Hey guys, I'm looking for some info to write an "article" on PSASBR!

Hi guys, I'm doing some research on PSASBR as I want to write an article about it for my web site (smashbrositalia.com), please understand that I do this in my free time and I'm by no means a professional editor, just a pro smash player. So, as I pointed out, I actually come from the Smash Bros community but was a supporter of the game early on. PSASBR didn't really meet my expectations, but i gave it a shot anyways as I believe that you cannot judge a fighting game until you had a taste of the competitive side (I played the game under the tag: SkullK55, maybe someone remembers me). Unfortunately i abandoned the game after a while for a couple of reasons (the main one being there is absolutely no competitive scene for PSASBR in Italy; or at least, so it was when i dropped the game). Eventually I just got tired of playing it online, plus another few factors contributed. I'd be really be glad to hear your take on the following questions:

  1. Currently, what's the state of the competitive scene worldwide? How has it's popularity changed? (downward spiral, evolving ecc)

  2. How has the metagame evolved? (I played until last year, I was a Raiden mainer, so I have no idea how/if things changed)

  3. Honestly, is the game growing bigger or is it something for just a couple of die-hard fans?

  4. What are the main "complains" about the game (example: personally, to me, it's just feels too slow and limited in it's options during MUps).

  5. What did the game nail?

  6. What do you think might need improvement in order to make an eventual sequel to succeed?

  7. Do you believe that if the game had borrowed some ideas from the Smash Series it would've been more successful? Maybe even add depth to the core gameplay? (example: characters having different weight, gravity ecc).

  8. Did the constant patches requested by mostly casual players (this is my understanding of what happened, correct me if i'm wrong) contribute to players dropping the game?

I already have my own opinions, but i really want to hear the fans perspective.

In the future, if possible, i'd really like to have a chat with a SuperBot Developer/Creator in order to discuss the game. I know it might be unlikely for a dev to show up, but i'm doing my best to find one (as SBs website and all being shut down).

Thank you for your time and eventual reply!

Edit: words

Posted Jul 22, 2014, 2:53 PM UTC · edited

38
burstfiredragonThe original Nyan Cat!•

I can only answer a few of these myself, but here you go :P

  1. I often see new people joining in, but some older fans never seem to appear online. It is the third best selling game on the PSN store though, so maybe people just haven't bought passes to play online.

  2. It's always a wave of Jak, Kratos, Kat, Dante and G.Cole. Very little variety in the characters played online. I play literally everyone in the game purely to spice it up online.

  3. The Super system and combos are what were nailed for me. It's a breath of fresh air being able to hold onto your super and charge it up to make it easier to get kills.

  4. Kat being less broken. I want to use her but she is just so blatantly overpowered I don't enjoy playing her. Also, much bigger cast with well known characters.

  5. I don't think this would've benefited the game, as it already gets shunned as being a "Smash clone" when it quite clearly isn't. I like it the way it is.

Hope I was of some use providing my own opinion :D

5
LIQUIDFGC•
  1. The competitive scene is quite weak. It's had no rep outside a very small EVO side event and SoCal 2013. To me it's going downhill.

  2. Until the patch hit it was discovering whatever tech possible. Now that the patch was released it seems to be returning to that style, but tweaking according to the new changes.

  3. Die hard fans. Anyone "new" is most likely an alt by some troll.

  4. I left a long time ago, so I'm not quite one to talk, but usually, the community, the AP mechanic being somewhat exploitable and broken, and really screwed up MU's.

  5. Fanservice(not that one; like appealing to fans) with content, some characters, and hilarious glitches and moments. Nevermind managing huge determination from it's community.

  6. Better roster, fixed mechanics, less glitches, and better community moderators.

  7. Successful as a carbon copy, sure. Sure, it'd add depth, but it'd come under fire for it.

  8. I'm pretty sure not. Casual players are mostly ignored and the real evidence comes from match footage and top character usage.

3
roflpower•

^

2
sefazuresyou'll never win•

well, first of all, if you want to talk to someone who worked on the game, Maj might be your best bet. He was the combat designer for Allstars, and his website is sonichurricane.com.

and, as for my answers...

  • The competitive scene is pretty small, and it's pretty much entirely online. There's been a few offline tournies here and there (including a small side tourney at EVO 2014), but nothing major. Allstars never really "took off" (and it probably never will, which is kind of a pity, despite the game's flaws.)

  • The metagame's evolved quite a bit, especially because of the patches. There isn't really a solid tier list at the moment, but it's generally agreed that in 1v1, Kat's the best character and Zeus is the worst. Beyond that, I'm not really sure what you're looking for with this question. :p

  • Well, I've heard there's been a few new players on the online random matchmaking since a PSN sale, but the offline (and even online) competitive scene isn't really growing. It's pretty small overall, it's mostly contained in the official forums. There's some streams on Twitch, online tournies, that kind of thing.

  • Well, the main one is that people don't like the super system. It was an interesting and unique idea imo, but it didn't really work. It's too unbalanced and makes for less exciting play than Smash Bros overall. A few other problems include: bad online netcode, meh stage selection, bad UI, disappointing roster (no Crash/Spyro), bad balance (Kat is still ridiculously good, and a couple other characters are still great.)

  • Well, I think the game nailed the combo system. I wouldn't want it to replace anything in any other game (especially Smash Bros), but it's fun to play around with and find new things that work (eg this, lol) Other than that... despite its flaws, it's still a pretty fun game, imo, even if it can get a little frustrating sometimes.

  • Well, quite a few things need improvement, imo. The UI, the single player content, the roster (it needs Crash/Spyro), and the stages. But what it probably needs most is new mechanics. I like the super system but I don't think it works well enough. I don't think a sequel with the super system will be popular even if it gets the other stuff right.

  • Allstars definitely would've been more popular if it copied Smash's mechanics (the ringout and % system). But what it needs most from Smash is mobility options. Running, dashing, fast falling, etc... All things that you can't do in Allstars. Lots of characters are pretty sluggish, and that's part of what makes the game so slow. And aside from those... it should copy the way Smash handles single player too. I mean, obviously multiplayer is more important, but Allstars had very lacking single player.

  • The problem wasn't the number of patches, but what was actually on them, honestly. It took a LONG time for Sony Santa Monica to make a new patch after SuperBot shut down, and when it hit, it made the game better, but it was still a little disappointing. Characters being unfairly nerfed, bad balance (Kat), support being dropped by SuperBot... they're the things that made people drop the game. The big one was patch 1.10 (the patch that hit in March 2013): a LOT of people quitted after that patch.

2
Sentence55OP•

Thanks for the link man!

1
sefazuresyou'll never win•

no problem. If you want some more opinions, you might want to consider asking this over at the official forums. This subreddit isn't completely dead, but there's a lot more people over there.

2
Bartman013•

I really think you should address the roster. I am completely okay with this roster that Superbot made with the conditions they were under. I talked to Clockwerk at a PlayStation event in Toronto like a month before the game came out and we talked for a long time about the game. I asked him about the roster a lot and here were some of things he said.

  • The decision with Dante was not up to Superbot. When I asked him why they included the new version of Dante he said it was not up to Superbot and that Capcom wanted the new version in the game. He told me that if Superbot had the choice they would not include the version if a character the everyone hates.

  • Sucker Punch wanted 2 Coles in the games because they thought that was the best way to represent Cole. Superbot was planning to just have 1 Cole but SP really wanted 2 Coles.

  • I asked about Crash, Cloud etc. and he could not say anything but he did tell me they had conversations about a lot of requested characters.

The only 2 characters in the game that I did not want in the game are Zeus and Isaac.

I just want people to understand that Sony does not own Crash and Spyro. There is no question that they tried to get various 3rd party characters that all the fans wanted. They're not stupid. They obviously tried to get Crash, Spyro, Cloud, Snake etc. but they final say was up to the publishers. I know it sucks that they could not get those characters but if the 3rd party publishers did not want their characters in the game there is pretty much nothing Sony could do.

2
[deleted]•

The game nailed everything it tried to do. The thing is, it didn't try to do enough. There was no story mode, which I'm sure would have been great. If they put thought into the characters they included rather than pick based off of who was willing to pay the most, things would have been better. Customization excelled above smash in every way but still there could have been more things, namely costumes and supers

1