war too and kill innocent people.

0
rewboss•

bible bashers

In America, a "Bible basher" is one who criticizes the Bible. For somebody who is constantly preaching at people, Americans use the term "Bible thumper".

2
[deleted]•

Thanks, corrected it.

0