The (New) Weekly Hub and Meta Talk Thread: Week of July 20th
###Important Links
- Simple Question & Answer Thread
- Rulings Thread
- Trading Thread
- General Discussion and Casual Chat Thread
- Subreddit Rules - Read before posting, seriously!
###Subreddit Events
- Banner Contest - Entries due July 26th!
Tournament - Currently at Round 5Tournament - Currently at Round 6- Tournament - Currently at Round 7
###Updates
Hello all! This is the new mega thread for all weekly threads and talk about the general affairs of the subreddit. Every Sunday, after the Simple Q&A, Rulings, Trading, and General Discussion threads go up, this thread will be posted and stickied for all to see. If you have a concern about the subreddit, want to talk about recent events here, want to offer some complaints or critiques of moderation, or anything, you now have an outlet to do that every week. This will be the replacement for the not-so-weekly Weekly Update thread!
With that in mind, there are a myriad of things that we need to hear the community's thoughts on! There are a few planned adjustments to the rules that should tone them down and allow for more open posting, and after consideration we've decided to go forward with implementing AutoModerator for very basic functions, and open up further discussion on the viability of more complex functions. A few of them are going to require community feedback; without your input, there will be no major rules or guidelines changes.
##Potential changes to the Simple Q&A Thread - Less restrictions on what has to be posted there, and any changes you want to see
This thread linked in the rules covers fairly intensively the do's and don't's of posting questions on the subreddit. With that said, it is also realized that there are types of questions that, while technically falling under categories that are seemingly more appropriate for the Q&A Thread, are still new or relevant enough that them being saked or answered in a more public fashion would be beneficial for expanding the community's general knowledge or serve as the starting point for discussions on new and engaging topics.
Take for example, a thread may be posted about where to go buy certain Yu-Gi-Oh! products in Japan. Normally, simply asking about where to purchase things is something that belongs in the Simple Q&A Thread: there are only a select few concrete answers to this question. With that said, it has some very important distinctions compared to questions such as "Where can I buy the latest booster box?"
In general, this is the difference that we'd like to recognize and promote as questions that will be viable outside of the Simple Q&A Thread: if a question is asked which, while seeking a straightforward answer and not inherently seeking some form of discussion (the normal qualifiers for belonging in the Q&A thread), falls outside the realm of general knowledge, cannot be reliably searched for through conventional means, or whose answer can serve as the starting point for expanding general knowledge or pique community interest due to it being a new or rarely discussed topic, then it would be acceptable to post it outside of the Q&A thread.
While the premises behind this are somewhat vague and subjective, we'd like to think that this stance would help promote new kinds of different questions and topics to be posted.
In regards to that, we also want to make sure the current state of the Q&A thread's rules aren't preventing the community from engaging in meaningful ways. Thus, there are three questions to be asked this week about your personal thoughts on the Q&A thread:
- Would the above change in policy listed be acceptable or viable for the subreddit?
- What types of questions are currently disallowed that you think should be allowed?
- What types of questions are currently allowed that you think should be disallowed?
In regards to the latter two questions, our stance on the Rulings thread is going to remain firm to what the rules currently say.
##Potential changes to R/F guidelines - Casual and Competitive R/F distinction
In short, the proposition here is simple: we want users to be given the opportunity to opt-in to higher posting standards. This would mean that the judging and approval of R/F submissions tagged as "Casual" will mean less restrictions and expectations, while users opting in to make a "Competitive" R/F will be expected to post more detail in their post.
The current R/F guidelines would need minor adjustments, but you would expect the Casual R/F guidelines to be slightly more lax, whereas Competitive R/F guidelines will be at least at where the current R/F guidelines lay, if not with higher. Competitive would be expected to be prepared for more serious quality control in their presentation. Casual submissions would have their #1 priority be following the guidelines and having presentable formatting; the level of detail, demonstrated knowledge, topics covered, etc. would be secondary issues to the submitters actually getting help.
The only additional restriction that would be necessary for this would be the mandatory inclusion of either the "Casual" or "Competitive" tag in the title of your R/F submissions, but in exchange for that users will have the option to choose what standards their submission will attempt to uphold.
There aren't any specific differing guidelines laid out at the moment, but rather this is an idea we'd like to gauge interest in before implementing in any way. If the specifics of what those different guidelines will be are absolutely necessary, then those are something that can be decided on with community consensus in this thread.
##Implementing AutoModerator - Starting basic functions, and further capabilities (and why you may be interested in those)
AutoModerator is very simple to set up surprisingly, and it will be able to help the mod team with the following functions right away:
- Automatically removing 99.9% of memes, ragecomic, etc submissions
- These are already disallowed, and while not a pressing issue at this time, the ability to have most of them automatically removed is
- Whitelist domains that are normally caught in the spam filter
- Pojo is automatically flagged by the spam filter for some reason. AutoMod can pick up on these links and approve them without you having to wait for another mod to do it (even if it would only take a few minutes)
- Alert the mods when posts get X number of reports, or automatically remove them based on Y number of reports
- Remind submitters to read the rules and guidelines for R/F submissions (word count, Casual or Competitive in title should that be enforced)
- All the AutoMod would do is comment leaving a reminder to double check the R/F guidelines in the rules. For a low content submission, AutoMod would also suggest to consider adding more detail. It would not remove any submissions unless they are blatantly breaking basic and simple to follow rules (e.g. Casual/Competitive distinction should that be agreed upon and them being self post only)
- Remove direct link R/F submissions (to automatically ensure all are in self posts)
- Automatically remove hateful/racist/etc comments and posts
- Automatically notify the mods if they are mentioned in name or in general
Additionally, there are multiple other features which are considered to be beneficial that would also warrant consideration:
- Enforcing a certain post length for self text posts
- This would effectively be cutting down on the types of questions that have only a body of "this" or something similar. The post length would be incredibly minor, something like 50 characters, meaning that only a sentence or two would be needed.
- Automatically remove submissions based on key words and phrases (e.g. removing any post that has phrases such as "looking to buy", "where to buy", "want to buy", etc)
- This is somewhat tricky, given the possibility of a thread covering an acceptable topic but being removed due to using specific phrasing that makes it seem inappropriate for general submissions. This would only be introduced if there was some sort of community consensus on what phrases would be reasonable enough to automatically flag.
- Automatically remove posts by certain users while giving them the ability to comment still
- As a disclaimer, temporary bans as a part of the strike policy have been suspended for the time being. Though I personally didn't see much issue with it, there was enough contention to give consideration as to how to handle bans better. AutoModerator gives the capability to automatically remove submissions from certain users, but give them the ability to comment. For users who end up continually breaking the rules, this would allow them to still contribute to the subreddit without them posting further rule breaking threads.
- Automatically remove posts by accounts less than a certain age
- This would likely be only for accounts less than a day old. The intent for this would be to cut down on trolls who like to continually create alt accounts after being banned and resume posting right away. This would hopefully deter them from doing so, and only affect a minimum number of users otherwise. In fact, giving brand new users a day to be notified of and aware of the rules while lurking could prove beneficial.
- Automatically filter super generic frequently asked questions that should go in the Q&A Thread (e.g. "How much is this worth?")
- Again, this is tricky given the possibility of accidentally removing otherwise fine submissions. There would have to be community consensus on what phrases would be acceptable for automatic flagging and removal.
Those features are ones which can be easily implemented, but won't without further community feedback on them.
##General subreddit quality - Cutting down on the crap and promoting better content
There have been concerns voiced by some that there are too many rules concerning what can't be posted, and not enough concern with what should be posted and promoted. We have a couple of incentives in place already (special flairs, for instance) for contributing quality content, but we're all ears if you have any ideas. In the meantime, until we can think of ideas on our own (trust me when I say we've been trying), our focus is going to be on maintaining quality with the tools and rules (haha, rhyming) at our disposal, and fine-tuning said rules as necessary to improve the subreddit experience for you all.
That's it for the first week of the new hub/meta thread. It's our hopes that this will be a new important resource for the subreddit. Remember to use the linked weekly threads as appropriate, keep the rules and community standards in mind as you post, and please, please, please post any and all feedback in these threads from here on out. Expect future ones to be a tiny bit shorter too (hopefully)!
Posted Jul 20, 2014, 7:56 AM UTC · edited