MRW a guy compliments me on being clever or interesting instead of telling me i'm cute

MRW a guy compliments me on being clever or interesting instead of telling me i'm cute

Posted Aug 2, 2014, 2:36 AM UTC

1K45
violaceousOP•

not that there's anything wrong with being cute or getting a compliment on your looks, it's just that it's not a priority in my life. i'm about average looking i guess but i care a lot more about my interests/hobbies and personality!

i feel like comments on my looks are mostly from drunk strangers who say that to everyone they want to talk to, whereas compliments about other things are actually about me as an individual.

tldr being cute is great and all but i get a huge boner when people recognize my actual self that i put effort into and have the power to control

51
AWildRisuAppearednerdy cat "lady"•

I know what you mean. The first thing my boyfriend told me he likes about me is that I'm opinionated. It was nice.

17
FancyFoss•

Eh I hear what you're saying, but I also really hate the, oh I assumed you were a total idiot thing - how amazing it is that I am like, reasonably interesting.

16
SugarTits1strong independent troll who don't need no bridge•

It's hard to tell how interesting a person is just by looking at them. I mean even if you walk down the street wearing parachute pants, a waist coat, a monocle and a cane, it could all be a show to cover up the fact you're the most boring person on earth. Any time I meet a person and they turn out to be really interesting I make damn sure they know about it!

4
team_meh•

Yeah. It feels like torture when I have to suppress a creepy giggle when dealing with compliments that aren't based on my looks.

3
HStark•

Just for the record, I think there are some guys (probably quite a large number but I haven't done a survey) who never use "cute" to mean the same thing as "pretty" or "hot." It is difficult to be cute if you don't have a pretty face, so they do go together, but if I call a girl cute, about 9 times out of 10 I'm referring to the way she carries herself and/or reacts to things.

Oversimplified example: if you have a nice face, I might say you're pretty. If you blush and smile when I say say you're pretty, that's when I'd call you cute.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Thesupersalsa•

I dunno man, I'm cool with being cute.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
ANBU_Black_0ps•

As a guy I'd really like to unpack this with you ladies just to help me understand a bit better. That sentiment surprises me and I'm not sure why. When I have been in a relationship with a woman typically my compliments tend to be skewed looks based over personality based (probably 75% and 25% respectively). This is because I have found that most of the women I have dated/ know tend to be more insecure about their looks and thus compliments in that area tend to be more impactful and meaningful.

While I can see how personality compliments could be meaningful to someone you don't know very well is this equally as important to someone you know intimately well? Do you think its important to try to find a better balance between complimenting looks vs personalty in a dating relationship?

I'm sorry if these questions seem dumb or obvious but I never really thought about it from another perspective and I'm really interested to hear what you ladies have to say. Thanks in advance.

26
meteor_streamCatholic. As in "cat holic".•

Because it's better when you compliment people on something they're actually proud of. If a guy complimented me on my looks, I'd brush it off as flattery/lie/trying to get into my pants, but if he complimented me on my smarts, or on my art, I'd take it as an actual praise.

34
HStark•

Can I compliment you on your rhyming skills?

4
meteor_streamCatholic. As in "cat holic".•

...I didn't even notice that my reply sort of rhymed ._.

And yes, yes you can <3

2
HStark•

Nice rhyming skills! :D You're just a poet who's afraid to show it

1
violaceousOP•

Well this probably won't sound very helpful but it REALLY depends on the person. If it's the kind of girl who gets ready for an hour or more before she goes out at night, she's obviously invested in it. If she spends a lot of time reading nonfiction or drawing or doing science experiments in her basement... you get the idea.

If i'm physical with someone i do like assurance that they're attracted to me (whereas if i'm not interested in sleeping with them i don't care), but overall i feel like what makes me "special" or different than anyone else isn't look related - i'm pretty average and kind of on the tomboy side - but that i sometimes make weird connections and have a sense of humor that I like, so it's nice to be around other people who appreciate it. Same with personal art and my philosophies and such, it feels good to have someone "get" what I mean.

I'm insecure about my looks quite often (pretty common), but I also feel like society overemphasizes it, so that's why i like when people swing things back towards balance. YMMV.

20
ANBU_Black_0ps•

That makes a lot of sense. As a personal rule of thumb I typically don't compliment women that I don't know as I have learned from reddit its very easy to come off as creepy even if there is no intent to do so. (I have a whole set of rules for compliments I won't bore you with.)

Plus in my mind by the time I get to a point in a relationship where things turn physical/ sexual I know that you are funny/smart/passionate/quirky, etc and so my compliments get skewed more physical for previously stated reasons. I know personally compliments about my looks would be most meaningful to me, but I also probably wouldn't believe them since I'm average looking and from bad experiences with ex-girlfriends in my past.

Anyway thanks for your answer I understand much better now.

3
lel__lel•

Forget the rules. Be sincere. Never compliment anyone on personal things (looks, weight, clothing, behaviour) if you don't know them really well - same as any kind of positive or negative personal remark. Usually it's offensive either way. Compliment people on intellectual achievements or creativity or hard work even if you know them not very well. This applies for all men and women. It's not about being creepy just inappropriate and rude.

1
FixinThePlanetwith imagination and cogitation•

Compliments make you feel doubleplusgood when they acknowledge either something you wish you had but don't believe you have, or something you've put a lot of effort into.

This is because I have found that most of the women I have dated/ know tend to be more insecure about their looks and thus compliments in that area tend to be more impactful and meaningful.

You already understand. Personality compliments are meaningful to OP, so she's happy she got them. I think people tend to try complimenting others very early in a friendship/ relationship without waiting to find out if the compliment is really welcome/appreciated. I myself have a very bad habit of telling people when they smell really good without checking to see if that might offend them. P.S. this is totally about to happen at prom, by the way.

14
violaceousOP•

telling people when they smell really good without checking to see if that might offend them

even if my face is in someone's neck, i feel creepy complimenting them on smelling nice ):

1

That's one thing I am so over. I appreciate if you smell nice, and damn it, I'll let you know.

2
[deleted]•

I want my boyfriend/crush/husband to think I'm hot and have a great personality. Strangers/friends/co-workers/family I'd rather get personality or good character compliments.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ANBU_Black_0ps•

I thank you for your comment and sharing your perspective. I have been reflecting on it quite a bit over the last few days and I would like to take an opportunity to respond. This is not me trying to change your mind about your opinion (as I do not want to mitigate you feelings on this matter) or in anyway be dismissive of your feelings or your experience. This is merely me being open and honest about my worldview and my experience as you were open and honest with me.

If you do not want to read this by all means don't. I will never know if you did or not and if you choose not to I won't be offended in anyway. By talking about this helps me further conceptualize my thoughts and feelings on this matter.

After I broke up with my last girlfriend a little over a year ago I decided that I was going to take a few years off dating and during this time I would also remain celibate. This time away from dating has helped me in many ways but the one that is germane to this conversation. I have come to understand and realize that all women are beautiful.

I am not talking about the standard of beauty that exists in American culture; (thin or athletic build, busty, long hair, etc.) that based on a checklist where you either have enough checkmarks or you do not. I am talking about the concept that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I believe that all women are beautiful because when you step away from the narrow minded stereotype of what beauty is you can appreciate the innate and unique beauty that every woman posses. Maybe its the color or shape of her eyes, the shape of her lips. The way her hair cascades over her shoulders. Maybe its her dimples or freckles, or her legs, or her walk. And that only covers the physical characteristics, there is always her wit, or her laugh or her charm, or her sense of humor, tenacity, intelligence, indignity, creativity, passion, her joie de vivre. I truly believe every woman is beautiful and that beauty deserves and demands to be appreciated and celebrated.

Moreover I believe when you (generally 'you' not specifically 'you') are in a relationship complimenting your partners beauty is has far more meaning that you acknowledging their physical attractiveness. I firmly believe that when a person is in a relationship their partner should be enough for them and what they desire physically, romantically and sexually. Thus when I tell my partner that she looks beautiful, inherent in that compliment is a) my acknowledgement and appreciation for how beautiful I find her b) an acknowledgement of my desire for her and her alone and c) a spoken acknowledgement of my fidelity to her and her alone.

I mean saying "I find every part of you enchanting and breathtaking and I am so blessed to be in a relationship with you" sounds so much better and means so much more than "Just so you know, I'm not sleeping around on you".

In summation, I do agree with a lot of what you said and while some of it I knew it was a healthy reminder (and one must stay vigilant to not get complacent) to appreciate the whole woman and not just her looks. However I also believe that a woman's beauty is more than just her looks and every woman is beautiful, and that beauty demands to be acknowledged, appreciated and celebrated.

1
[deleted]•

I just find looks based compliments rather boring and uncreative. Like great, your eyes work, can we talk about something more interesting than my hair now?

2
iamtheparty•

For me, I'd rather be complimented on something I've had to achieve. Compliments on my physical appearance are still nice, but even then I'd rather hear 'your eye makeup is fantastic' than 'you're pretty'.

Tell me I'm cute and it'll make me smile, but tell me I'm a great photographer/I kicked ass at the gym/my movie knowledge is impressive/my cakes taste amazing etc., I'll be beaming all day.

2
lel__lel•

Most guys have this logic. Which makes the words "your cute/hot/beautiful" very common to a good looking girl. Anything you hear very often will sound boring (sincere or otherwise- normally you can tell insincerity regardless of the words of choice). When your complimented on something unusual it's a novelty which is always charming. Even a girl insincere about her looks will not complain if you tell her she's smart. And if she's never heard that before she'll like that even better.

2
SleepingBoba•

I understand where you're coming from. But I would prefer to be complimented on how I look. I am more confident in my personality than I am in my appearance, so when I get the "you look cute today" type of comments that just makes me a happier me. To know that someone noticed I actually tried.

20
cwearly1cwearly1 sounds hideous. Well cwearly1's a guy, so•

You don't look cute today.
You look cute everyday :D

13
SleepingBoba•
5
HStark•

Wow, it was Emma Stone this whole time! Sometimes being kind to a stranger really pays off

2
[deleted]•

I would try this one, but with my luck I would get cut off before I could finish the second part.

2
Frau_Von_HammersmarkAll I need is Alexander Skarsgård and alcohol•

Yeah I know I am a cool lady. I only sometimes have enough confidence to feel like I am a cute lady.

6
Wlcome2enemyturf•

Yeah that's me too. First off I have been dieting for 6 months, I put 4 hours into my look last night, I spend a half hour contouring my face to perfection... It worked though I got a shit ton of compliments last night, most of them from women! (at least half of which I'm sure were not straight). It was a good night.

2
tealcello•

Either form of compliments is fine, but when it is just appearance-based all the time, that is an unhealthy balance.

I always say that if you don't find me funny or smart I don't want anything to do with you. It raises the chances that you are someone who will stick around and be a genuine friend or lover, instead of dumping me for the next hot girl.

12
shut_up_iris•

Jeffery Dean Morgan... yum.

9
AlphabetSmut•

I watched this gif longer than I should have.....

3
IAmtheHullabaloo•

There's an old joke:

If she's cute, tell her she's smart. If she's smart, tell her she's cute. If she's both, tell her you're rich.

8
FixinThePlanetwith imagination and cogitation•

YAY for getting the compliments you truly desire and that make you feel awesome about yourself!

I like when people tell me I'm fun and they like hanging out with me.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
SugarTits1strong independent troll who don't need no bridge•

Oh god I love this. One of the first compliments my FWB ever gave me was a comment on how interesting I was and it was hands down the best compliment I've ever got.

4
HStark•

Can I ask how old you are? I'm 17, and as someone whose #1 romantic turn-on is a girl smarter than himself... this thread is both confidence-boosting in that it shows girls are out there who like that sort of trait, and frustrating because I don't seem to know many such girls. I wonder if it's something that becomes more important in adulthood?

2
SugarTits1strong independent troll who don't need no bridge•

I'm only 22 so I'm not far off you but yeah I find that girls in college, while still fairly obsessed with their physical appearance, start discovering themselves as more than just looks. I've grown to really appreciate my personality. I'm completely confident in myself as a person and I love that, which is why I love getting complimented on my personality: of course I love getting complimented on my looks but I still get offended if a guy who doesn't know me tries to tell me I'm hot assuming that I'll fall on my knees straight away as a result.

To answer your question: yes, most girls seem to grow to love who they are as a person rather than what they look like. My parents, and everyone in a healthy adult relationship will tell you that looks only matter while you're young. As you mature it'll be more about personality.

What would you rather? To spend your life with someone who's interesting but unattractive or someone who's attractive but in interesting? Most people choose the latter while they're immature and as they mature their answer changes to the first. I even experimented with my friends with this question to see what the mature/immature ones would say.

3
HStark•

Thanks sugartits, this made the thread pretty much nothing but confidence-boosting for me :)

3
digger64•

...veeeerrry interesting. (Sigh. Interesting. Can't stop thinking of that little Nazi spying on everyone on the old TV show Laugh In.)

More seriously, what's even better than discerning compliments: someone who's pretty much always glad to see you in particular. And that's why dogs rule! Of course, it's even nicer when it comes from a person of good judgement.

3
raziphel凸(`△´+)•

I just stalked your profile a bit.

I like how your brain works. :)

3
IAm_ThePumpkinKingI'm cute and unstoppable•

I get called brilliant a lot. I rarely get called 'pretty' or 'cute'. Because I'm not. Well, that's not true I'm downright adorable but I think a lot of people call me 'brilliant' in a surprised way. Because these day's I dress very bright and feminine. I wear cute dresses, bright colors, and lots of poke-a-dots. So I think a lot of people assume I'm ditzy or dumb and when I'm not it throws them off. I got this a lot in a political science class. People(mostly men tbh) where blown away by the blonde in the pink cat dress with purple tights could hold her own in a political debate.

3
GracieBalloonthat's Bitch Goddess to you•

I had a guy tell me he thinks I'm funny and invite me to a party a couple of weeks ago. If I hadn't been at the start of a hellacious weekend working two jobs I would have gone. I'm not sure if he was hitting on me or not, but I wouldn't have minded if he was.

2
Sinnagirl•

I miss Denny.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1