r/violinist•
SoupUser

Don't know what notes are supposed to sound like

Hi. I've been learning for a year now and I still am not too sure on what pitch to be aiming for on notes. Is this normal? Does it come with time? I have to refer to a piano to figure out what I am trying to get. Maybe I am a bit paranoid, but could I be tone deaf?

Posted Jul 23, 2014, 6:23 AM UTC

719
blpsoup•

The best way to find your bearings is to listen to notes and find the harmonic rings in your violin. The notes G, D, A, E will all harmonize and the instrument will ring loudly. Pressing any string to produce those same notes in any scale will also cause the violin to ring if it is in key. Use those notes to get your bearings.

5
arcowhip•

This is great advice! I think the best in this thread. I just am going to add a few things that might help the OP find these rings.

The ringing is also called sympathetic vibrations. For some notes you can actually see them. Place your first on the G string in first position. Play with a healthy and round sound and you should see the A string vibrating sympathetically. This only happens if you are in tune with your A string. From there you can see the other strings vibrating sympathetically with the third fingers on the string above. This is harder to see as the string vibrates in two parts, split in half at the harmonic or node in the middle of the string.

2
SoupUserOP•

Thanks.

1
blpsoup•

You're welcome! A final piece is to try some of your practicing with your eyes closed. I find that looking at my strings is a massive culprit for me that inhibits playing, and doing it this way forces me to listen.

1
IFUCKINGLOVEMUSIC•

I doubt you're tone deaf. My first question is are you taking lessons? If so (well even if not) you should be practicing scales WITH a drone note. This is how I fixed MOST of my intonation problems. I'm still working on it just like everyone else is working on something. Knowing what notes are in the scale and playing the tonic of the scale will help you develop an ear and what the intervals should sound like. If you need me to, I will happily elaborate on what I mean by intervals and how all that comes into play if you don't know already.

4
ashirviskas•

What is a drone note?

1
IFUCKINGLOVEMUSIC•

Let's say you're working on a scale for example D major. You would drone a D and hold each note for an extended amount of time to hear the intervals. The interval is the distance a note is from the tonic note in this case D. So since E is 2 notes away (D to E) we call this a second and since its found in the key of D its a major second. Does that make sense?

2
ashirviskas•

How is E two tones away from D?

EDIT: My bad. You said two notes, not tones.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Motokostarwind•

D, D#, E.

1
IFUCKINGLOVEMUSIC•

Right! And again if the note is I'm the scale its major, if not, its minor.

1
pkpkm•

The "2nd" refers to where in the scale it is, not the half steps between it and the root. E is the second note in a D major scale.

It's less confusing with a major third. F# is 4 half steps away, but it is the 3rd note in the D major scale, so it's a major third. An F natural is the 3rd note in a D minor scale, so it is a minor third.

1
suznebula•

Consider going to a local music store and having their string specialist put stickers on your fingerboard where the notes are.

3
StarvingAutist•

I can't remember how I learned, but maybe doing some chromatic scales would help. That way you learn how far notes are from each other. I recommend practising scales every day. I'm not sure what level you're at or whether you have a teacher, but I'd recommend the Tune a Day books and Doflein study books to help you.

1
SoupUserOP•

I'll try that, thanks.

1
onemilehigher•

I would recommend finding a teacher to point out when your notes are off, or playing along to recorded versions of the songs you are working on. It comes with time and practice.

1
SoupUserOP•

That's currently what I have/am doing, maybe not the last part as much as I should...

1
dickwheat•

My advice on this would be to listen to how the instrument responds to where you place your fingers. String instruments are unique in that they will give you sympathetic feedback if you are playing in tune. For example, if you play a 3rd finger G on the D string, the G string below will vibrate to indicate that your finger is in tune with the open string. You will also hear a distinct echo/ring from the violin when the notes are in tune. Listening for this will not only improve your accuracy in the left hand, but also help the right hand to be steadier; as it is easier to hear the pitch when the bow is good. Playing in tune is a habit that takes many hours of practice and maintenance, even for professionals. If you are still in doubt, download cleartune for iphone or buy a needle tuner. I promise you will quickly start hearing better with those tools.

1