Judge Paul Muscat questions young males facing sex prosecutions when girlfriends avoid charges
abc.net.au/news/2014-05-28/judge-questions-un...Posted May 28, 2014, 5:49 AM UTC
Posted May 28, 2014, 5:49 AM UTC
Damn right. Good on Judge Muscat.
This is fucked up on so many levels. For one, having the age of consent at 17 is unrealistic and problematic. 16 would be more reasonable and more in line with the majority of states (only SA and VIC have it at 17).
Second, there's a reason the boy was charged here. It's due to society's idea that males are always the sexual aggressors - that sex is something a man does to a woman rather than something they do together.
Judge Muscat said the girl also would be liable for prosecution for sexual activity that occurred when the boy was underage, but he never had seen such a case in the Youth Court.
Really though, no one deserves to be charged here at all. This is a great example of why every jurisdiction needs Romeo-and-Juliet exceptions to their statutory rape laws (exceptions when a young couple are close in age). As u/Alaric4 pointed out, SA has some of the most restrictive Romeo-and-Juliet type exceptions in Australia.
Now, the girl says some of the sex was also coerced. Fine, if that's the case then bring actual rape charges against him. But they haven't done that they've just got him for statutory rape.
I think this would be worth cross-posting to r/mensrights as well.
Now, the girl says some of the sex was also coerced. Fine, if that's the case then bring actual rape charges against him.
Except that's never going to get up, due to lack of evidence. So the DPP have gone with a more easily proved offence. Happens all the time with all sorts of offences, even murder.
The judge is very lucky the previous DPP is no longer in the job. He'd be marking remarks about the DPP, and not the judiciary, being the body to determine charges. If the judiciary wants separation of powers, then it should realise that the principle cuts both ways. It could well be in the public interest to charge one partner and not the other. That isn't for the judge to decide -- or even to comment upon in his official capacity -- but for the DPP.
The boy was charged because he was a legal adult, and the girl wasn't. This wasn't two minors.
It's a pretty stupid law to begin with, quite a lot of teenage relationships have an age gap by a couple of years. 16-18 year old relationships would almost all involve sex.
The law is different in every state. (Claims to be accurate as of Nov 2013).
All states except NSW have some sort of tolerance for consenting acts between under-age participants of similar ages, but the SA exception is one of the narrowest, in that it still doesn't allow for consent as a defence if the complainant is under 16, and only allows it in relation to a 16yo if the defendant is also under 17.
Much broader exceptions apply in Tasmania (allows for a five-year age gap down to age 15 for the complainant, and a three-year age gap down to age 12) and the ACT (two-year age gap down to age 10).
That last one seems very low at first, but then I'm not sure charging an 11yo would be the right solution either.
EDIT. See correction below by u/CuriousPenguins regarding QLD and NT.
Queensland has no legislative tolerance for something such as a 15-year-old and a 16-year-old relationship with a sexual element. The tolerance for that kind of thing is in a direction to the ODPP that they should not prosecute such things.
The only defence Queensland allows is a reasonable belief the other was 16 or above. That kind of defence wouldn't apply to a scenario such as this, for example, I'd suspect. Just checking your link more, all states bar QLD, NT and NSW make exceptions based on close age. QLD and NT make defences for reasonable belief. NSW makes no defence. (note those with age similarity defences may also have reasonable belief defences.)
You're right. I didn't read it as well as I should have.
Why the hell does SA use 17 anyway? Australia is small enough a national age of consent at 16 is fine.
Can I ask why the nation size matters?
Somewhere like the USA or India might have enough cultural difference between regions it might make sense to have different ages.
Ah, that makes sense. Cheers.
These days the cultural differences are not so much about regions but more about the group people identify with, those differences exist also in Australia.
You could say that about any law. Competition between the states should be encouraged.
Damn straight. Lucky for that kid he doesn't live in the US or his life would be ruined forever but fucktard judicial zealotry.
[deleted]
http://www.aifs.gov.au/cfca/pubs/factsheets/a142090/
Because the age of consent is 17, and unlike other states, doesn't allow for similar ages, except for two people of 16 years of age.
Anyone else feel like people do actually need to check the laws before they jump on a bandwagon? Personally, I prefer the Tassie laws based on that little rundown...
<12 years old - illegal
12-15 - up to 3 years older
15-17 - up to 5 years older
I am a sex criminal. And so is my x 22 odd years ago. Lock me up fools cause 15 year olds fucked.
edit: sorry i lied i was 16. I fucked my maths up. Police stay home now
Hold your horse everyone. Boy was 18, girl was not.
The mother contacted the police because a legal adult had sex with her underage daughter. The judge has decided the 18 year old was immature and there was a previous sexual relationship, so he probably won't get a custodial sentence.
Nothing to get all frothy about here. If anything the judge is making some pretty off remarks about rape, that if you have had sex before it doesn't count, and that teen girls often go through the embarrasment of bringing charges of rape just because a relationship breaks up. Both of which are total bollocks.
But whatevs. We don't know anything about the case, and the judge may have been taken out of context. We don't even know how old she was. Move along.
The boy was under 18 (17?) when they started having sex, the girl was 15. Regardless of what the law says, that's not rape. That's two teens in a consensual relationship.
This boy was charged because it's always the male's fault. Because society views sex as something males do to females, not something that males and females do together.
The article also says that some of the sex was coerced. Now if they want to go and charge him with actual rape that would be appropriate. But they haven't done that - they only charged him with statutory rape.
Nothing to get all frothy about here. If anything the judge is making some pretty off remarks about rape, that if you have had sex before it doesn't count, and that teen girls often go through the embarrassment of bringing charges of rape just because a relationship breaks up. Both of which are total bollocks.
Bullshit. He never said the former, and in the latter case he was referring to this case specifically.
If someone is 18, and someone is 15, which is what this case is about, that is statutory tape in any jurisdiction I have knowledge of. A 3 year gap isn't protected anywhere AFAIK.
You can claim the children can consent all you want, but it doesn't make it so.
The "similar ages" clauses aren't even about consent. There is still no legal consent. It is just understood the harm of charging them both is higher than preventing the harm of non consensual sex.
The age gap between them did not get wider just because he turned 18. That doesn't make him an extra year older - they would still be however many months apart. My partner and I are 9 months apart in age. If one of us has a birthday, that doesn't change.
There is still no legal consent.
Yes, there is no legal consent but in reality, in fact, it was consensual.
If you think this was a case of the boy raping the girl then you are delusional and need a reality check.
The reason for laws. You don't understand them.
He claims that he was 17 on the fateful night of the alleged banging.
The article says he admitted his guilt.
Yeah, guilty of breaking the law, which is a bullshit law.
Everywhere should have a Romeo and Juliet exception to their statutory rape laws - and exception for young couples who are close in age.
But, that's why he's being charged, and the girl isn't.
Because legally, he commited a crime, and she didn't...
WE CANNOT start enforcing laws only when we think it's right, that can only ever end up ending badly.
Different article to the one I read. It had:
The boy’s lawyer told the court his instructions were the boy was under 18 when they had sex.
Not real sure where you are pulling that from. The judge states that for him to be charged, she should be too, so their ages would have to be similar.
Maybe try reading the article next time
Straight back at you dickhead.
No mention of rape, yet you try to make it an issue.
In an article about a guy being found guilty of non consensual (definitionally) sex?
What a leap of logic!
The thing you said isn't in the article. Read it again.
Damn straight. The DPP should have calmly refused to prosecute such a matter... what an absolute joke.
Think how fucked up that kids whole life would have been if he happened to get a different judge.
I can't imagine any judge giving any real sentence for this, which just makes the DPP's decision to prosecute all the more strange. Perhaps they genuinely do believe there was some aspect of coercion but couldn't prove it so they wanted to get him on this lesser crime... That would still be disgusting.