It thoroughly depresses me that my family is teaching my young cousin this

Posted Jul 5, 2014, 7:30 AM UTC

Posted Jul 5, 2014, 7:30 AM UTC
My young cousin posted this (I removed her text because it was irrelevant), and my grandmother responded. My cousin has had awful things done to her, and no one in their right mind would think she's done anything to deserve it. But somehow it's ok to tell her she deserved a bloody awful death on a cross? Seriously?
How they're raising their kid isn't going to fuck them up or anything. It's their religion and I honestly don't see anything wrong with the post, I do think you're being a bit over dramatic though. Edit: And i do get that this whole subreddit is pretty much all atheists buttttt that doesn't mean you have to put down other people.
To put it simply, I don't think it's a good thing to teach your kids that they deserve hell and/or torture.
To put it less simply, this is systemic of a kind of education that can reduce a child's ability to engage in moral reasoning and critical thinking, which is the kind of thing that contributes to harmful civil rights legislation.
I disagree but everybody's got their own opinions.
It does fuck people up to tell them they deserve to be tortured, and that they will be tortured for eternity if they don't believe it.
They don't believe that people deserve to be tortured, all she was saying was that Jesus died for the sins we committed because he loved us.
Some do. I like how Doug Stanhope said it. http://www.google.com/search?q=doug+stanhope+mortgage+shovel&client=ms-android-sprint-us&hl=en&source=android-browser-type&v=141400000&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=KZW4U7SjPIaZyAS4wYL4Dw&ved=0CAkQ_AUoAw&biw=320&bih=508
Some do.
And that does include my family. I thought that was clear from the "...us who deserved what He went through", but maybe it wasn't!
[deleted]
It's not any different than what me and my siblings were taught, and we survived... plenty of other people get through it without being fucked up. But the kid has been abused and it does make me mad that telling a kid who has been abused that she deserves what was pictured is OK because Religion.
The attitude and practice in general makes me mad, it's certainly nothing specific to my grandmother. She's a sweet, wonderful lady, but even the most well meaning people can say hurtful things.
oh well I'm sorry. I didn't know the backstory, I hope everything turns out well.
No worries. Sorry if it was confusing... I was trying to be vague to avoid being identifiable and I obviously went too vague.
I don't think you got the point...
I tell them that i will never accept anyone suffering for me. I would gladly spend time in hell rather then take responsibility for someone slowly choking to death while bleeding from wounds.
I tell them Jesus got off pretty fucking lightly, considering that out of an eternity in heaven, he only had to give up a few days of pain by the most liberal of estimates. Try dying slowly over the span of months from famine, or being locked up in a rapist's dungeon for years, or gradually losing all motor control over decades; that's real suffering that happens to real people who can't do anything about it. I think things hurt more when you don't choose to bring them on yourself.
The story of Jesus would've been so much more compelling if it ended with him being confined to hell for eternity.
true.
[deleted]
You literally can't experience an infinite existence (and suffering) during a finite time; that's a logical impossibility. Besides that, he's Godly, which I would take to mean he has an infinitely high threshold of pain, so it couldn't possibly be as bad as the pain experienced by mortals, or else he'd have surely risen completely insane as people are prone to go after periods of sustained abuse.
Saying "Three days from God for Jesus was exactly like an eternity for him" is also silly because that would mean his actual experience of eternity is something more than eternity, which is definitively impossible, like something existing outside of the universe, or being a married bachelor.
[deleted]
So Jesus was God and completely separated from God at the same time? How does that work?
[deleted]
Why would God need someone to suffer if he was omnipotent?
[deleted]
It doesn't even work like that. He took the collective punishment for all of mankind. Every single human would only deserve a stern talking to at most. Unless one crucifixion is worth as much as a billion crucifixions, which would completely break all math.
And the reality is, he was crucified for pretending to be the son of god and telling everyone the current religion/status quo in power is wrong. There was no threat of punishment to anyone except to Jesus and the ones who followed him.