Why don't we see any The Sims clones?
Posted Aug 5, 2014, 1:25 PM UTC
Posted Aug 5, 2014, 1:25 PM UTC
I am always wondering this, as the Sims audience is massive. Simultaneously, there are many people who love the concept who have become progressively pissed off with the direction EA have taken it (the endless, high-priced expansions/stuff packs, endless overpriced DLC, etc) - and I count myself among the peeved.
If you look at places such as Garden of Shadows, you find a huge "alternative" market just waiting for a grimmer, more decayed interpretation of the idea. There are also a host of people who'd like to see a more medieval version of life simulation - many only play in 'medieval hoods' with everything modded to look olde worlde. There is also a market for a more 'adult' version, which Singles failed to really capture (there are whole sites with sex-based or fetish mods). There are still more who mod everything to be 'supernatural', with wings, horns, magic and dragons. Others change everything to look sci-fi. And so on...
So, in answer to your question, I really don't know! I know I'm still waiting after more than a decade for someone to take the base concept and run with it in a more interesting direction, and I know I'm not alone in this.
The only two clones i can think of is the Playboy Mansion and another one i think it was called Singles, both were more adult oriented and came out around the time the first sims was reigning. I don't have a clue why nobody trys it, maybe it's a lot of work to do to have an actual good working game with all the options the sims can offer. The genre although it is successful it must be one of the most hated ones also
It's a lot of work, some of it rather difficult, and in the end you'd end up in the shadow of TheSims the whole time as an also-ran.
Take a look at SimCity. Then look at things like Cities XL. None of them every managed to top SimCity, and are just viewed as second-best. They probably made some money, but it was clearly a clone and there's no fame involved. (And probably a lot of hate mail.)
Devs could expect the same thing of TheSims, and it's probably a lot less fun to create.
Instead, it's better to put all the effort into a game that has more to it, such as Animal Crossing, and have something truly new and novel. You get a lot more attention and the fanbase is happy about what you created, rather than what you lack from the last game of that type they played.
Devs could expect the same thing of TheSims,
But there's tons of unexplored potential.
E.g. there could be a first person play mode where you are one of the Sims and have no control over the others.
There could even be communication with other Sims using symbols like in Captain Blood - to me, the symbols uttered in TheSims 2 and 3 didn't seem entirely random. Or what about natural language processing? If strict syntactic/grammatical rules are applied (almost like in a programming language), something the average Joe Shmoe might not be willing or able to put up with, there could be meaningful communication with other Sims, e.g. about things they have observed or experienced, and it wouldn't be very hard to implement (because of the restrictions).
There could also be exploration of physical and mental abuse - and of their opposite extremes. With simulation of the effects on those Sims, e.g. psychoses.
The Sims, to me, seemed to rather be a doll game, because if you'd actually let a Sim act freely, they'd just oscillate between TV/Computer/Videogame, toilet/shower, and bed, and maybe work. So, you'd decide for your Sim(s) and only let them reign freely a bit from time to time, at least that's from my game experience.
While TheSims 2/3 were well done from a technical perspective (graphics, 3D models, and especially the house editor), they had just been toy games, and players would purchase more and more content just to see what happens when situation X happens or how the money tree *works - no depth at all, just like most games where you need more content for more experience. A real sim game would keep providing you with new experiences with the same set of content.
But there's tons of unexplored potential. E.g. there could be a first person play mode where you are one of the Sims and have no control over the others.
TheSims for consoles. Or did you mean just as an addon to the clone? Might be fun, but it's hardly enough to overcome the stigma of being a clone.
There could even be communication with other Sims using symbols like in Captain Blood[1] - to me, the symbols uttered in TheSims 2 and 3 didn't seem entirely random. Or what about natural language processing? If strict syntactic/grammatical rules are applied (almost like in a programming language), something the average Joe Shmoe might not be willing or able to put up with, there could be meaningful communication with other Sims, e.g. about things they have observed or experienced, and it wouldn't be very hard to implement (because of the restrictions).
AI Communication? That's too tough, and it adds too little value.
There could also be exploration of physical and mental abuse - and of their opposite extremes. With simulation of the effects on those Sims, e.g. psychoses.
I wouldn't even know how to begin modeling something that intricate. Either it would end up half-assed and pointless, or so time-consuming and expensive that it would be impractical. And it wouldn't sell.
A real sim game would keep providing you with new experiences with the same set of content.
Well that's where "sim" comes into play. It's a scaled-down version of a real life situation. They can't implement everything because of budget and time constraints.
I'm not saying there aren't features that could be implemented. I'm saying that to get to the point that you could implement them is rather expensive and time-consuming, and cloning complex games has never been a good market strategy. They clone small, easy games because they can do it quickly and cheaply.
there could be a first person play mode where you are one of the Sims and have no control over the others.
Might be fun, but it's hardly enough to overcome the stigma of being a clone.
?? At this point it barely sounds like a clone at all. It sounds like a first person game about people and relationships. Something akin to [Facade](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fa%C3%A7ade_(interactive_story\)).
Then it doesn't fit this topic at all. I was assuming the gameplay remained largely the same, except for the changes stated: First-person view, and only control 1 sim.
If the gameplay changes considerably, it fails to answer the question the original poster had.
I can't see how this is any different from Wow and all it's challengers.
Userbase? Expected income? Monthly recurring income? Piracy?
It's all about money.
The Sims brand name basicly sells the game. Any clone would get a "but its just sims" reaction. Saying that however I do predict we are going to get a rise in the "Controlling people" game genre, with Banished and Dwarf Fortress being a large success I think its just a matter of time until more people being making variations on a theme.
The same can be said about the WoW, but that doesn't keep other companies from trying to compete.
I'm currently working on a game that draws some elements from the Sims. But I think the main thing that would keep me from making a clone would be the amount of content needed; furniture, animation, clothes, etc., it doesn't leave much on the programming side and it makes up a big part of the Sims games.
If done right this can be overcome with a very mod-friendly design. If you can manage to cultivate a Minecraft-like modding community, you'll have more content than all sims expansions combined.
The sims has a modding community too.
I'd settle for a deeply simulated text variant. I mean text-adventure text, not Dwarf Fortress text.
Good question. Maybe there is a disconnect between people who like to play The Sims, and people who are actually indiedev's? I'd imagine that you'd need overlap in those 2 categories to even have a fighting chance at someone taking on that project.
I personally don't like the genre... I'd never try to clone it.
I'm the overlap, however when I think about what kind of games would be successful Sims aren't the first things that come to mind. Now if I thought about a cool never done before Sim game I would be all over that like white on rice.