BigFailureOPFail big. Fail really big.•

Taking adivce from this thread.

3
VWftw¯\_(ツ)_/¯•

Fantastic idea! Here is the canned script I use for these emails, free free to copy and or modify it for your personal use.

Dear (Name of official here),

I write to you today about the future of The Internet, which is Americas most democratic medium. The exponential growth of the internet has powered innovation and altered how we communicate beyond any previous medium. Network neutrality is the guiding principle that has allowed for these advancements.

For-profit interests want to destroy the principle of network neutrality in order to increase their own profit margins. This is a gross injustice to the people of this country and private interests must not be allowed to destroy the free and open culture of the web.

I strongly urge you and your colleagues in Congress to support your people and their desire for net neutrality legislation that prohibits network operators from blocking, impeding or interfering with any lawful Internet traffic or prioritizing any content or services.

1
bad_tuna•

Thanks for this. I will be doing this everyweek for the next four months.

1
fargoguy_105Flair Rocks•

Good idea!

I actually kinda hope they go through with it, and make "fast lanes". The current version of the internet is overwhelmingly commercial and controlled by big business and government. If it got "bad enough", we might see more investment in alternative approaches to networked communication, either over broadband or not...those versions probably won't have netflix though, so I'll be really angry about that.

-5
spoonchild•

I get your thought, the problem will be the only people that could afford it or that wouldn't get squashed trying to get their word out would be these giant corporation that control everything. Since anything smaller would get throttled as they couldn't pay and people would not know they exist because if you look all of your packages for internet say "Up to XXMbps". This means that if you get a .0000000001 bps you are still within the means. It will only take 10 years for the simplest of webpages to open at that speed and they could do that for anyone that doesn't pay their fees. This is why it's so important that we work to keep the internet open and neutral.

3
fargoguy_105Flair Rocks•

Hmm...I'm not quite following you on that one. I'm envisioning "mesh" networks that might help reduce the load on one specific internet connection. Think how Uber and AirBnB are revolutionizing the "sharing" economy, and now imagine you could do that with your internet connection!

Another point I'd like to make on this is what about people who "Work from home". There will either be "approved" VPN systems that the ISPs allow into this "fast" lane (which could then be used to send any traffic), OR, ISPs will have to monitor all the traffic (work) these people are doing! This sounds like the END of working-from-home to me! (I don't think that's really going to happen, but I CAN see the ISPs trying to get more money out of users who use their connection for "business-use".)

Thanks for continuing the discussion!

-2
BigFailureOPFail big. Fail really big.•

I think you are under the impression that there is some sort of "internet congestion" currently. The only congestion we may have is due to the technology used in the "last mile" to your house/business. Coaxial cable and telephone wires are decidedly slow, and the networks that are built around them aren't tailored to scale as well. This is a huge failure by our ISP's and their lack of incentive to innovate - its not a problem of the internet itself.

Regarding your "mesh" network, you are describing peer-to-peer that already exists. Creating an "internet fast lane" would not allow those networks to move any faster, nor would it help improve the speeds of other large corporations. In fact, if the current proposal were to go through, the telco's would have incentive to limit the traffic from peer-to-peer connections in favor of big business.

For example, lets say you were buying content from someone directly in your neighboring state - however apple also sells that content. Apple would pay the telco's to give themselves a "fast lane" and they would impede the traffic from your neighbor so you would be forced to buy from apple. Where is the innovation there? Sounds terrible to me.

*edit: for more information, read this

2
netGuy70•

This should be a good read for you on the foundation of what's at stake .. it's a lot more important then the the last mile scenarios posted here.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_carrier

1
autowikibot•

#####

######

#### Common carrier:


A common carrier in common law countries (corresponding to a public carrier in [civil law](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_law_(legal_system\)) systems, usually called simply a carrier) is a person or company that transports goods or people for any person or company and that is responsible for any possible loss of the goods during transport. A common carrier offers its services to the general public under license or authority provided by a regulatory body. The regulatory body has usually been granted "ministerial authority" by the legislation that created it. The regulatory body may create, interpret, and enforce its regulations upon the common carrier (subject to judicial review) with independence and finality, as long as it acts within the bounds of the enabling legislation.


^Interesting: ^E-carrier ^| ^List ^of ^common ^carrier ^freight ^railroads ^in ^the ^United ^States ^| ^Freight ^forwarder ^| ^Mobile ^phone

^Parent ^commenter ^can [^toggle ^NSFW](http://www.np.reddit.com/message/compose?to=autowikibot&subject=AutoWikibot NSFW toggle&message=%2Btoggle-nsfw+chkysqq) ^or [^delete](http://www.np.reddit.com/message/compose?to=autowikibot&subject=AutoWikibot Deletion&message=%2Bdelete+chkysqq)^. ^Will ^also ^delete ^on ^comment ^score ^of ^-1 ^or ^less. ^| ^(FAQs) ^| ^Mods ^| ^Magic ^Words

1
VWftw¯\_(ツ)_/¯•

I always laugh at this stuff. No government can run the internet, laws of countries mean nothing to dedicated nerds. Perfect example; Pirate bay.

-8
BigFailureOPFail big. Fail really big.•

Yeah, but this is different. The ISP's could throttle the protocol that we use for torrents so that regardless of whether the torrent worked or not (or if you could find it), it would be incredibly slow. As far as netflix is concerned, i believe they transmit over HTTP so they would have to throttle the IP addresses of netflix - so netflix could try to hack their system to make it look like the videos are streaming from somewhere else, but those would continue to get caught and it would be a perpetual "cat and mouse" game - leading to instability in the service itself, most likely.

Its just not how we should proceed, with hacks upon hacks.

4
VWftw¯\_(ツ)_/¯•

Hacks upon hacks is equivalent to innovation upon innovation. It is the nature of the information game.

The human element of legislation and regulation is quite literally so far behind in this game that any given majority have to catch up by making it into a social issue. You don't want the small private interests running the whole show? Well, those private interests are also behind, so I say fear not.

It's the future. There will now always be groups of individuals advancing methods of exchanging information faster than any majority will ever have time to catch up to it, let alone regulate it.

0
fargoguy_105Flair Rocks•

Yeah, your last paragraph is kinda what I was trying to say too. Let them kill THIS incarnation of the internet...we'll be partying elsewhere!

1
VWftw¯\_(ツ)_/¯•

Hah, well if you'll notice I also agree with the contacting of the representatives.
It's good to keep the fight up on all fronts, as well as exploring the frontiers with no current oppositions.

0