r/DIY•
manfre

Why are ArcFault breakers so unreliable?

help

Posted Jun 27, 2014, 6:45 PM UTC

05
OpposablePinky•

One of those in my game room trips whenever I use my blender. It's really annoying.

1
manfreOP•

Certain types of motors essentially arc and cause them to trip. This is one of the reasons why ArcFault breakers are not required for garages.

1
EventualCyborg•

I have arcfault breakers for all of the bedrooms in my home and have never had an issue wither their function.

0
manfreOP•

Congratulations, but your "I never had a problem" comment doesn't really contribute to the discussion and here is an example to explain why.

Lets say you have two widgets. Widget A is the tried and true model that has been around for decades and has a premature failure rate of 0.01%. After some time, widget B is created as the safer, better replacement for widget A. Widget B has a premature failure rate of 10%. Widget B is orders of magnitude less reliable than Widget A. even though 90% of the time widget B is not an issue, it's still an unreliable piece of garbage when compared to widget A.

0
EventualCyborg•

Likewise a single failure is hardly indicative of a chronically faulty design.

0