r/asoiaf•
Beigenoise

(Spoilers All) On what Mel sees

ALL

Mel comments that when she looks into the fire for AA, that all she sees is "Snow". We've taken for a reference to Jon, but what if she really means literal snow?

Mayhaps the only time she looks for AA is when Jon is warged as Ghost. Even if you're looking very closely, a white wolf would be quite hard to spot amidst only white snow. Perhaps she doesn't see that she is seeing Ghost?

Posted Aug 11, 2014, 2:30 PM UTC

14
tgun06Two Gods - No Mercy•

This also right after she is looking for a vision of AA, and sees a vision of Jon Snow. I recently reread ADWD and was surprised by how much this line is pushed because right before we have her actually see Jon Snow when she asks to see Azor Ahai. The line is a good sum up, but it is about what just happened earlier in the chapter. I don't have the book to quote but she is looking in the fires and asks to see AA, because she wants to know how Stannis is doing, instead she sees Jon Snow with danger all around him.

2
SculleryWenchScouring my way through the crackpots...•

Or maybe Rhallor is demanding that Jon be sacrificed as a price for revealing AA. King's blood and whatnot.

2
cra68•

She means Jon because the word is capitalized. She may not know it conciously but subconciously, she has switched from Stannis to Jon. Her visions are obsessed with him and she repeatedly claims Jon is important, she must get closer to him.

1
TwoBonesJonesAnd the Lord said, "Let there be hype"•

I think the fact that the "Snow" is capitalized is indicative of Jon.

Pair the with "a man, then a wolf, then a man again" makes a lot of people pretty convinced that she is indeed seeing Jon, and not actual physical snow.

1