I'm no developer but....

I really want to see a TagPro port to Android, however I realize it's really hard to make a stable and fun app appear from thin air.

So today, I was thinking about easier ways to get TagPro running on Android. I don't really understand what you guys are doing here, but I have the vague impression that you guys are creating a TagPro "client" app for android from scratch.

I was wondering why it wouldn't be easier to write an app that displayed a joystick (or dpad) on the screen that was mapped to WASD on the android keyboard? I know writing a client from scratch would have many advantages, but TagPro already runs in chrome on my phone (LG G2) at 50 FPS. The only problem is that there is no way to control it without plugging in a external keyboard.

It seems to me it would be easier to write a app that was basically a browser, but with a transparent joystick/dpad instead of a keyboard. I know it wouldn't be as efficient or stable as writing a TagPro client app from scratch, but it seems like a easier app to develop.

I also think this would be a good way to generate some HYPE for this subreddit, and start getting more and more people involved. Obscurity is the main enemy of this project, not difficulty.

Disclaimer: I have no idea what I'm talking about.

Edit: I think Lightning Browser is open source, so that can probably save the devs some time.

Posted Jul 23, 2014, 6:45 PM UTC

28
DJGreenHill•

Doing an app and making the graphics render on the machine would ease the porting, fps and performance a whole lot. Your idea is neat but the fitting would be complex and the performances would be very poor

3
omegadeep10OP•

Yeah this makes sense. I still think playing in Chrome with a controller is a viable option though.

2
d0xxx•

Well.. I don't know if it was only me, but there is this paid app "Sixaxis" which makes me able to use a PS3 controller as an input device for my Nexus4 - which allowed me to controll my ball using the Chrome browser. The problem was, even with full WiFi signal, I had a very bad latency which made me unable to play. Like between 150-300ms... I wonder if that's something that can be fixed...

3
omegadeep10OP•

I think latency is caused by your actual connection, rather than the speed of the device. For example, if you have a slow internet connection, it doesn't matter how many WiFi bars you have because your internet is still very slow regardless.

It's cool to know that you got it working with a PlayStation controller, that can definitely come in handy! I wonder if it's possible to get it working with a general purpose bluetooth controller instead...

2
d0xxx•

I should have mentioned that I was playing TagPro on the computer nearly at the same time. With a 40ms ping..

1
nerdwaller•

Yeah, this has been proposed a few times now. There are a few blocking issues for that:

  1. Sure, it runs in a browser. But that's not something exposed to another app's control. Android gives a 'Web view' for apps to use which is 'a browser', but before KitKat (android 4.4) the web view was a very basic Dom that doesn't support many of the features required 4.4's is chromium based). KitKat is on <20% of all android devices.

  2. Supposing we could have an embedded browser do it, performance would likely suffer as the resource use there is much less in our control. It may work as a short term solution, but wouldn't be quite as good as a native app. We spoke with Lucky about it and wanted to provide as good an experience on the mobile platform as it is online.

I forget the other issues, but I've not done much on it for a few months now.

All that said, the project has mostly stalled, at least publicly. I see some stars and forks, but nothing new added. I'm hoping to find time again to put there, but my free time is pretty limited at the moment.

2
omegadeep10OP•

I understand. Porting it over is definitely a better idea, but it does take a lot more time. Unfortunately, we don't have enough people working on this to make it happen. I wish I could help develop this, but I'm pretty new to programming in general. How did you learn Java?

1
nerdwaller•

Yeah, people have had other stuff come up. I may try to get back into it, but if I do I'll re-start the project. Mostly because I think we prioritized the wrong things and it should be converted to use Gradle.

Learning is different for everyone. I used to write a lot of C++ at an old job, which pretty much solidified many of the major programming concepts. While Java acts a little differently, it's really easy to pick up once you've gotten a pretty good grasp on another syntactically C languages. So, for me - I just started doing it - but it all fell in line with what I know. If you write lots of python or something, it's a slightly larger jump.

1