Porn actor Jack Venice received a life sentence convicted of rape in 2008. He feels he was wrongfully convicted as he never had sexual contact with the accuser, let alone in the same room as the accuser. Evidence presented seems to affirm that. What do you think?
Posted Jun 6, 2014, 9:19 AM UTC
The jury, who presumably heard all the admissible evidence from both sides, disagrees. I am assuming he had a fair trial and he lost. 2nd guessing them is a waste of time because the reality is that if you were on that jury, you would probably have agreed with them. Now the trial is over and you want to focus on only certain aspects of evidence without considering all of the evidence, to what end? He wasn't tried in a court of public opinion, but of law. So why should our opinions matter now?
[deleted]
The only thing that would really matter is a DNA test of this other guy the convict says is the real rapist (barring some material error in the trial). If you really want to help this convicted rapist, lobby the innocence project in his state. They usually work with the local law schools. They live for crap like this. I think it's a circle jerk.
The reason I am so dismissive of these claims is that they would have typically come up during or before his trial, and would have been dealt with by refuting or dismissing his claims with additional or contrary evidence. Only when a group of 12 strangers was convinced beyond a reasonable doubt was this guy proved guilty, after they heard all of the admissible evidence and arguments of the attorneys. So there are those 12 people who sat with this guy and his victim probably for a week. The jury listened to the police, the forensics and the victim, all who were cross-examined. Then they listened to the defendant, if he chose to testify, and they were convinced he was guilty. They usually get that right. What make you think you are in a better position than they were?
Now a couple of hundred people on the internet are looking at one side of the story, from the convict, and re-trying the case. Except we're not, because we are only getting the convict's version. Not saying mistakes don't happen, but claims of innocence are much more common than actual innocence. If you ask around most prisons everyone will tell you they are innocent. If you believe that, I feel sorry for you.
Waste of time? My time is worthless...
Ha
He will be eligible for parole in February 2017, after serving 9 years of his sentence. His life sentence seems a bit excessive as well.