r/MMA•
random_sTp

[Official] EA Drama

Hey r/MMA, I have made this thread so you can chat to me directly, as the head mod I am ultimately responsible for the decisions here and also for the behavior of my team.

As you're all aware we have had quite the shitstorm over the EA competition, here is the original thread in case you didn't see it.

http://www.reddit.com/r/MMA/comments/25f3qv/official_ea_sports_ufc_ticket_giveaway/?sort=confidence

Its been very hard to try and have a reasonable discussion over this due to the vote brigading and users coming over from r/subredditdrama. There have been a lot of new accounts, troll accounts and users unfamiliar with r/MMA.

To most of the regular users you know I'm straight up and honest, I have never had a reason to lie, always willing to listen and discuss issues, feel free to go through my 5 years of comments and you will see that.

Time to get to the matter in hand...

We got approached at short notice for this competition and were trying to figure out the quickest and most efficient way of picking a winner, due to the short time constraints we felt it wasn't wise to make a thread for voting, we felt that if we did that then we might miss the opportunity completely. As you all know we virtually always get community input on decisions.

We got together and picked 12 users who in our opinions were going to be good representatives of the community, I know some of you might not agree but these are people we have personally dealt with and have had some positive influence on the sub-reddit.

Out of these 12 it turned out 6 were ineligible due to nationality, lack of passports and disabilities. This was our concern with the voting thread that it would turn out that people were ineligible and leave us no time to find an alternative.

As you all know one of those 6 people is a Mod. We honestly didn't see the issue with one of the mods taking part if the competition was being picked at random. Obviously this isn't the case.

I woke up this morning at 6am to a ton of messages via the modmail and have been trying to plow through them all day.

Yes, I will happily admit that we could've handled this better. Some of the comments by the mod's shouldn't have been made or worded differently. Not making excuses but its really hard to have multiple conversations while being abused and inundated with messages, emotions take over and people say the wrong things.

I have been in discussion with the admins and I am waiting on a response from them before we decide what to do. In the meantime one of the mods Avery (who has since stepped down due to the drama) has bought two tickets to UFC 174 out of his own pocket and has offered to donate them to a vote.

Personally I think the 5 that missed out should be put up for the vote but we will happily take suggestions.

This is the first time we have been offered something like this as a subreddit and it would be a damn shame if it never happened again due to this incident, we are truly sorry if we have left a bad taste with the user's, this certainly was not our intention. We honestly didn't think we had done anything wrong but can see how this would look.

As far as this thread goes please keep it civil and I will happily discuss this, if anyone gets abusive then I will remove the comments without warning, this goes for troll accounts or users that are less the 3 months old. I am not trying to censor people but there are already 3 threads to discuss how awful we are. I would also ask you all to look at the accounts that made the threads and some of the more vocal users, I'm sure you will see a pattern.

Thanks

random_sTp


BTW its getting quite late here in Australia and I have to be up for work in the morning, I'll probably be online for another hour or so, after that I will respond to the questions in the morning.


Also downvoting is doing nothing apart from making it harder for people to discuss this, I don't care about the karma I just want everyone to be able to see my replies.


It's late here so I'm going to sleep, I'll check on the thread in the morning.

Posted May 16, 2014, 10:56 AM UTC · edited

0285
Duckman_10Australia•

I'm not saying that there was any actual favouritism shown but surely you realise that it doesn't look good. This is why companies go to extreme lengths to eliminate even the appearance of a conflict of interest. Its like a company held a raffle and the CEO just happened to win. But not only that but the CEO won without people even seeing the draw. They just came on stage and announced the CEO won.

I don't really think this subreddit has terrible mods, most of the time I don't notice you (as mods that is) and thats how I think it should stay, but this definitely wasn't handled well at all.

Also J_Hall seemed like a real cunt in the other thread.

82
acemanrules92"Hot piss, ees normal"•

Agree with everything Duckman_10 has said here, especially the J_Hall point. IIRC this isn't the first time I've noticed him being a dick to some of the users.

27
CanniziDPVenezuela•

Sardonic humor is being a dick? You can't make satirical ripostes to someone who's being an actual cunt to you? People give that guy so much unwarranted shit, you don't think he's going to retaliate? I think he did it in the most innocuous way if anything. He could have just as easily lashed out at the subhuman pieces of trash that frequent his PM box and stalk him to the point of causing real life apprehension. You people are in favor of that?

Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with this subreddit?

-14
goldenticketstubUnited States•

Here's the issue: when you're discussing what happened in thread you're not really just talking to one person, you're talking to the entire community. If one person asks a question rudely and your response is rude, the community sees it as you being unwilling to discuss the issue. As much as you're willing to give him a pass for only being less of a dick than he could have been, he could have just not been one at all.

If people are making threats to your inbox it's a short order to report them to the admins and ignore further messages.

12
sm222Canada•

To put it in perspective the CEO of my company won a raffle once at a company party and he laughed and told them to do the raffle again so someone else could win.

14
pizdobol•

Yep, this is the reason why lottery ticket sellers are not allowed to participate

2
yushinokamithankyouMixed Martial Arts & Crafts•

Exactly, its perfectly reasonable given how quickly they were forced to organise the competition that they didn't realize how it would look to the community. Never attribute to malice what can be attributed to a mistake.

And in my experience at least, r/mma is a pretty swell place to be almost all of the time thanks in large part to the mods.

1
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Points taken...

And yeah, J-Hall did act a bit dickish, he has apologised for his behaviour. I can vouch for the dude and he is a really good guy, I know that won't mean much to you.

-10†
Duckman_10Australia•

Yeah, I get it. From your perspective you're picking trusted members of the community that will represent us in a positive light and you know this because their your friends, from everyone else you're picking your friends.

I kinda think responding to everyone in that other drama thread was a mistake. It made it an us vs you thing when it needed to be a discourse between everyone. This was a better response I think but you know hindsights 20/20 and all.

And to J_Hall, hey I've never noticed you before so it means, from my perspective, you're doing fine. The attitude in the other thread sorta screwed you before you began.

20
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Yep, should've stayed the fuck out of that other thread.

-3†
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

Why would it? People already get the idea that you are keeping stuff from them and now you are protecting "one of your own" after he acts like a total douche nozzle

8
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•

"a bit"

3†
[deleted]•

Also J_Hall seemed like a real cunt in the other thread.

I admittedly was.

I tried to force my reasoning down peoples throats, when what I ought to have offered was humility. That's tough to do when you're having your name drug through the dirt, but that's what needed to be done, and you're right, I was an utter failure today.

That's not the usual impression people get of me when I'm moderating, but I took things way in the wrong direction because I know we'd never rig this. That's naive, and Bees just shouldn't have been in this, because it's only going to look that way. I get that now, and can only try and get forgiveness.

Sorry.

-24
KittenMittonz69•

Thanks for being less of a dick now. You're still kind of a dick though.

21
Random_guess•

I will remove the comments without warning, this goes for troll accounts or users that are less the 3 months old.

As per u/random_sTp's own rules, u/J-Hall's comment needs to be removed from this thread as his account is less than 3 months old. Unless of course, random is enforcing a double standard.

14
HotPandaLove"Ask me how to pronounce Jędrzejczyk."•

Why would it be removed? It's not abusive or trolling, unlike many of the comments in this thread.

0
kingkongfooDenmark•

That's not the usual impression people get of me when I'm moderating

I'm sorry, but you don't get to decide this...

8
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

You can't undick yourself with an apology. You showed your true colors that moment...

5†
jwikkedAustralia•

Stop being a moderator in this sub. Give it up. That will go a long way to showing how sorry you really are for this debacle.

5†
[deleted]•

Done.

-3†
[deleted]•

Wait, you're not J_Hall...

1
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•

Avery, who was a much better mod than you, has resigned largely due to the fallout of your posts. Yet you're still here. Are you really, really that selfish?

-1†
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

Seems that way...like I have said before, J_Hall needs to leave in order to recover from his cunty comments

-1†
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

Don't go away sorry...just go away

-6
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

By the way, who are you referring to when you say "That's not the usual impression people get of me when I'm moderating". Are you taking about the six or so people that you discussed the contest with? Because that does not seem like a fair representation. Seems like most people here do think you are an asshole and should step aside

-10
jwikkedAustralia•

How much time was given for the completion of the competition? It's one thing to say it was short notice, but geez, even an hour on the forums would have made it more fair.

I think most people are angry because it was a bunch of mods choosing a fellow mod. Whether or not there was any bias is irrelevant, it just doesn't sit well with people.

-edit-

That J_Hall bloke is rubbing a lot of people the wrong way. His attitude has been confrontational and poor. In my opinion.

53
AntiMatterPhysics•

I have to agree. CC picked the final name randomly out of a hat so it's hard to believe it was directly rigged for the mod to win, but the mod's name shouldn't have been in the hat to begin with. not sitting well. not one bit.

24
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

See that's where the major problem is, we really didn't think it would be an issue if it was a trusted person doing a random draw, there was no way of us rigging that. I wish people had discussed this in the original thread, out of all the people I think only 2 had an issue. If it'd been discussed then we probably would've done something straight away.

-27
Like_Wild_Potato•

In case you can't see why people downvoted your post here, it's because you seem to have missed their point entirely.

So fucking what if it's random or not? The point you're missing is that it's improper for the mods to have ever been eligible in the first place. You get it?

9
thefunnyman88United States•

Thats why when there are giveaways, family members of people doing the giveaways are also not eligible to enter. Creates a conflict of interest just like this whole thing did.

5
[deleted]•

Also improper to not even attempt to include everyone... Also this is not a proper apology, they still can't admit they messed up. Nowhere does this post apologize, say sorry or admit error, just says sorry if what we did leaves a bad taste in your mouth, AKA if you don't like it, too bad.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Yeah, J-Hall has admitted he handled things wrong:

http://www.reddit.com/r/MMA/comments/25n2oh/good_job_rmma_you_made_rsubredditdrama_again/chjaoch

We all have.

-11†
shun-16Conor McGregoresque in moderating, Joe•

"Admitting he handled it wrong" after attacking a shitload of people and behaving like a child for days. This is a guy who has shown an inability to follow basic rules on this site, I don't care what the circumstances were for his MULTIPLE shadowbans, that is someone who shows an inability to use this site and he's in charge of a place where he's gone out of his way to alienate people.

I've been on this sub for years, I remember the lad days, I have been vocal about my support the direction this sub has taken, you guys say dumb shit here and there but that's reddit, we all gonna disagree on some shit. I think the addition of avery as a mod has been great I think he's done a great job being active and visible and explaining shit and I think a lot of the downvotes are unwarrented but that's how redditors do shit. I think J Hall needs to be seriously looked at, I get he's your guys buddy but modding shit isn't about hanging out with your buddies.

It's a thankless job and the only time people really talk about you is shit like this where you made a bad call, no one is ever gonna give you the respect or anything, but anyone who mods anything know this. You do it because you're passionate and you want to further something along and help others get into it. I can't speak to J Hall's passions but I can speak to his behavior which is not isolated to this incident.

This is certainly my favourite sports sub on reddit, one of my favourite subs as a whole, I remember when the front page consisted almost entirely of shit u/MattyBlaze posted, I remember the Lauzon shitstorm, I've seen just about everything that's gone on here. MMA and martial arts have been a big part of my life and this is the place I go to discuss it and read about it out of all the places on the internet. Yeah you guys made a bad call but it happens, I'm not holding onto it and others will eventually get back to MMA and leave this behind, but the J Hall shit, that is someone who doesn't respect this place and doesn't respect how he needs to carry himself. It's a bad look for you guys who do a lot of good shit on here.

7
LittleHoss•

But u/ialsolovebees is still the winner of the "contest" and is still going to UFC 173 in Vegas next weekend? And has EA said anything about this backlash from the community? Are they even aware?

4
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

These are based on Australian dates so may be a bit different for you guys...

We received the first email on the 9/5, we had to get a reply back by lunchtime of the 15/5, by the time the selected users had all replied it was the 12/5, then we had to email Chris and get him to do the draw. We then made the post as soon as he got back to us.

We didn't know how quickly Chris would respond or the users so we had to allow a day or so to ensure we didn't miss out.

-13†
jwikkedAustralia•

So roughly 120 hours worth of competition time.

10
matheusmcardoso•

You need at least 2 weeks to organize this kind of stuff. One month is optimal time. Don't forget people sleep, work and live beyond reddit in general.

0†
jwikkedAustralia•

Hindsight is a beautiful thing, but how difficult is it to have a post "for those who eligible on x dates, to do x, write in 100 words or less why you deserve this" leave it up for 72 hours and then everyone gets a chance. Hardly needs 2 weeks notice.

Again, it's easy to say this after the fact. Whatever. I appreciate that the mods are trying to make things right, and the sooner this is in the past the better.

13
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

Really? You need two weeks to do a raffle? Lawl

0†
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

Then those people are not eligible. Tough titties. Sometimes you just gotta get lucky, that is what a raffle is all about. You do not just make up the rules as you go along. Come on now

-1†
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Exactly, normally with voting and competitions we do them over a few weeks, not everyone uses reddit everyday.

-8†
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

It seems like a lot now but bear in mind we didn't want to pass up this opportunity, we didn't realize Chris was going to be so prompt or the user's would get back to us.

-8†
[deleted]•

My take on the situation:

We really messed up! Duh!

Seriously though at the time we got the message we panicked. We felt that the amount of time that we had was very short and looked upon things such as the logo contest, which took a week to get 4 responses, as a baseline for how long it would take for participants to arise for this competition. Of course in retrospect this was foolish. While we may have thought what we were doing was the best way around this, I now realise how this appears outwardly and how completely idiotic it was to add a mod into the competition when the potential for it appearing corrupt could arise.

I apologise profusely for how this situation came about, and twice over for how the aftermath was handled.

33
I_Bent_My_Wookie•

See you should be taking over. No shifting blame...just honesty. Gotta appreciate that

10
Wormwood03United States•

You are the only one that is handling it like a man. You accept blame, apologize, and i really believe you will do ur best to not let it happen again.

Stp and Hall will not admit fault but only try to dilute the mistake, shift blame, or dismiss everyone as trouble makers.

Time will tell your intentions, but bravo for sacking up and not trying to deflect.

6
stryfe604•

Using a contest to create an original piece of artwork and comparing it to just opening a thread with the rule of not nominating yourself is different. If that was your baseline, you guys were destined to balls this up.

3
[deleted]•

That seems to be the case, we really were complete idiots, plain and simple.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

Trust me, I'm baffled at what I was thinking too. This was a major cock-up on my part, simply put.

5
GentlemanJAustralia•

I appreciate the time you've taken to address the issue. I haven't wanted to put in my two cents as the vote brigading stemming from the SRD thread was ridiculous. But here is my thoughts:

  • It was probably wrong to include a moderator as a participant in competition, regardless of their contributions as even if controls are taken to remove a conflict of interest (by having the name pulled out of the hat) it was always going to end in some trouble. Especially when u/ialsolovebees isn't particularly active on r/MMA when compared to some members (although I'm sure he/she does their fair amount of mod work behind the scenes that they don't get credit for).

  • I understand that you would want to give the prize to an active participant of the subreddit and limiting the pool of candidates is a good way to do this but there were probably better ways of picking the people involved, such as asking the community for nominations. . I did just read below that it was meant for some to represent the community rather than an award for contributions. Regardless, I think the point still stands.

  • I'm extremely disappointed that Avery stepped down. He (or she?) was a fantastic mod who was very active in the community and the CSS update they prepared is fantastic. I would hope that he would reconsider. I wasn't aware he was even involved in the drama.

  • I'm also disappointed in the reaction of some community members. Although most people agree with the treatment of the competition as being subpar, to say the subreddit has turned to shit because of one incident is going a bit far. To those of us who were a part of the old r/MMA, you would know what shit was.

  • A quick look at u/ialsolovebees's account show's that pretty much everything (even dating back a few months) has been down voted. Who does this? Actually not that bad when looking at it again, but following them into threads outside r/MMA...

Overall, I've felt that the mods do a great job for this subreddit. Certainly better than the old r/mma days. But this whole fiasco wasn't one of your brighter moments. I hope the community and the mods can come up with an acceptable resolution to this and we can get back to talking about who Nick Diaz is going to fight. Putting this up for discussion and limiting the other mods involvement in this is a good first step.

Thanks.

28
XniklasXSweden•

I'm extremely disappointed that Avery stepped down. He (or she?) was a fantastic mod who was very active in the community and the CSS update they prepared is fantastic. I would hope that he would reconsider. I wasn't aware he was even involved in the drama.

I am too. The Sub looks and functions so much better since the changes were implemented. I also hope he reconsiders.

20
FlyingGogoplataIreland•

He made some great additions.

I was inspired for much of r/eaufcps4's (albeit terrible) design by him.

1
XniklasXSweden•

Also the speed at which he made the changes after getting suggestions was pretty cool.

2
FlyingGogoplataIreland•

Honestly the best mod I've ever witnessed.

2
[deleted]•

I can take all the heat, and people can act like I'm an idiot and an asshole, but this one really bothered me. I hope now that I'm gone Avery comes back.

People need to campaign for that, because that's the kind of guy who can really help take this sub places. Hopefully when this blows over he will consider returning.

-7†
Bees_else_Beads•

I sent him a message. Honestly I hope you come back too. I'm probably going to get hate for saying that because you were a dick in the other thread but imo that's forgivable. If you were abusing your mod powers banning people who disagreed with you or deleting comments you didn't like that would be a different story. I think that a mod should not have been in the running but I understand the thought process behind making sure we know who is going to be representing us in an official manner and agree with that decision. You guys did the best you could with such short notice and people running around calling "rigged!" clearly didn't watch the video of Camozzi pulling the name.

7
Wormwood03United States•

The majority of us arent claiming it was rigged. We are claiming it was corrupted by inserting mods name to begin with

5
ruffus4life•

i hope you understand that your own reaction led to this blowing up and had some role in Avery leaving. you still seem to lack the understanding of what you did wrong with the statement "people can act like I'm an idiot and and asshole" people only acted that way because of how you acted.

3
[deleted]•

Yeah, I do understand that, and I've messaged Avery apologizing. I feel really bad because I was the one who sought him out, and we were all extremely excited to have a guy like that on board.

There's not really much I can do now though, his decision is his decision, and he has to do what's right for him.

1
[deleted]•

I was just about to comment but find myself agreeing to all of this, especially the reaction of the community. Demanding mods to step down over something like this is quite mind-blowingly shortsighted. The main instigators of this down-vote campaign are people who've called users white-knights for challenging sexist comment they themselves have made, and yet a botched competition is worth your indignation?

The mods have made a mistake, have owned up to that mistake, let's all move on and carry on talking about fighting.

8
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Good points and well made...

I'm hoping Avery comes back, I have messaged him and given him the option, he is a great addition to the mod team and his skills helped change r/MMA considerably.

Oh, and Diaz vs Condit 2 - return of the spinny shit.

7†
BowdallenCanada•

I really hope Avery comes back, i appreciate what him and the rest of you guys do.

I like this sub because it's the best discussion place for MMA IMO, i hope this ridiculous drama can be put in the past.

24
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Me too, Avery is a great addition.

1†
allanchezar2•

I think you should hand over the subreddit to Avery and the rest of you should step down. I think he's the sole moderator who acted properly here.

7
[deleted]•

Tragically English did nothing wrong either.

7
MattyBlayze•

I'm not going to say I pay attention to every user who comments on r/MMA, but this thread seems to be full of the same users commenting over and over, and many of them are names that are completely new to me. The contributors to this sub that I've seen for years - u/tekprodfx16, u/joey6957, u/Jsalz, u/judokalinker, u/blueboybob, etc - seem to be refraining from this topic. Curious what they think.

Either way, regardless of the shitstorm that has hit (and who may or may not be behind it), and regardless of the r/HailCorporate shitstorm that some people seem to be expecting, I'd urge the mods to not cancel the trip. I do think things should have been handled differently and I don't think a mod should have been included in the list of finalists, but I also think it is awesome that EA saw this community as important enough to offer the opportunity, and I'd hate for us, as a community, to miss out on future opportunities because we've blown this horribly (and I believe, despite this uproar, we can still salvage the relationship...unless we cancel the trip).

23
AlantheCowboyKillerCanada•

Since I was one of those originally chosen for the draw, I feel obligated to put my two cents in here.

I've personally found the mods to be quite good here; if I message them about something (e.g. stuck submissions, user harassment, posting threads w/ spoilers), they are usually pretty quick and helpful. In my estimation they've done a lot to improve this sub over the years and help make it, imo, one of the best places to discuss MMA.

I do understand, though, that not all users here have had the same experience as mine. Though, I have seen plenty of people be complete cocks to the mods, and whether said cockery was warranted or not I cannot absolutely say, but based on my own experiences I would lean to the latter. At the same time, I do believe being a key part of being a good mod is to never act like a dick, even if he or she may be justified in doing so--it is just that essential part of representing the community.

I think situations like this do help, in a sense, to show both users and moderators what a good and bad moderating entails. It was good that the mods made this contest available to users; it wasn't good that the qualifications of being in the a draw were unclear (I was surprised that I was chosen over other good users here); it was good that the mods contacted an actual fighter and neutral party like like Chris Camozzi host the draw; it wasn't good that a mod was included in the draw. Again, I appreciated that I was recognized by the mods for being selected, but I did wonder why it wasn't a bigger draw.

Going forward, I'll agree with u/MattyBlaze here that the trip should not be cancelled, as, situation poorly handled as it is, it still is a nice opportunity for the sub (I'm hoping that u/ialsolovebees can make a good record of the experience, journal or album or otherwise).

EDIT: Also, u/avery_crudeman stepped down? That is really crappy. I've had nothing but pleasant interactions with the guy.

11
kyt•

Not to be facetious, but what would their opinion offer over mine or anyone else's? I'm a pretty avid reader of this sub but not that often of a poster/submitter. Their opinion carry any more weight than mine and frankly, anyone with sense would agree that the mods handled this entire situation poorly.

I have no idea if u/ialsolovebees deserves this trip or not. But I don't care that much. I hope he has a good time and reports back his experience. I would wish that for any mma fan who is lucky enough to have this opportunity.

My only concern is that the only time I and most people have even been aware of the mods is because they excercised such poor judgement that it's conceivable that their poor judgment isn't an isolated incident. I'm not calling for anyone heads because I don't really care who mods this sub as long as its done well. I think any reasonable person would question their judgement after this display. Maybe this sub is too big now for them?

8
MattyBlayze•

My point was that I question if this is really a big deal or if this is a couple of disgruntled people with fake accounts coupled with people who are only here because they like drama and found us from the r/SubredditDrama thread that are just going on and on about this.

It was telling for me that, when I commented, of the 150+ comments in the thread at the time, none were users with positive karma from me according to RES, and most didn't have any karma (positive or negative) from me period. Considering I'm pretty active on r/MMA and make a habit of trying to upvote/downvote everything to stimulate the discourse, that is very telling to me.

6
kyt•

I understand, but my point is that it doesn't matter if there are just a couple of trolls. This is a big deal because the community leaders of this subreddit completely mishandled the situation. By their own admission they botched it and I think most people would agree with that.

It's unfortunate that this thread is not as productive as it could be but I think it worth the effort to ignore the theater and understand the true problem.

3
MattyBlayze•

Yes, I don't think anyone denies this. I believe the vast majority, if not all, of the r/MMA populace agrees with you - including the mods. The mods screwed up and we expect this to improve going forward. Most of us were past this pretty quickly, though, I feel like, and it is my belief that the continuation of this "discussion" is the result of a vocal minority who may or may not be representative of what r/MMA really is.

3
internet_enthusiast•

but this thread seems to be full of the same users commenting over and over, and many of them are names that are completely new to me.

I'm pretty sure that's because many (most?) are puppet accounts run by the same person who's cyberstalked, trolled, and generally acted like an internet tough guy for the past year or more. For example, u/gato22, the OP of the SRD thread that started this whole thing, has been banned. I'm pretty sure he's running other accounts like u/GussyH and u/raciocination as well.

0†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
internet_enthusiast•

An eloquent defense, but I remain unpersuaded due to the highly suggestive evidence to the contrary. For instance:

  • Your account is one month old
  • You first and only submission is the one that alerts the r/mma community to the fact that there is an SRD post involving the EA contest.
  • Two of your five total comments (Here and here) make it clear that you've been around much longer than the account has.
1
suckyalexei•

God, Avery left..pretty much only him and tragically are worth a damn.

23
XniklasXSweden•

We need to convince him to rejoin. The changes he has made have significantly improved the experience here...

14
suckyalexei•

I agree 100%.

8
AlantheCowboyKillerCanada•

Personally message him. That or we can stand outside his window on a rainy night and hold up a ghetto blaster.

6
HotPandaLove"Ask me how to pronounce Jędrzejczyk."•

Rejoin, only to receive dozens and hundreds of abusive comments form people who are only interested in putting them down? Don't see why he would.

5
churrrls•

Yeah at the end of the day it seems to me all we are accomplishing with this shitstorm is making our whole community look bad.

2
goldenticketstubUnited States•

Not a question, but if you guys are actually that concerned with appearances you will apologize to each user you replied to with a snide, bullshit comment last night. That goes doubly so for you, random_sTp. Leaving out a non-apology apology 'we're sorry if we made you feel that way' really doesn't do too much.

16
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

I would check the users history of the people I was short with, then come back to me and if you still believe I am in the wrong then I will happily admit my wrong doings.

-16
Random_guess•

The age of an account does not take anything away from the validity of some of the points being made.

I will remove the comments without warning, this goes for troll accounts or users that are less the 3 months old.

This is unnecessary, comments that are snide or trolling should be removed but comments that actually add to the discussion in a constructive manner should not be removed solely based on a users account age.

By your own reasoning, If we're not applying a double standard here, u/J-Hall comments should be deleted from this thread if he posts as he's only been a member for a month.

6
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•

Considering u/random_sTp specifically pointed out that my opinions aren't valid because my account is 87 days old, I think it's pretty direct what he's saying. I post OC and try to dig to find things the board may have not seen, but since I registered technically less than three months ago, I'm not worth an opinion.

6
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

The reason for that rule is I know for sure some of the newer accounts are users that have been banned by us and their alt accounts, also I wanted to discuss it with the community that knows us and we feel we have wronged.

-12
Random_guess•

Fair enough, but I still think users that want to contribute to this thread constructively should be able to do so regardless of the age. Like you said

I know for sure some of the newer accounts are users that have been banned by us

Making a blanket rule to stop all users that have accounts less than 3months old from discussion is inappropriate. I want to reiterate that I don't have an issue with you removing snide or trolling comments that add nothing to the conversation. Heck, ban them if you think that's the right course of action. But the competition was meant to be open to

Any contributing member of the community

And not just the ones who knew you guys, therefore I think everyone who falls under that category should be able to discuss the issue.

6
goldenticketstubUnited States•

Well, it's a good thing that they're the head mod of this subreddit and not you because then I might be concerned with their behavior.

You've stated multiple times that you represent this community. Act like it.

3
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Honestly mate, I think I am. I'm not perfect but I am trying my best to be open and honest...

What more can I do?

-11
goldenticketstubUnited States•

Again, you could apologize to those whom you made the comments that resulted in this ongoing shitstorm.

0†
DuckedUpOnQuackPoland•

To be honest I'd say if J_hall wasn't being douchey about it then it probably wouldn't be as big of a deal...

I don't think it was rigged and I can see how bees is deserving of the prize. I can also see though when the contest happens behind closed doors and one of the mods is basically like "DEAL WITH IT" that people will naturally become upset.

I guess its a learning experience for next time!

EA: "WHAT DO YOU MEAN THEY DIDN'T BELIEVE IN THE RAFFLE!? MOD: "Sir one of the mods couldn't help being a condescending douche..." EA:"DAMN IT r/MMA IF YOU WANT CORPORATE SPONSORSHIP YOU HAVE TO MODERATE THESE PEOPLE TO BELIEVE!! CENSOR! MODERATE!

15
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

The guys were just going into damage control mode, they have openly admitted fault and have learnt a valuable lesson...

I was a mod with Ladt420 so I learnt my lesson a long time ago!

-6†
DuckedUpOnQuackPoland•

Yep, were all human and mistakes happen. Its crazy that some users expect mods to always be 100% right just because they have power over a sub. As long as mods own up to their mistakes and learn from them we should all improve as a community.

I was also under the impression that you are Australian... when do you sleep mate?

2†
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Heh, I should've been asleep a while ago, watching Red Dwarf in bed trying to keep up with this in my phone.

-3†
[deleted]•

What a totally contrived apology.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kingkongfooDenmark•

This was handled so god damn poorly... A raffle hidden from the users of the forum which led to a mod winning the only big prize ever given away in here... And then on top of that the mods get aggressive towards the users who voice discontent.

Also the 'apologies' are worthless. If you apologized like that to your girlfriends (assuming you have girlfriends) you'd be sleeping on the couch. 'I'm sorry you were offended' is not an apology, it's a contrived way of trying to reap the benefits of an apology without ever having to apologize. Keeping quiet would be better and less disrespectful.

Now I am not eligible for this prize no matter what, so this is not a case of 'if I can't have it, no one should'. The only fair way a moderator should ever get this prize is if he was chosen by the users of this sub. If he was a great moderator and really contributed as much to this sub as the mods claim, he could have been chosen fairly, but that isn't the case.

Avery is the only one who seems to get all of this (I don't know the guy, but he deserves to have his name mentioned). Apologize and remedy the situation. And yes, him buying tickets to give away is an unusual and very effective way of trying to show his regret about this whole matter, but when you fuck up big, you make up big. You take responsibility. Also for the other mods to use his actions seemingly as a way to say "but we did this to prove how sorry we are" is bullshit. He (Avery) did that. Not the mods and had I been him, I would have done that mostly to disassociate myself from the other mods who are still not handling this well.

The worst thing is that the only mod who seems to understand the users is the one that resigned as a mod because of all this. I just want to say to Avery that I think he should come back, he is the only mod I really trust after all of this... In the end the whole community loses something from all of this and one mod gains a free ticket to the UFC. It's almost funny... Almost.

15
[deleted]•

I really cannot overstate how much I agree this whole fiasco has been handled in a terribly poor manner. I take responsibility for the mess and apologise for all the trouble it has caused. We are currently in talks about our next step in rectifying this mistake.

7
kingkongfooDenmark•

Good on you, mate. I hope you guys figure out a way to get this sorted out properly.

0
AssholeinSpanishUnited States•

Although the situation is questionable, I'm willing to accept that the contest wasn't rigged. That however doesn't fully ameliorate the situation Mods, like Caesar's wife, should be above suspicion.

Mods, by nature or their position have control and power over the subreddit and it's users. They are users and members of the community, but they are inevitably apart from the community as a result of their powers and responsibilities- this divide is built into reddit's mod structure and will likely always persist.

As we've seen before, the power that Mods have allows the mod to manipulate and abuse users; this is precisely why Mods should try at all times to remain objective and project a selfless devotion to the good of the subreddit community through their mod activities. In doing so, mods can cultivate the confidence necessary to grow and better the community.

In selecting a user of the mod team for a contest, you've eroded the trust and confidence of the mod position and the subreddit as a whole. Even giving another mod the opportunity to receive some kind of material benefit will look like corruption. The inference of corruption- regardless of reality, is as problematic as actual corruption, when no evidence can be offered to the contrary.

Modding a subreddit is largely a thankless job, I'm sure. And users rarely acknowledge when a mod team is doing well, but are quick to criticize a team when they act in away that is questionable- but that's the job. Users want Mods to be selfless and put the community above themselves in the same way we want our elected officials to put the benefits of citizens above their own personal gains.

I think you are taking the right step in addressing this head on and engaging in direct communications with the community. The mod team has also taken a number of steps to make good on the issue, but confidence is easy to lose and difficult to regain. I hope that additional changes will be made to address these problems and make the community stronger.

12
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

Agreed...

Good points and explained well.

-5†
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•
  1. Starting off putting the blame on brigading, trolls, SRD, 3-month old users (nice subtle attack) is a shit way to start an apology.

  2. Avery wasn't the main problem. Their response was underwhelming (and a tad condescending,) but not attacking or offensive. The main problem was the way u/J-hall and, yes, u/random_sTp went about handling this. You could really learn from Avery about what you should do when you fuck up.

  3. I was hoping for a response from u/Tragically_English. Why isn't he the main moderator? He seems to be the only one with their head on straight.

But yeah, nice non-apology and blame-shifting, it's par for the course from yesterday.

12
[deleted]•

Point 1 is perfect. It is like if BP tried to discredit the oil spill victims by saying they're primarily leftists and environmentalists that were personally unaffected and now causing trouble.

Lol... Discredit the discontent... Awesome apology! bravo! No lesson learned at all

7
[deleted]•

Since u/random_sTp seems to not be taking this seriously (blaming it on trolls, or you having a grudge), I just want to add, I read this subreddit everyday, and I 100% agree with everything u/GussyH is saying.

He's laying out the exact problem, and the exact solution. u/random_sTp and u/J-hall should step down.

1†
DuckedUpOnQuackPoland•

English people devote most of their day to being English. NO TIME TO MODERATE

0†
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

I won't remove you as I know you even though your account is 87 days...

Mate, honestly you have had a grudge against me and a few of the mods since you appeared here. It seemed to start of the first gif Sunday thread, you got pissy over us making that thread IIRC.

-10
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•

I already told you: I don't like it when mods stick their business into where they aren't welcome. You actually unstickied a useful post that took time to make so you put up "Post your gifs LOL" for no reason. It has nothing to do with my gif of the day threads, since I planned to, and did, continue them. What don't you understand?

6†
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

We put up one of our regular threads, the other thread had been up for a few days IIRC. The regular thread was actually requested by the users!

-5†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
XniklasXSweden•

Unfortunately so do the trolls and people with gripes.

3†
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•

Now to get to the actual contest.

You absolutely cannot have a community contest with no community involvement. It blows my mind that you thought that was okay. You didn't pick top contributors to the board. You picked twelve users based on how you feel about them emotionally. Lots of better contributors got glossed over, why? Because you picked solely on who you wanted to go. Absolute mod power over the contestant: corruption #1.

And why did someone who barely ever contributes get nominated (by mods)? Literally solely because he was a mod. You said it yourself, he does mod stuff behind the scenes. Corruption #2.

And of course this was all in secret. Not a word of dissent allowed because no one knew about it. Zero community involvement for something was supposed to be for the community. Corruption #3.

A mod winning it was just the boiling point. The rest shows corruption, that you think you have absolute power over this board. All you've shown is that no one should go to the mods to handle something like this, because you cannot handle the responsibility. That's why you're shitty mods.

11
[deleted]•

I agree on most points here. I disagree with the word corruption and would like to replace it with idiocy though. We had no intention of rigging anything up so that a mod one and at the time didn't see the problem with having a mod involved. However, that doesn't make the situation better. I'm racking my brain right now trying to solve what was going through my mind that I thought it would be ok to have a closed door community raffle. I can't go back and change that foolishness, all I can do is apologise and hope that it goes somewhat of a way to making amends.

12
Grimmbles•

I disagree with the word corruption and would like to replace it with idiocy though.

I do wish more of the riled members could realize this. Folks want this to be some far reaching mod conspiracy with forethought and planning. It's a classic case of Hanlon's Razor.

Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity.

Mods fucked up by including a mod. It's that simple, no plan no scam no rigging, just simple lack of foresight. Some of them realize this now. Others(random) seem to be taking the classic celebrity "apology" method of apologizing if anyone was offended while not actually admitting what they did was wrong. But the threat of future public shaming works as well as actual realization in this case and should fix this going forward.

2
GussyHVitor needs to shave his Jesus mullet•

I'm trying to give context to being called corrupt. Do we literally think that you had CC write the mods name on all the drawings so the mod is guaranteed a win? Of course not, but it seems that's what random thinks we're saying. But everything else, while it could just be a series of bad choices, stinks of corruption because you guys have power over this competition, and abused it.

But I maintain that you're the only one who has actually made an apology. This whole thread is definitely a half-hearted "sorry that you're offended" and acting like this is SRD's fault, and not the mods. I'm going to be honest, I expected and hoped this thread was going to come from you.

-2†
[deleted]•

Yeah I agree on that part. From an outside perspective all this looks like is us suddenly springing up and saying 'Hey, a mod won a user raffle!'. And even then I now realise he shouldn't have been involved in the first place for the sake of transparency.

As for me posting the thread, It was already up by the time I had arrived home from work.

12
NOSaintsBeans16United States•

It's kind of impressive that you're the only mod not getting down voted

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
TheMeatballOfficial Naysayer•

lol, you should check out any thread discussing the Condit/Diaz fight. Or even the first Weidman/Silva fight. LOTTA downvoting.

7
DaBakeEverybody underestimates the kick to the groin•

Or Vitor threads, or Fallon Fox threads, or Bellator threads, or really just any thread that isn't about Pride.

9
EdamusWhat Would Chael Do?•

This is the only subreddit I frequent -- practically daily. I can honestly say that I've never even noticed you guys (the mods). There was that incident a few months -- maybe more -- where there was backlash for a mod acting like a cunt and the r/mixedmartialarts was made. But, I don't remember what the reasoning was specifically.

This opportunity from EA was, in large, a great opportunity for our subreddit and we kinda blew it. I'm not sure how much they read or others do, but offering a a contest like that and having the shitstorm brew up afterwards does not bode well in the return of future offers. Mods are humans and are normally downvoted into oblivion -- it is a thankless job and that a lot of the times is the source for being cantankerous. However, as leaders of the subreddit, you shouldn't have included anyone in the contest who was a mod. The hive mind is powerful...

I'm sure the mods have learned and will hopefully continue to better themselves and the subreddit.

10
jnthnsuTaiwan•

Hey I appreciate the mods trying to rectify the situation and some even admitting to their mistakes. It's a hard pill to swallow and I hope all of these downvotes that are raining down upon the mods or anyone trying to say anything other than "fuck the mods" are mostly from trolls and not members of our community. That being said, with the mods realizing that they should not have included one of their own into the already small unannounced pool, I'm on the fence on whether or not the winner should have forfeited their prize. I understand it's a once in a lifetime event and plans have already been made, but so is being a moderator to one of the largest growing online mma communities(be it a thankless job). But at least a clear statement from the mod who won on the situation and not all of the surrounding cast members trying to defend themselves.

9
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

I have asked the other mods to stay out of this thread so I can talk to the community directly, if needed we can make another thread tomorrow to discuss it as a group. I thought it best to give you all the opportunity to voice your concerns with me.

-4†
HipOutUnited States•

As you all know one of those 6 people is a Mod. We honestly didn't see the issue with one of the mods taking part if the competition was being picked at random. Obviously this isn't the case.<

Except it wasn't random if you pre-selected 12 people. It is so simple and clear to me that this is a conflict of interest that I am baffled not one person who was involved in this decision brought it up. You're MODERATORS, it's your job to moderate discussion and leave important decisions to the community, IMHO. You should have been far more transparent.

How much of a window period did you have to decide? I'm curious. it seems that you left that out intentionally. If you put up a stickied post explaining the situation you would have gotten feedback from dozens if not hundreds of users within hours providing solutions and quickfixes to the problem; whether it be nominations, polls, entries to a raffle, etc.

People seem extremely excited about sponsoring Camozzi -- I think people would be equally excited to hear that EA is giving us props by providing a free trip and r/mma users have a chance to be a part of that. This would have been a huge feather in the cap (or fedora) for all of us who care about this sub but the first I ever heard of it was because of this controversy.

EDIT: Apparently the mods had 6 days to decide a winner. That seems MORE than enough time to have brought it up to the community. Source

9
fartcityallstarsViet Nam•

Instead of avery buying tickets, why don't the original tickets just get put back up for vote?

8
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

The ticket has already been confirmed for Bees, it's past the deadline now and to get another user switched over I don't see happening in time. If anything the ticket would just be scrapped and nobody would get it. This isn't my decision and I have stated that I'm trying to discuss it with the Admins.

-9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Lobster_Man•

so no one even bothered to try to find out? unfortunate that is...for everyone else but not the so-called "winner" hmmmm

1
judoxingViet Nam•

Thanks Random, hope this gets buried quick. R/mma is by far the best place on the internet to discuss shit, debate shit, see instant gifs of shit, have shits and giggles, make bets about eating shit, lose your shit, etc.

One thing that hasn't been mentioned is that Matt Brown nearly slipped ass up on his walk out last weekend, than he did this little ninja duck and weave to try and cover it up. Thats why he lost the first couple of minutes, took him a while to recalibrate. Haha, good times right? Now we're all mates again!

8
random_sTpOPDown under and cant BBQ to save his life•

I didn't notice that, I'll have to go back and rewatch it tomorrow.

-3†
judoxingViet Nam•

Just as he goes through the entrance and into the main arena. Like a ninja.

3