What are people's opinions on the possibility of Turkey joining the EU?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accession_of_Turkey_to_...Posted May 28, 2014, 10:29 PM UTC
Posted May 28, 2014, 10:29 PM UTC
I'm all for it. It will only speed up the disintegration of the EU which can only be a good thing
Turkey...Ukraine....mon over
[deleted]
Yeah, except if anything the possibility of EU membership gives an incentive to governments like Turkey's to respect human rights. But of course they should not be considered for membership until they improve their conduct in that area.
I don't think that Germany would be in favor of this as they have a huge Turkish population already and would be a magnet to an open boarder scheme. I believe some time ago Merkel had to go on the defensive and say that multi-culture in Germany had failed because of unrest from the German populous towards the Turks.
I think we should be good, powerful Europeans committed to the European Project and give them our spot.
Selfless humanitarian I am.
Perhaps when they aren't busy suppressing dissent this would be a more sensible discussion?
A positive thing and might force change in their country aslong as Erdogan and his cronies have been given a swift boot
Turks should not be allowed free movement however
sod it lets keep going and put Syria, Iraq and Iran in as well. There is plenty of money going around to keep adding to the bureaucracy of the EU.
Terrible idea, as things stand.
Once they've fixed their human rights issues, maybe. But absolutely nothing's going to happen until they withdraw from Northern Cyprus.
They're occupying what the EU considers to be half the territory of one of its member states with military force. Greece and Cyprus will veto the fuck out of any accession attempt until that issue's dealt with.
No objection to the Turkish people. Plenty of objections to the Turkish government.
Europe already has enough countries with corrupt Governments. It needs to put it's own house in order first.
In the long run it could be a good thing but given how long "negotiations" have been going on and the pace they have taken I don't see it happening anytime soon.
I remember when they started to make progress with their separatist issue and things kept looking up for Turkey but now you have the current government mess and cyprus is still an issue which will make joining not even a possibility for many years.
I think they should join but not quite yet, they have some big social factors that they need to get sorted. As an economic member they would be great because of there population size, one country that would really benefit would Greece from it having a open market neighbor.
I think people who are comparing Turkey to syria or Iran, don't understand Turkeys much more western style government secular liberal constructs due to the pre-ottoman rule. Most people seem to think "Muslim your a Islamic country!!!!" but Turkey has more in common with its Balkan neighbors then its eastern Muslim ones.
Integrating Turkey would be a create symbol to the EU, having a Muslim country in the EU would give the EU greater legitimacy on the international scale.
I would like to see them join but they have to solve a few social and political issues first.
If Turkey ever meets the criteria they should join. It would drastically boost the overall power of the EU and its bargaining position with the world at large.
Right now Turkey is veering away from the criteria rather than towards them.
Turkey should definitely have the possibility, but they're not ready. The EU has already been a great thing for Turkey, leading them towards more democracy and respect for human rights, but that work is far from done.
When they fulfil the Copenhagen Criteria, I don't see why they shouldn't be able to join. But that's – at least – 25 years in the future, perhaps a lot more.
Arguments for: Inclusiveness, more collective power, Turkey has a fantastic army who would be a key asset in any future EU defense/foreign policy, promotion of stability in the region
Against: Plenty of uneducated and poor kurds (20%) who inhabit the east, there would be massive resistance against free movement of these people who are basically nomads and run a big drug smuggling trade. This is a unresolved problem and it has been since the Treaty of Lausanne was signed by the Allies and Turkey in 1923, establishing Turkeys borders, which included large parts of the region now known as Kurdistan.
In context. When Blair pushed for this and got 'candidate status' for Turkey back in 2004, the EU was a rather different place. We had just enlarged to allow some Eastern Europe countries. The EU has seen stagnation, with a loss of influence in the Euro, while Turkey has seen some rapid growth, albeit debt fuelled.
Desire to join the EU from Turkey has waned. Erdogan is a very canny politician. He used EU accession as a kind of gambit to weaken the influence of the military, sworn defender of secularism and enemy of Islam, who basically ran the country from the sidelines 1938-2011 or so. Now he has achieved that aim, with no threat of a future coup, Turkey has taken a different path. They have taken a path of 'Neo-Ottomanism' under foreign minister and another canny politician Davutoglu, which combines 'peace with neighbours' with soft power in the region. The situation in Syria and Libya has put the brakes on that for the moment, leaving Turkey in a somewhat precarious position as neither a friend nor an enemy of the U.S, the west or Israel.
I'm for it. They'd be better for the EU than Romania/Bulgaria/Ukraine are. Only thing stopping them are a bunch of social factors for now.
Too much of a cultural divide in my opinion, however I do admire it's social conservatism.
er ! more kebab shops !!!
Very illiberal government.
Yup, they really need to sort out their internal issues before they are even considered for joining the EU.
I've got to ask though, where does the EU stop? How far do they want to expand? Turkey is geographically in Europe and Asia, but the culture is far from European at all.
Canada may join at some point, and depending on how things go I could see an USA/EU merger somewhere down the line.
TBH, I think the world is going to merge into several large blocs over the next century or so, and something similar to or evolved from the EU will be a core of one.
You're right, the EU's biggest ally is the US, but if you're considering that they could form some sort of EUUSA bloc I don't think that would happen. -shrug-
I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing. :l
I should clarify, I'm thinking in terms of a century or more, but sooner if the space race heats up and we have permanent off world settlements.