If the multiverses theory was real, it would be proof of "god's existence" (maybe not in this universe, though).

According to the multiverses theory, there could be an infinity of universes. If there are infinite universes, there must be a universe covering every possibility. If that's true, it means there must be a universe where an omnipotent/omniscient force/being had some role in its design and/or the evolution of its life. If there's such a universe, how can we be sure it isn't OUR universe?

Posted Jul 17, 2014, 7:34 PM UTC

06
servicalOP•

Please note that I'm an agnostic who doesn't care about spirituality. I have no agenda, it's just something I came up with, yesterday.

1
chorzo•

Check out some of the elements of m-theory for a fun time.

1
Bokbreath•

Not exactly. The multiverse is not a shorthand for 'absolutely everything and anything goes'. If it were to be true, all those distinct universes would still obey the laws of physics. Eg. Toss a coin and you'd have a universe in which it was heads and another in which it was tails. You'd also have one where it landed in the edge and another in which brownian motion conspired to whizz it across the room. You would not however, find a universe in which it became a cat, since that would violate the law of conservation of mass.

1
servicalOP•

Well, you make a valid point, but since the concept of "god" has never had a specific definition (I wasn't referring to an anthropomorphic, cloud-dwelling, beard-wielding, abrahamic god in particular), the laws of physics don't necessarily apply here. Think of a greek pantheon of gods, where there would be a planet inhabited by supreme beings (in relation to other beings who'd perceive them as gods). In fact, I guess some creatures on Earth could perceive us humans as gods, the same way ancient greeks perceived their gods (and titans/cyclops and other mystical creatures) to be beings of great power.

Also, what if quarters in that universe had the same mass as a cat? Or if it turned into a quarter-sized cat? Either way, you're obviously right. I've never been a fan of the multiverses theory to begin with, anyways. I posted this with the "sudden clarity Clarence" meme in mind.

I also omitted (self-censored) the final line, which went...

And for each "god-universe", there must be thousands of "no-god-universe" populated by creatures who made up their own divinities to explain phenomenons they couldn't explain with science, yet.

...because I didn't want to antagonize theists.

1
Bokbreath•

I always had a mental image of a god as something that transcends known laws of physics. if we stick with a more mundane 'really advanced but compehendable' then we may find them in our universe. More thoughts. The laws of physics must apply to any multiverse universe. Here's why. We are supposing a multiverse based on QM so any universe created as a result of a QM 'collapse' must adhere to the rules of QM otherwise it would never be created that way. If we assume that black holes lead to other universes then they are candidates for 'new laws of physics' since (we think) everything breaks down inside a black hole. Final edit: oh and on top this wouldn't prove God's existence - merely allow for it.

1
servicalOP•

I agree with most of your reasoning. I didn't expect someone would take my shower thoughts so seriously.

My mental image of "god" is the big bang, since it's the closest thing to fit the definition I was given of the power of a "god" (in the "creator" sense of the word, anyway). If a big bang created our universe and there are further universes, then a big bang must've created other universes, but then, what if one such universe (or all of them), was (were) instead created by an "engineered big bang", would it qualify for "intelligent design"...?

P.S.: Proof-reading this last comment opened my eyes on the fact I watch too much Family Guy. My last post sounds way too much like the first act of [this episode](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Big_Bang_Theory_(Family_Guy\))...

1