r/DnD•
alterafro

My friends and I just decided to start playing D&D and I've been nominated as DM. Any advice?

As a group of friends we've danced around the idea of playing before, but when the new 5th edition starter set came out, I went out and bought it. We're gonna play through that with the pre generated characters before starting a regular meet up once the Players Handbook comes out. I've read through all the rules I can get my hands on and have a pretty strong knowledge of the Lost Mine of Phandelver booklet. I was just wondering if you guys have any advice at all, as I've never actually seen a game of D&D played before and there will be things that might be obvious once you're playing, but not so clear when you've been staring at a rule book. Also what basic information, if any, should I get my players to look into themselves before sitting down at the table that would make my life significantly easier?

EDIT: Crap, just realised someone has JUST posted a super similar question just before me. Oh well.

Posted Jul 28, 2014, 6:36 AM UTC · edited

115
kobrahawk1210Necromancer•
  • Make sure you have enough dice. A d20 for each player, and various numbers of the other dice.

  • I read through the entire PHB1 in 3.5 before joining my first game online, and it was still quite awkward getting into it. When you've never played before, you don't quite realize that you can do anything. Make sure your players are ready to get creative, as they are the ones whose actions have reactions; you are simply the storyteller. Make sure that they know they can have their characters try anything they want to. It is NOT like other RPGs where you can't fall off ledges or pass through fences. You can literally do anything, even if there's not a skill check for it.

  • From what I've heard, 5e is deadly compared to 3.x, PF, and 4e. For the first few levels, things will die fast, including PCs. Warn your players that if they're not tactical, they could easily wipe on the first or second encounter.

As for you!

Roll with it. If a player wants to try something unorthodox, let them, and encourage them to get in character and describe how they go about it. This will get all of your players thinking outside the box.

Encourage roleplay; for example, anyone in my groups that make a bluff, diplomacy, or intimidate have to speak as their character when making the check.

Get a DM screen. You'll want to make some rolls in private (things where the players could receive false information) and if things are going really good for the monsters but not the players (or vice versa), you can lie about the results. Goblin just crit the party wizard? Oops, he rolled a 17, actually. wink Group of bandits not able to land a hit? Say that 3 was a 14. It's called fudging, and while it can be used for evil, a good DM can use it to keep things from getting too unbalanced.

Be prepared to make up rules. Sometimes you don't quite remember a rule, and you don't want to spend too long looking for it. Just come up with something on the fly that seems fair, unless it's something absolutely crucial.

Be. Descriptive. This is a BIG one. You're the storyteller, tell the story. Don't be afraid to use voices for NPCs, and make a fool of yourself; it helps immersion, and a good DM acting out a particularly unique NPC can be the best part of the night. You're all friends, and it will make the night more fun, so don't worry about embarrassing yourself!

Ending on that last note, remember that you're all there to have fun! Don't take anything too seriously (unless you all want to heavily roleplay and be serious), and it is a social game. So just let loose, and have a good time. Good luck! :D

4
alterafroOP•

Is there anything you would recommend as a makeshift DM screen? I read somewhere that the 5e one isn't put until January or something. Also, when reading the rules I had trouble getting my head around NPC stealth checks. Do these immediately start a combat encounter after they've resolved (with the party being surprised or not depending in the result) or can the opponent wait the party out? If it's the latter, are there any clever ways to disguise a roll to keep the players in the dark in case it results in the NPC remaining concealed?

1
kobrahawk1210Necromancer•

A folder should work to just make private rolls.

I'm not the authority on skills in 5E. I play Pathfinder, which is a lot different from new editions. That being said, in PF, generally, the PCs would make perception checks to see if they notice someone hiding. If they don't, the NPCs would remain hidden (which could mean ambush!). If they do, they wouldn't be caught off guard, but they can choose to be diplomatic or initiate contact.

1
alterafroOP•

Yeah, I think that's how it's supposed to work when the players are actively looking for threats, but when just entering an area, there's a passive perception aspect (I don't know if Pathfinder has this rule)

1
kobrahawk1210Necromancer•

Pathfinder does have passive perception, although I must admit I don't know the specifics of it.

2
dubiousmage•

Yeah, basically, the way that first encounter (and others like it) work is that you roll for the goblin stealth at the beginning of the encounter (1d20+6).

The result of their check becomes the DC of the Perception check to notice the goblins, for however long they're hiding. If a player's Passive Perception beats that DC, they notice the goblins automatically at some point before the goblins attack. Otherwise, the goblins stay hidden until someone either rolls Perception and notices them, or until the goblins decide to attack. When they choose to attack is up to you.

Then you've got the surprise round of combat, where (after everyone rolls initiative) only the goblins, and any PCs aware of them, get to act.

1
LaFlame•

You'll want to make some rolls in private (things where the players could receive false information).

Being an absolute newbie to D&D, I've been watching some videos on-line. I've seen some DM's do this while others have not. I saw a Chris Perkins game and he did not do private rolls.

I can see why you would roll in private, but would players sometimes think this is fishy? When I get my group together (none of whom have played D&D before), they may think this is abnormal to roll in private.

Rolling in private allows you to manipulate the game in parts it is needed, to give the players a hand if they are extremely unlucky. But there is also the real element of mystery with rolling in the open, as anything can happen and the dice roll being final.

Have you played both ways? I'm just looking for a little more insight on which method people think works the best?

1
kobrahawk1210Necromancer•

I have indeed played both ways. Honestly, I prefer fudging, because sometimes one side will be really lucky with the other not. It can get really frustrating for either the players or the DM.

1
Hecateus•

It's Improv with Dice. Always try to find a way to say yes to player ideas, in a modified way if need be. But rolling dice is fun too...

My reading so far (haven't played the module...as I need friends with similar schedules). Cart could use a driver, as PCs will likely go wandering after a bit. Approach to first encounter could be telegraphed by spotting vultures circling. See if there are any handouts you can make in advance...like at one point there is a "Wanted" pamphlet with a crude drawing of one of the PCs. The set does not include at scale maps at such but clever redditors have created spoiler free versions at scale, use your printer or go to Kinkos. Lego figures can be used as miniatures, or even bits of paper with sitck figures on them: http://www.iheartprintandplay.com/

good luck

3
alterafroOP•

Thanks! The link looks really interesting, it'll be super useful because I'm not an artist and I think just having the things in front of me will help a lot at least to start off with :)

1