r/SilkRoad•
polvb

Is it necessary to tumble bitcoins in order to buy stuff on SR?

Does it even make a difference? I heard that people can track it through the blockchain anyway. Would it be a bad idea to just send my BTC straight from Coinbase to SR?

Posted May 20, 2014, 2:48 AM UTC

911
Verzero•

It makes tracking you much more difficult. Would you rather they find you right away because it lead straight to you? Or be tangled with thousands of other addresses that would take god knows how long to find. Better safe than sorry.

11
SoCo_cpp•

necessary? Is it necessary for me to drink my own urine? Probably not, but I do it anyways because It's sterile and I like the taste.

10
[deleted]•

Yes it's necessary and yes you should. You're committing multiple felonies so you should probably go ahead and keep your asshole safe and sound.

9
evilbrent•

I'm no expert, but I understand that it's a good idea but not strictly necessary.

On the off chance that they DO ever go through the blockchain and start tracking people down, they're going to go after the people they think of as the serial offenders first. If you're spending $1000/month on drugs on an ongoing basis, then, yes, it's probably a good idea to cover your tracks. If you spend $75 once, and then don't buy drugs for another two years, you probably don't have as much to worry about.

It's only technically possible to determine your identity from the block chain, and my understanding is that it requires multiple data points to pin you down, and anyway, your one little $75 transaction in a sea of $1000/month transactions is going to be a blip on the radar. Remember that they can't tell the difference between your untumbled transaction and all the thousands and thousands of tumbled coins, until they track each and every one of those tumbled coins to figure out that they're dead ends - which they might not be, all those tumbled coins aren't swapped for new coins, they might well be swapped for the coins of a serial killing assassin and they might want to have a really really good look at why you've suddenly got them.

Long story short, don't take my word for it because I've never even bought a bitcoin in my life and know nothing about it. How much risk you're willing to take on is your choice. Good advice would be to lessen the risk if you can.

6
sqoatz•

no

5
Lookingforclarity•

This guy is to comfortable.

6
AutismHour•

dumb question yields dumb answer.

OP might as well have asked, "do i HAVE to get a speeding ticket if I get pulled over by a cop going 10 over?"

answer: probably, but not necessarily

simple answer: no.

3
DilbertPickles•

No, it is not mandatory. However it is HIGHLY recommended. Find a good tumbling service and tumble your coins before sending them to SR. Some people even recommend tumbling your coins twice or even thrice for large transactions that may be of more interest to authorities.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Brendanten•

bitcoin fog is great

realnet address :http://www.bitcoinfog.com/

deebweb address: http://fogcore5n3ov3tui.onion/

1
AutismHour•

are you trying to ask if SR outright prevents you from making purchase using coins that haven't been tumbled? no.

are you trying to ask if it is completely safe to order without tumbling your coins? well, that's like me asking someone if a certain stock will go up or down tomorrow ... no one can tell you that

1
snowypile•

Always tumble your bitcoins, no exceptions!!!!!!

I tumble my bitcoins multiple times before it gets sent to SR.

1