ITX - ASRock Z97E vs ASUS Maximus VI Impact

I am looking at the AsRock Z97E-ITX/AC motherboard comparing it's features & price over the Asus Maximus VI Impact.

As I understand it, they are almost neck and neck for performance and features. Except the ASRock motherboard includes SATA Express support and higher quality 12k Platinum Caps (Asus uses 10K black Caps), while the Asus appears to have a slight edge in audio (ASRock uses the TI NE5532 amp vs Asus who uses the better TI LM4562 amp).

Overall it would appear (on paper at least) that the AsRock Z97E-ITX/AC has similar or better features and costs roughly $98 USD cheaper ($118.49 after mail-in-rebates). Maybe I'm just missing something. Is there anything about the Asus Impact motherboard that helps justify the extra $100?

Asus Maximus VI Impact Mini-ITX (Z87E) gaming board from ROG. $229.49 + $3.99 @ Newegg

Impact Power

  • 60A "BlackWing" Gold-treated CPU Choke

  • 10K "BlackWing" Caps (Nichicon GT Series)

  • powIRstage MOSFETS

SupremeFX Impact

  • TI LM4562 Amp

  • Realtek ALC1150

  • ENLA audio caps (Japanese)

  • DTS Connect

  • Sonic Radar

mPCIe ComboII

  • Intel LAN

  • Broadcom 802.11ac

  • Bluetooth 4.0

  • M.2 Socket 2

Other

  • USB Charger+ (for iPhones/iPads)

  • Q-Code, Direct Key, and MemOK!

  • ROG EXT Connector (for ROS Connect)

ASRock Z97E-ITX/ac $134.99 + $20.00 rebate = $114.99 @ Newegg

Power Delivery

  • 60A CPU Choke

  • "Premium Alloy" Choke

  • 12K "Platinum" Caps

  • Dual-Stack MOSFET for CPU Vcore

  • "Digi Power VRM Design" (???) for CPU

  • NexFET MOSET for DRAM slots

  • 15KV ESD Protection

Audio

  • TI NE5532 Amplifer

  • Realtek ALC1150

  • Nichicon "Fine Gold Series" audio Caps (Japanese)

  • DTS Connect

Other

  • 15u gold DIMM, VGA, and PCIe contacts

  • M.2 SATA3 / M.2 PCI Express socket on rear of motherboard

  • HDMI-In (bypass only; capturing not supported)

  • "High Density" PCB

  • Dehumidifier (Fan powers on after going into S4/S5 state)

Internet

  • Intel Gigabit LAN

  • Qualcomm/Atheros 2T2R 802.11ac

Posted Aug 12, 2014, 7:27 PM UTC · edited

16
-blind•

the main difference between the two is power effeciency where the Z97E-iTX is 20% more effiecent, against performance where the Asus is about 10% faster. What justifies the price of the Asus is that it is basically a micro-ATX board compacted into a mini ITX format(more overclocking options that way AFAIK, never used one).

2
Reloader45ACPOP•

Thank you for your detailed reply and linking to source material. Very much appreciated. I was not aware of the power draw differences. This helps a lot.

1
-blind•

My pleasure, been looking at these exact parts for my build too :)

1
Reloader45ACPOP•

And for context, here is the build I'm planning on doing...

PCPartPicker part list / Price breakdown by merchant

TypeItemPrice
CPUIntel Core i7-4790K 4.0GHz Quad-Core Processor$279.99 @ Micro Center
CPU CoolerCorsair H100i 77.0 CFM Liquid CPU Cooler$94.99 @ Amazon
MotherboardASRock Z97E-ITX/ac Mini ITX LGA1150 Motherboard$134.99 @ Newegg
MemoryG.Skill Ripjaws X Series 16GB (2 x 8GB) DDR3-1866 Memory$149.99 @ Newegg
StorageSamsung 850 Pro Series 256GB 2.5" Solid State Drive$189.99 @ Micro Center
Video CardMSI Radeon R9 280X 3GB TWIN FROZR Video Card$294.99 @ Amazon
CaseCorsair 250D Mini ITX Tower Case$84.98 @ OutletPC
Power SupplySeaSonic 660W 80+ Platinum Certified Fully-Modular ATX Power Supply$141.97 @ OutletPC
Optical DriveLG UH12NS30 Blu-Ray Reader, DVD/CD Writer$49.98 @ OutletPC
Case FanBitFenix Spectre Pro 148.7 CFM 200mm Fan$16.67 @ Amazon
Case FanLogisys LT400PL 21.7 CFM 80mm Fan$6.99 @ Amazon
Case FanCorsair SP120 57.2 CFM 120mm Fan$14.99 @ Newegg
Case FanCorsair SP120 57.2 CFM 120mm Fan$14.99 @ Newegg
Total
Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available$1475.51
Generated by PCPartPicker 2014-08-12 15:42 EDT-0400
1
Reloader45ACPOP•

Last night I bit the bullet and ordered all the above parts, minus the ram. I ended up going with cheaper PNY memory. I will not be overclocking the memory and I just don't feel I'll see the speed difference from value ram to premium ram with the applications that I'll be running.

I also opted to buy everything at Amazon and signed up for the Amazon Visa credit card, which gave me an instant $70 credit towards my purchase. With these savings I was able to upgrade the SSD to a Samsung 850 Pro 512GB drive.

1
Reloader45ACPOP•

In case any one else is reviewing these boards, it's worth knowing that Asus has announced their Asus Maximus VII Impact Z97 motherboard. They improved the audio amp, power delivery, and a few other things. It's not official for sale as of this posting which is why I didn't do a breakdown.

I ended up settling on the ASRock board since I only plan on doing minimum overclocking on the CPU. I personally value stability and energy efficiency more then raw power. And being a $100 cheaper just sealed the deal.

1